Hi everyone! Before jumping in, I will preface with some information about me. I play the Tenor Trombone, and plan on studying Music Education in order to become a Band Director. I plan on attending graduate school, and the end goal would be to teach Trombone at a college or University. I have been accepted into both universities already, and the overall division maker for me is the cost of attendance vs quality of music department.
Now some information on the Universities:
At TAMUC I have been offered a full ride scholarship (Tuition + RB + Books) through their honors college. The music department, specifically the Trombone Studio, is nothing to laugh at or overlook. They focus strongly on music ed within the department, and I’m quite familiar with the University.
UNT is my dream college, admissions into their trombone studio is fairly difficult, and I always considered it to be a reach. I recently received my acceptance letter into the music department and it’s causing me to have second thoughts. UNT’s Music Department is among the best in the Nation, and in the music world holds a level of prestige. Things to note here are that i’ve been offered an 8,000/yr Academic scholarship, with Music scholarships being released April 1st (though I wouldn’t count on any).
So there lies the question(s), Is the difference is quality of the schools enough to justify throwing away a full ride offer? Since I plan on attending graduate school, is the prestige/quality of my undergrad really that important?
Thanks for reading, any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Congratulations on your scholarship and admissions!! I must admit, I live in Texas and I didn’t know what TAMUC was. I had to look it up. UNT has a an incredible reputation, Keep in mind I am just a random person on the internet but I do have three musician kids, FWIW, who plan to continue in college. Can you talk to your band director or private teacher for advice?
PS - there is also a music major forum, I suggest posting there.
You mean Texas A&M- Commerce, right?
UNT definitely has a good rep for all things music based. Commerce is solid too.
Does the Commerce deal come with any special perks like a study abroad fund or a special honors college cohort group?
You should focus on and meet the trombone teachers. Which teacher do you like the best? You have to progress and play concerts a lot to get into graduate school. What are the ensembles like at each school? Do you need to audition? Will you make it into the ensembles at UNT? It seems to me UNT is your pick if you are a serious musician who wants to be a professional musician. You mention teaching but do you want to be a professional musician as well? Most teachers here play for an ensemble, so you can do that, as a high school or college teacher and make more money as you can get payed to play for ensembles. Most college level music jobs may not pay enough to make a living so you will need to also keep a private studio in that case, maybe. Eventually getting to be a band director, will pay more! Good luck.
UNT is known for music, is in a better location, and has a better reputation overall. You should go there if you can afford it.
“UNT is known for music, is in a better location, and has a better reputation overall. You should go there if you can afford it.”
This and only this. TAMUC is known for producing teachers. UNT has a much better music program and has a better location. Finances would be the only reason I would select TAMUC over UNT. If you can financially afford UNT it should be the choice.