UW cs vs. UCLA cs vs. Vanderbilt Engineering Department

I have been directly accepted by the University of Washington’s computer science department, and also by UCLA’s computer science department. I have also been accepted by Vanderbilt University’s Engineering department. I am receiving a fullride to attend both UW and Vanderbilt, but as a non-California resident, I would still have to pay upwards of 30k per year to attend UCLA. These monetary concerns at UCLA are annoying, but my parents would be able to help me pay for tuition. So if you respond to this discussion, there is no need for you to factor the topic of tuition fee in your contribution to the discussion.

My priorities/concerns - here are topics you can discuss

  1. actual level of the schools’ cs departments
  2. future projected income of a cs graduate from each of the schools
  3. ease of finding a job after graduating from each of these departments
  4. the presence of abundant Asian culture (food, people, facilities, etc) (I’m Taiwanese)
  5. the name/prominence of each university and/or department
  6. the helpfulness of the professor’s
  7. difficulty of studying at each school’s cs department
  8. overall student satisfaction and happiness at each department

What are your suggestions? In my shoes, which school would you choose?

Thanks a lot!

Full ride at Washington with direct admission to CS seems like an obvious choice.

First, congratulations on your admissions!

From the UW website: “Computer Science Direct Admission is offered to about 250 freshmen, selected from more than 5,000 candidates.”

These popular “rankings” indicate that Washington has very strong CS and CE departments:

https://www.usnews.com/best-graduate-schools/top-science-schools/computer-science-rankings

https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/rankings/engineering-doctorate-computer

Here are a sampling of articles regarding job placement:

https://www.seattletimes.com/business/technology/job-recruiters-work-to-woo-uw-computer-science-students/

https://www.paysa.com/blog/2017/06/05/top-colleges-in-tech/

https://m.slashdot.org/story/208691

To get an idea of the UW’s abundant Asian culture, see:

http://asc.asuw.org/about/asc-constituents/

In particular, there is a very active and popular Taiwanese Student Association at the UW:

http://www.tsauw.com

http://www.tsauw.com/night-market.html

For the perspectives of some CS students, see:

https://www.quora.com/What-is-it-like-to-be-a-computer-science-major-at-the-University-of-Washington (slightly dated but a lot of good information)

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zyRhnAfLHP0 (a humorous look at a day in the life of two CS students, which great aerial footage of the campus)

With the second CS building (Bill & Melinda Gates Center) scheduled to open in January 2019, it’s a great time to be a CS student at the UW:

https://www.cs.washington.edu/supportcse/cse2/background

https://www.geekwire.com/2017/no-stealing-computer-time-bill-gates-marks-key-milestone-uw-computer-science-expansion/

Good luck!

Agree that full-ride to UW CS direct admit is the obvious choice if you are 100% certain you will major in CS.

All three schools are great. I wouldn’t worry about where their CS departments rank in comparison to each other, because at least in the US, hiring managers won’t make a big distinction. In Asia, I would think UW and UCLA would be better known than Vanderbilt. (I can’t tell if you’re a Taiwanese citizen, or an American citizen of Taiwanese descent. If it’s the former, you’ll need to apply for an H-1B to work in the US, and that’s basically a big lottery that you can’t count on winning.)

When you say you got accepted to Vanderbilt Engineering, does that mean you got accepted into their CS program? If there’s a question about being accepted into CS there, I’d go with the sure thing at UCLA or UW.

Obviously there’s more Asian culture in LA and Seattle. My wife is from Taiwan. Our daughter lives in, and went to school just outside of, Nashville. Everyone in our family loves Nashville, so I don’t think the fact that there’s less Asian influence in the city will be an issue. We lived in Seattle for 2 1/2 years, and couldn’t handle the constant cold drizzle. My wife likes LA. I don’t, even though I went to grad school there.

How much money you make after school will be more influenced by where you work, rather than where you went to school.

It will be logistically easier finding a job if you’re living in Seattle or LA while you’re looking, just because there are lots of tech jobs in those cities. Nashville is less of a tech hub.

My question is how do you get full ride to UW and Vanderbilt? These schools are not known to give full ride scholarships.

@bogeyorpar: Probably fin aid.

@simba9, switching majors at a mid-sized private like Vandy should be easy.