Want to be software developer? Think twice before you go by US News Rankings!

<p>I am interested in entering software development, more specifically I want to enter the interactive entertainment industry (graphics/AI/gameplay programmer). As I was choosing a university from the list of acceptances (which ranged from state schools to top privates), I decided to e-mail Tim Sweeney, the CEO and technical director of Epic Games, the wildly successful development studio responsible for the Unreal and Gears of War series of games, about the value of “top” schools for software development. The response may shock you: </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Then, to supplement this, I asked ** John Carmack ** of id Software (the guys behind DOOM, Quake, etc – the guys who invented modern video games), a similar question and got a similar reply: </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Draw what conclusions that you will. But it seems for tech industry jobs, your educational background is not anywhere near as important as what you can do and what you’ve accomplished extracurricularly in your intended field. </p>

<p>-Arachnotron</p>

<p>what do you expect them to say? No. We dont hire you unless you go to harvard! ?
seriously… try getting a gig at google from Fresno State, then try from Caltech. See which one’s easier</p>

<p>First of all, those comments are from the gaming industry. I think they put more stock in creative side-projects than academic merit, per se. Their opinions may not be applicable to software development as a whole.</p>

<p>Second, I also agree that their responses are somewhat typical, in that they wouldn’t come out and say that they wouldn’t hire someone from an average-but-not-great school. I think that given the choice between Podunk U. and Carnegie Mellon, ceteris paribus, we all know who’s getting the job.</p>

<p>I do think it’s true that most state schools have respectable enough programs that you’re going to get a great CS / SE education no matter where you go. I also think that what you do beyong the regular curriculum will help you stand out. But college is about academics at the end of the day; the stronger the academics, and the better your grades, the better that will reflect on you.</p>

<p>I don’t go to a great school for CS, per se, but I’ve found that there’s far more to learn about CS / SE here than I could pick up in a decade, let alone in a 4-year bachelor’s program. Good students will get a lot out of it wherever they go, and I can only hope that counts for something in the end.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I could not have said this better myself. People say that “top” universities have more “opportunity”, but I dare you to find someone who has exhausted every single class at a (good) state university. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>For an entry level position, maybe. But I’m pretty sure a guy from any good state university who has substantial programming experience (either from previous jobs or from independent/open source projects) is going to get the job over the straight A student from CalTech who has done nothing but programming assignments in school. </p>

<p>The assumption “given all else is equal” can’t really hold in this sort of work. If you have two candidates who can do the job well, I don’t think something as trivial as the university they went to (for a non-entry level job – rarely do these jobs require substantial qualifications) would seal the deal.</p>

<p>^
The thing is that usually, the guys who hire at the top things are more than likely to be from top schools and might show some preference to those students (perhaps they obtained the job through the alumni network?). Indeed, the alumni network of Podunk U. will not exactly help you get any job while MIT will get you jobs just by name alone. </p>

<p>More opportunities come from a bigger (and better) alumni network as well as more research opportunities.</p>

<p>This might be the case in the game industry but that’s not the software engineering industry as a whole. Take a look at where Google & Microsoft recruit. (I’m not suggesting that they recruit at top schools, just that it’s a good place to take a look if you want to find out how much this kind of thing matters.)</p>

<p>A different perspective, from outside the game industry - I can’t say that I agree with all of Joel Splosky’s opinions here, but it’s another data point. And yes, it’s about sorting resumes rather than hiring, but you do have to get someone to take your resume seriously before you get an interview.</p>

<p>[Sorting</a> Resumes - Joel on Software](<a href=“http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/SortingResumes.html]Sorting”>Sorting Resumes – Joel on Software)</p>

<p>I do think that it’s true that obsessing about going to, say, the school with the #40 ranked CS program, vs the one with the #50 ranked CS program, is misplaced.</p>

<p>No John Romero? Maybe he’s too busy working on his cell phone games.</p>

<p>Anyway, one of my buddies in undergrad (Carnegie Mellon) was offered a spot at Suckerpunch Studios; the guys behind the Sly Cooper games. We were both pretty sure it was because he’s had a few pet projects (along with a friend he wrote a Wetrix clone when they couldn’t get ahold of a copy anywhere) as well as some other things. He was also a Computer Engineer, and not the more targeted CS program, so I’m sure it had more to do with the stuff he did for fun than necessarily for the school. Though, to be fair, he did meet them through the school’s career fair, so I guess that’s more directed targeting than you’d get at most large publics.</p>

<p>(And, as a note, Suckerpunch is run from a bunch of guys that left MS to develop games prior to the X-Box being released, so that might explain their favoritism towards a big-name CS school.)</p>

<p>Does anyone else ever find Joel a little pretentious?</p>

<p>What else would one expect from someone who went to Yale for CS…</p>

<p>"I could not have said this better myself. People say that “top” universities have more “opportunity”, but I dare you to find someone who has exhausted every single class at a (good) state university. "</p>

<p>it generally isn’t about the classes you can take. better schools tend to have better alumni networks, better connections to industry, a better reputation with companies. schools that send a lot of students to top companies tend to get a good reputation with those companies.</p>

<p>That’s likely very true. It’s not really what you know, but who you know, that determines a lot of how successful you’re going to be. Better schools make it easier to meet better people, and knowing better people makes getting in with them easier.</p>

