Oh, defintely not excusing Duke! Hate Greek life generally no matter what school is on their sweatshirts. Just don’t know much about frats at Duke, having no experience with them, so that’s why I didn’t mention it by name in an earlier post. Honestly not concerned about Greek life, I know how to avoid it, and almost every school I applied to has Greek life in some way shape or form. Those articles are particularly disgusting though. Not really digging the elitist social life at Duke nor the fact that my participation in it is dependent upon my looks @suzy100
What is it that you like about Duke besides the name recognition and the accolades from your peers?
We visited Duke twice. Both times my daughter did not like it… but she kept it on her list because it’s …Duke. When it came time to write her “Why Duke” essay… she was stumped. She could not answer the question because she did not like the school. She promptly dropped it from her list. Great school… but not for her. She also expected to love it… surprise!!
One of the first things you mentioned were all the congrats on Snapchat.
Once you begin college… you will no longer be congratulated for your acceptance. You will be congratulated because of your accomplishments.
Don’t base your decision on inter*net articles that characterize a school, threads on CC that bash a school, or opinions of people that you don’t know (in other words, everyone here). All very top schools have highly competitive clubs. And USC has a line of clubs (including the business fraternity) that are hard to get in, +=8—and greek social life that are pretty much reserved for southern money. It has a reputation as a “party” school. And it lives up to that reputation during football season. I imagine the same thing goes on at Duke.
If your parents won’t cosign more than $40k in loans, you are going to have to choose USC, McGill, or Miami/Oxford. The latter of which would get you away from the southern region for which you seemingly have little affinity. Unfortunately, I don’t think USC allows you to take a gap year and preserve TS status. I actually think a gap year might help you focus and sort out priorities.
http://www.thestate.com/news/local/education/article33067959.html
http://www.thestate.com/news/local/education/article118724218.html
Let’s be fair. Its not just Duke that has problems.
Here is an overall snapshot.
@lesjubilants have you given any thought to McGill? A lot of very strong students from our HS attend McGill and seem to like it very much.
@twogirls Yes, I gave it a lot of thought especially after I got the scholarship. Ultimately I ruled it out because:
-They have really strict curves that make it difficult to get a good GPA for grad school
-There’s not much academic support. You’re really on your own and if you’re struggling it’s hard to seek help. They don’t have dorms after freshman year and class are huge.
-Honestly, the weather. I’m really partial towards the warm and sunny and know I’d be miserable and would never step foot outside my dorm haha
I have a daughter that is a current junior at USC in the Honor’s College (not Top Scholar) and she loves the program. Even without being a Top Scholar, she has had tons of advantages over the average student due to the Honor’s College. Her advising is top notch, the ability to change between the different programs has been seamless (she went from Arts & Sciences to Darla Moore with no problem), and she feels like she is a member of a small program, with all of the big college feel as well. She has had many classes with less than 10 students and with the priority registration she has had no problem getting the classes she wants. She has also had amazing internship opportunities and will actually have a prestigious internship with a top bank this summer. Telling them that you are a member of the top ranked honor’s college does have significant pull. Yes, greek life is very prominent, but that does not mean that you have to be involved. Being from the South, that is something that she felt like she would like to do, and she tried it, and it was not for her. She is still doing fabulous even without being involved. On the flip side, my current daughter is leaning heavily towards going to Duke herself. Financially, Duke will actually be cheaper than USC for us. It’s one of the few times that being solidly middle class helps. Duke is an amazing school with amazing opportunities (she is really looking forward the Duke Engage program and spending a summer fully funded doing outreach and community service) and dependent on what you ultimately want to do career wise could be a fit.
I find it funny that no one has mentioned the Duke porn star. If you aren’t familiar with the story, google it.
She also was going after prestige with her college selection. I haven’t read through all of your posts, but I have concluded from what was said here, that her family’s financial situation was better off than yours. She quickly realized after her freshman year at Duke that her accruing debt was stiffling. Her simple and immature solution was to make porn movies a couple weekends a year and graduate debt free. All would have gone well if she hadn’t been outed by one of her classmates. She surely didn’t have good things to say about her fellow Duke students after the outing, but always seemed self-righteous about her financial decision. She has managed to stay under the news radar since graduating. I wonder what her advice to you would be.
One more article to recommend @lesjubilants. Google “A Prudent College Path” by Frank Bruni in the NY Times. It’s about the student who picked Alabama Honors over Ivy League options. The article is what you’d expect, but the comments offer additional insight in the opposite direction (i.e., pick prestige). Not sure this will help with a decision but it might prepare you for either path. Good luck.
