University of Rochester vs. Iowa State vs. U of M Duluth for engineering major

Hey guys,
I am in need of some help here. I am currently attending my last semester at a community college and I am planning to transfer to a four-year school in this fall with a major in Chemical Engineering. As of now, I have been accepted to these schools: University of Rochester, Iowa State University, U of M Duluth. It is almost impossible for me to attend ISU because of the high out-of-state tuition. I am from MN, by the way.

I am debating whether I should accept the admission offer from RU or from the U of M Duluth. Below are some of the reasons that can influence my decision and I would appreciate any comments/suggestions.

UR pros: More prestigious than U of M Duluth. Might have more/better on-campus recruitments. Might be more generous in terms of financial aid (I haven’t received a financial aid package yet). I like the location better.

UR cons: My only main concern about RU, which is actually why I decided to start this thread, is that I don’t want to be in an environment where I will be below average in terms of academics. I mean… without any exaggeration, I am a really hard-working person when it comes to doing my school work, even if that means doing nothing on the weekends and breaks but school work. However, I realize that most of the students at RU are quite talented. I truly enjoy challenging myself but that precludes if I have to struggle to keep up with my studies.
By the time I transfer, I will have pretty much all my lower level classes completed so I will start the upper-level engineering courses at wherever I wind up transferring to. I am doing fine in my current college and my schedule is quite heavy loaded. I am taking O Chem 2, O Chem 2 lab, multivariable Calc, and Calculus-based Physics 2 with its lab and I am handling this ‘ok’. My schedule for last semester was the same as this one except it was the lower courses.
So I guess my point is, I am not sure if I will be able to handle the work at UR. What I am sure of, though, is that I will work hard to the best of my ability.

U of M Duluth pros: Student-body might not be as competitive, which means I might do well in academics. In-state tuition (more on this later).

U of M Duluth cons: future job placement might not be as good as that of UR. Although I am an in-state student, I would still have to take out more than $10,000 in student loans. The location is good but not as appealing to me.

On another note, what is the student atmosphere at UR like? is it super competitive or more collaborative? How hard is it to get a one-to-one attention from the professors/advisors there?

Your input is much appreciated.

Again, these are just my thoughts and are open to critics.

You will find a lot of very capable students at UR, but it is definitely not a cut-throat competitive environment. From what I’ve witnessed (secondhand), the dominant student culture is very collaborative. In fact, that’s something that I think they pride themselves on.

UR would not have admitted you if they didn’t think you could do the work.
They have lots more applicants than they can admit, they wouldn’t admit one whom they’re iffy about.
As for loans, there’s a possibility it’s be similar in cost to UMN Duluth., in which case I’d choose UR.
Post back once you get your financial aid package.
And congratulations! :slight_smile:

I’ve known one engineer from UM Duluth; I was favorably impressed.

Would probably recommend Duluth to my own kid under these conditions.

The magic words are ABET certified. Save your money, study hard, and remember that nearly every company in the US has a url called "careers.(company name here) .com - even those that don’t recruit on campus.

@EllieMom It is awesome to hear that. That gravitates me towards UR even more.

@MYOS1634 excellent reasoning. As for my financial aid package, I will definitely post back. I will probably comment on this thread, then. My EFC is zero so… that might become a whole different issue as I will not be able to pay a lot (if any) out of pocket.

@50N40W Thank you for the suggestion. UMN Duluth is one of my top options, and like you said, it is a good school.

Thank you all. I appreciate everyone’s great ideas.

Besides, Lake Superior. What an opportunity, geographically. That really is a unique body of water.