<p>“I definitely don’t agree with those who say that she is in an easy major, and probably did not even put in a minimal effort. What?”</p>
<p>That would be yours truly, but apparently I didn’t articulate what I meant clearly enough. </p>
<p>I have no way of knowing how hard she tried. But if she tried and got those grades, there’s a problem somewhere. The truth is that it’s pretty darn hard to get grades that bad in college these days–especially a top tier college. At least it is for a kid who has always been a good student and had a high ACT, who attends classes regularly and studies. And if the D’s major is communications, it’s unlikely she’s taking organic chem and multivariable calc. And if she was only taking 3 courses when the norm is 4, then the problem isn’t that she overloaded herself first quarter either. </p>
<p>Maybe like the person one of the other posters described, she has a learning disability. One of my closest friends got a D first semester of college in French. It later turned out that she has a hearing loss which had never been diagnosed. She lip read her way through life WITHOUT KNOWING that was what she was doing. In college, the oral part of the French exam was given using head phones. She honestly didn’t realize that the reason she couldn’t understand what the recordings said was because while she could hear some sounds, she couldn’t hear well enough to get the words and, for obvious reasons, she couldn’t lip read. My friend could have studied French 24/7 and it would not have helped. She would have had exactly the same problem if she had been given oral exams in English through a head set. </p>
<p>My D has a friend who came to her the night before he took his SATs. He had bombed the verbal portion of his PSATs-- a score well below 500. He hadn’t studied at all for the SAT, and was really bummed out the night before it. So, he asked my kid–who is good at standardized tests–for help. She asked him to show her his PSAT report. He hadn’t bothered to look at anything other than the score. She looked at it and told him that it was obvious that he actually knew the material. He got almost every question he answered correct. But, he didn’t answer very many questions. Because she knows him well, she knows he’s a slower reader. She told him cramming that night wasn’t going to help. However, the next day, he should skip all of the reading comprehension problems and go through the rest of the exam. Only after he had finished the rest of the verbal section should he try to do the reading comprehension section. That way, he would finish more of the test. He followed her advice and broke 600.</p>
<p>More importantly, he recognized that the fact that he was a slow reader was a problem he had to deal with. He went to a Sylvan learning center. He took a diagnostic test and learned that he was a REALLY slow reader. So, the summer before college, he took a reading course and upped his speed by more than 100 words a minute. </p>
<p>He is eternally grateful because when the heavier reading load of college hit, he was prepared. He may not have made it through college if he had still been a slow reader. Fortunately for him, he figured out what he needed to do BEFORE he started college and avoided a catastrophe. </p>
<p>I think the OP has to help her D figure out what the real problem is. I don’t think the girl has done that, based on what her mom is saying. </p>
<p>I don’t think arriving at school the day before classes began is why this kid had a problem–and that seems to be her explanation. Something else is going on–the D has a learning disability, the D has a hearing or vision problem that wasn’t an issue in a small classroom but is in a large auditorium, the D is suffering from depression, the D was so homesick she couldn’t function, SOMETHING. </p>
<p>Throwing the OP’s daughter back into the deep end without figuring out what the problem is seems to me like a pretty good way to guarantee she drowns. If a kid says I “partied too hearty and now I know I can’t do that,” and I felt that was sincere, I’d send the kid back to school in a heart beat.</p>