Valparaiso vs. RIT

My son (International student) has been selected in several Universities, but currently is looking at these two, but finding it hard to make a decision. He is planning to major in Mechanical Engineering. Appreciate comments from parents on these two options.

What are this criteria?
Valparaiso will be smaller. It’s more isolated but you can get to a big city.
RIT is in a big city but the city itself has had economic setbacks that don’t make it too desirable.
Both will be cold.
RIT has co-ops.
Valparaiso has Christian values and is very supportive.
They’re both very different and would appeal to different kids.

Congratulations on narrowing your search to two schools. The schools are very strong schools and have very similar rankings. Forbes has Valpo ranked a little higher. USNWR puts the two schools in separate categories, but ball parking them, I’d say they have RIT ranked a little higher. So, to my mind, it comes down to which would be the best fit for your son. Here are a few things I’d consider (all data from Forbes and USNWR college rankings):

–Both have 16% international students, so no difference there

–Both will be cold, Rochester probably a little colder, but not much difference

–RIT is very slightly more diverse (56% v. 61% white), with most of the difference being a larger # of Asian students, but not much difference here

–There is a big difference in size; I believe 12,000 undergrads (16,000 total) at RIT and 3500 undergrads (4500 total) at Valpo. My university had 4500 undergrads. I found it a good size for me. It was big enough that I did not know everyone by the end of the first year, but small enough that I very often knew people everywhere I went.

–There is a big difference in gender balance: Valpo has a similar number of men and women; RIT is fully 2/3 male. This can have a big impact on social life, not a good or bad difference, just a difference. Which do you think, in general, would be a better environment for you son?

–There is some difference in the number of students who live on campus. USNWR says that’s 63% for Valpo and 52% at RIT. Keep in mind that a higher % will be on campus freshman year, so that higher % will be factored into the total, meaning the difference would be larger, especially for junior and senior years. I do remember large parking lots around RIT, so it is a bit more of a commuter school, it appears. More students come to campus for class, so a lower % in the dorms and around campus in the evenings. It can be easier to develop close friendships, etc. when students are learning AND living together.

–Valpo is affiliated with the Lutheran Church. At some religiously affiliated schools in the US, there can be a strong tie between the church and the school. However, at many of them, the religious affiliation does not really have much or any impact on student culture. A higher % from that denomination will probably be students at a religiously affiliated school than at a non-religious schools, but there are very often no religious requirements for students, other than sometimes taking a religious class or two, which most often can be about any religious faith, or some other aspect of religion, not about the specific religion of the school. For example, a Catholic university may require students to take one religion class, but it can be about Islam, Buddhism, or another religion. I don’t know anything about the culture at Valpo, so I can’t say how it is there, though I would guess it is on the lower impact side.

So, I would not be concerned about making a mistake in terms of rankings, reputation, or quality of education. They are both quality schools, and any difference is not dramatic. There are some pretty large differences in terms of size, gender balance, and commuter/residential balance. So your son might think about some of these factors in terms of making a successful transition to the US and a college community, and in choosing a place where he will live for most of four years. Good luck!

Thank you very much for your inputs, my son has finally made a decision to choose RIT mainly because of its strong Co op program.

Thank you for the update! Congratulations to your son!

Congratulations! RIT has great programs. I wish him a happy, productive four years.