One more article to recommend @lesjubilants. Google “A Prudent College Path” by Frank Bruni in the NY Times. It’s about the student who picked Alabama Honors over Ivy League options. The article is what you’d expect, but the comments offer additional insight in the opposite direction (i.e., pick prestige). Not sure this will help with a decision but it might prepare you for either path. Good luck.
I showed this thread to my child who is also accepted to the USC Honors program. Their comment was “ This is one person that absolutely makes me NOT want to go to USC. “
@lesjubilants can’t afford Duke… Just like many other students. She can either take the offer to USC or Miami Ohio, or take a gap year to figure it out. I don’t see any other options .
@annie4321 I’m not really sure what the purpose of your comment was other than to be mean?
@lesjubilants, it may sound mean but your obsession with prestige is evident and is off-putting. You’ve been given so much great advice and information here, but it seems like you really don’t want to hear it. You come across as feeling as though you are above South Carolina, so I can understand why another student there would find that off-putting. Can you understand that?
It’s never ok to make broad generalizations… You made several demeaning/insulting remarks about USC and it’s students, the most offensive being about the “not so smart” non honors students. @ Suzy100 hit the nail on the head when she stated that people find it off putting that you believe South Carolina is beneath you and are only attending for the money. If you do end up attending USC, how would you feel if your fellow students/peers read these threads and figured out it was you? Are these things you would say to them in person?
@lesjubilants last summer my D was chosen for a selective research position. She worked alongside students from Duke and Hopkins… as well as students from “regular” schools such as Rutgers and Oklahoma. Nobody cared where their peers went to school… they were all invited to the program and they were all on the same playing field. They all hung out together.
My D received a full tuition scholarship to a strong public university. She interviewed for room/board and came out of the interview very humbled. She told me that she had just spoken to some of the most accomplished students she had ever met. She ultimately chose another school, but prestige had nothing to do with it. Had she chosen this school, she would have attended with students who turned down schools such as Duke.
Your accomplishments moving forward will help shape your future. You don’t seem to understand that. You seem to be laser focused on school name/prestige in order to receive the accolades of 17 and 18 year olds ( FYI you were offered prestige at USC).
I have no other advice to offer. Four years from now you may be interviewing for jobs… and you will need a solid resume… and the maturity to go with it.
@lesjubilants I think what folks here are asking you do is some reflection on how your comments impact others and ultimately could affect you. I began my first post encouraging you and congratulating you on your impressive successes. I then expressed concern about you statements of "not so smart " kids, kids at USC not having unique and impressive stories, kids at USC not being diverse, the Top Scholars being all homogenous, and statements that they would only chose USC because they couldn’t afford to pay for more elite schools. Every single one of those comments are so offensive. My comments came from a kind and compassionate place. However, that was met then with trashing your school, statements about deep south, and a diatribe about your feelings on Greek. You demonstrated little insight and you were a bit snarky (as you have been on other posts) saying “that is your problem.” I promise you my intentions are good. You are readily identifiable being a top scholar, female, from NJ. Please - stop and think before you type. My hope for you is that you will use the next few months to gain some insight so that you will transition smoothly to the next phase of life. I promise you that the top scholars at USC, the honors kid at USC , etc really don’t care about your past achievements - most of the kids will judge you on how you treat others - and so far, you have some work to do.
