What are your intellectual interests and academic goals besides sports? Start there.
Is the “guaranteed recruit” school a place you’d want to be if you were injured and couldn’t compete for a semester? Is the overall vibe and culture at Princeton something that appeals to you- presumably as a legacy you know something about the place? It’s fantastic if it’s a fit for you- it could be less fantastic if it’s not a fit.
Surely there are other criteria and considerations at play besides the athletic piece, right? Do you see yourself WANTING to compete for four more years or do you want to pivot to explore other things- political, musical, artistic, volunteer, etc?