It really is a bit of comparing apples and oranges. Top Liberal arts college and education vs a large public university in a metro area with excellent undergraduate business program. Yes, you can get excellent career opportunities in business out of Williams ( brand is excellent) but I think it is also true that the scale/depth of West coast specific marketing and consulting opportunities may be more plentiful and easier to access out of Haas. Are you interested in a liberal arts education (econ, finance, stats) or are you more energized about taking more pre-professional marketing and corporate strategy classes?