@fourparks To me, your comments were hurtful and aggravated, ignoring most of the details of what I said, and intent on exposing my exact identity to a group of strangers. Your intentions seemed rude and callous, particularly in your second reply, which is why they were not well-received. Perhaps they were purposefully so; perhaps they translated poorly over the internet. I know it’s the latter now, but assumed it was the former previously. I do acknowledge that I offended you, even though it was not my intention to, but I was also deeply offended by you and your insistence that I knew nothing about Greek life and even my own high school and classmates. Before your second and third replies I actually started drafting you a PM to apologize, but ultimately didn’t send it for the above reasons. You assumed that my problem (prestige v. money) is unique and a symbol of immaturity–a symbol of immaturity, yes, as I am 17, but certainly not unique. Even if your child did not have this problem, every Top Scholar I speak to is having it, from the girl who got into Yale to the girl who got into Vandy to the ones who got into Dartmouth and Cornell. It’s a testament to your child’s maturity or your parenting style that they didn’t have to consider the US News ranking in their college decision. My statement about Top Scholars only choosing USC because we can’t afford anything else was actually false, I knew this even as I typed it, as I knew on Ivy Day that no matter the results (unless I got into Brown or Duke) I was most likely going to pick USC over the competitiveness, stress, lack of individual opportunity, and relative financial burden of Harvard, Yale, or Penn. I honestly didn’t know that much about Duke before this post, and many commenters have enlightened me to the fact that Duke isn’t the warm and collaborative environment I thought it was and is just as stressful and competitive as the rest of the aforementioned schools. In my original post, I said that I loved USC and was deeply impressed by the older people I met during the weekend; later I said that I gushed about the other seniors I met. That still stands, and that stood through the trainwreck of underexplained, stereotype-driven, and misinterpreted responses. Again, I’m sorry for the possible offenses, know that I didn’t mean them as such. Honestly, I forgot about some of the more interesting stories and backgrounds that I found so cool and that I loved to hear and talk about. When I made this post, I had just finished scrolling through the Duke Facebook group and had read a post by a Syrian refugee who had been admitted to Duke and another who founded a charity for elephants. After another week on the Facebook, I see that those are exceptional people and that really, almost everyone who got into Duke is the same as those in the Honors College. Also, know that this isn’t really me or my personality; just one context, one topic, with weeks of being fed up with parents on CC (and in real life, to be honest), months of college-related stress and desperation, years of pressure, and momentary elitism from the Duke acceptances resulting in the somewhat snippy language and exaggeration.
I’m thankful for all of the advice I received on this thread, I can tell that many of you spent a significant amount of time crafting replies and considering my dilemma. I don’t think that USC is beneath me, although the average SAT score and GPA undeniably are, a bit of a hurdle I had to get over. This is partly an attitude held before I posted, and one developed through reading your comments. I do, however, think that frat boys who drug girls are beneath me (Not all frat boys!! Not only at USC!!) and I think I’m perfectly entitled to that opinion. Would I be considering USC if I wasn’t a Top Scholar? Probably. Would I be considering USC if I wasn’t in the Honors College, if I didn’t get money? No, and I think I’m entitled to that a little too. That being said, I cannot afford Duke, love USC and the opportunities to travel, maintain my silly hobbies, and develop a small community that it affords me, and have a near-zero chance of getting off the waitlist and receiving sufficient financial aid at Brown, so I will be attending USC in the fall. I don’t know what I’ll major in, and I know you guys said to major in what I love, good advice but will also probably result in me with a philosophy degree and angry parents haha. Again, sorry, and again, thank you.
@lesjubilants my D attends a strong flagship university. She was also a very high stats HS kid. She has friends from all over the world and volunteers weekly with refugees. Her friends from the US and abroad DO have cool stories to tell… not all do of course, but many. As for her own opportunities… they are the same ( often more) as her friends attending Ivy League schools. Are there some students at this school with lower SAT scores than she had? Yes, of course. Does it matter at all? Does it impact her ability to take difficult classes, engage in class discussion, etc? No …of course not. Are the classe somehow watered down or too easy? Nope. She does very well, but she studies and works hard. And guess what? There is something to be learned by everybody’s life experiences… Including those who may have gotten a few points lower on the ACT ( in the scheme of life this does not mean much). The experiences of some of her friends have shown her what exists outside of her sheltered HS bubble.
Does she have cool discussions on Friday nights while she and her friends cook dinner together and hang out? Yes she does.
Have you read the book Where You Go Is Not Who You’ll Be by Frank Bruni? My daughter read it in HS and recommended it. Attending USC will open your eyes… favorably… and provide you with experiences that you did not think were possible.
Good luck! Come back after your first semester and tell us about your cool research ( you can do research in any major).
Thank you for the apology and I apologize as well. I am not trying to be mean or callous. I am trying to get you to just pause before you write things that can start your college experience off on the wrong foot. You are the one who has posted so much personal information that makes your identity less confidential. I am letting you know that. Please know that I do understand how prestige can be important and that super bright kids want to be with other kids who have a love for learning. And you have worked for that prestige. And you achieved it in so many ways!!! All kids must balance so many myriad issues (major, finance, location, etc) when choosing a college and it is so stressful. I get it. As I said earlier, it is some of your more critical/harsh/judgemental statements that give me pause. But you gracefully apologized and I hope you go to whatever college (sounds like USC) with an open heart, a willingness to listen to other views, a love for learning, and a kindness that draws people to you. I wish you nothing but the best.