<p>Regarding Google:</p>

<p>*For the most part, it takes a degree from an Ivy League school, or MIT, Stanford, CalTech, or Carnegie Mellon–America’s top engineering schools–even to get invited to interview. Brin and Page still keep a hand in all the hiring, from executives to administrative assistants. And to them, work experience counts far less than where you went to school, how you did on your SATs, and your grade-point average. “If you’ve been at Cisco for 20 years, they don’t want you,” says an employee. *</p>

<p>[Can</a> Google Grow Up? Google is one of the best things to happen to the Net. So will its IPO, expected this spring, be a must-buy? A look inside reveals a talented company facing trouble. - December 8, 2003](<a href=“http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/2003/12/08/355116/index.htm]Can”>Can Google Grow Up? Google is one of the best things to happen to the Net. So will its IPO, expected this spring, be a must-buy? A look inside reveals a talented company facing trouble. - December 8, 2003)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Ah, but what about the not-so-good universities, whether state or private? </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>The key presumption here is that you really would be spending $250k to go to Harvard, yet that’s a price generally paid only by the rich who probably don’t care about costs anyway. On the other hand, for many people, Harvard’s ridiculously generous financial aid system means that many students actually pay less than they would to a own state school. As a case in point, I know 2 guys who grew up dreaming of studying at their state flagship school, but found out upon the receipt of aid packets that Harvard would actually be cheaper for them, given the state school’s unimpressive package. I will always remember one of them acidly joking that his family was too poor to afford state school, so he had “no choice” but to go to Harvard. The same can be said for other top private schools. Stanford waives tuition for anybody whose family makes less than $100k, and waves tuition and room/board for anybody whose family makes less than $60k, and on a loan-free basis as well (although students still commit to work-study). How many state schools can say the same? Nor will most state schools be able to match that sort of largesse anytime soon.</p>

<p>So for now at least, a student whose family earns $90,000 would have to pay as little as $4,500 to go to Harvard but would get little to no financial aid to help cover Berkeley’s annual cost of $25,000.</p>

<p>[The</a> New Battle over Financial Aid - Class Is in Session - TIME](<a href=“http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1838709_1838713_1838722,00.html]The”>http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1838709_1838713_1838722,00.html)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>If you do indeed have two candidates who you know can perform equally well on the job, then you truly don’t have to rely on the school brand name. The key question is: how do you know? Rarely if ever do you really know whether somebody can do the job well. Brand names are a way of economizing on search costs. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>But of course this whole discussion is based on the premise that somebody truly wants a programming job, yet the (sad) fact is, many top engineering/CS students don’t seem to want that. They’d rather be tech strategy consultants, fund managers, or venture capitalists. Something like half of all MIT undergrads who enter the workforce end up taking not direct technical jobs, but rather jobs in consulting or finance, and even those who head to graduate school will also often times later end up in consulting or finance. Those guys figure, why be the coder for a game company when you can be the venture capitalist who determines which game company to invest in?</p>

<p>That’s the response I would like to hear. Even though I do attend a decent university, I probably wouldn’t want to work for a company who solely wants ivy league grads and won’t even look at an applicant who didn’t attend an ivy league college.</p>

<p>I think I’ve got this notion into my mind from working at my internship which is a CS recruiting firm for larger companies. Every once in awhile, I’ll snoop through open positions and see a company specifically ask the firm for ivy league grads only despite qualifications, experience, etc. And from judging on the specifications they’ve provided, it doesn’t seem like these companies want ivy grads because they believe they’re better suited or have more skills…but just want the school’s name. </p>

<p>If I had the option to be picky about where I worked, I would probably avoid those companies. Something about them just seem a little grimy to me. I’d rather someone hire me because I had the experience, qualifications, knowledge, etc. than only because I attended x-school.</p>

<p>I don’t have a problem with companies requiring Ivy League graduates… I do think they should come out and say this, though, so as to not waste people’s time. Letting people who have no shot at the job apply is rude.</p>

<p>Most jobs aren’t like this, though. There are plenty of jobs for CS/SE graduates, even if some places won’t hire you based on where you went to school. I’m certainly not worried in the slightest.</p>

<p>A related thread:</p>

<p><a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/graduate-school/214816-google-microsoft-software-engineer-salary.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/graduate-school/214816-google-microsoft-software-engineer-salary.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>

</p>

<p>Yes.</p>

<p>However, I’ve come across a lot of people in the software world who take his hiring-related advice seriously.</p>

<p>these are some of the highest paying software developer or computer science related job…
note the “IVIES/TOP GRADS ONLY” remarks</p>

<p>compensation: 150k-250k
[C++</a> Developer Jobs, USA](<a href=“http://jobs.efinancialcareers.com/job-4000000000525608.htm/keywordAny=ivy/]C++”>http://jobs.efinancialcareers.com/job-4000000000525608.htm/keywordAny=ivy/)</p>

<p>[High</a> Frequency Developer - C++/Java - HEDGE FUND Jobs, USA](<a href=“http://jobs.efinancialcareers.com/job-4000000000529049.htm/keywordAny=ivy/]High”>http://jobs.efinancialcareers.com/job-4000000000529049.htm/keywordAny=ivy/)
“ivy league education” (Again similar algo trading developer jobs typically pay 200k+)</p>

<p>DE Shaw Senior Programmers get paid in the range of 300k+
Guess what? They only recruit at ivies and the very top engineering schools… too bad for the Idaho State Computer scientist.</p>

<p>The most exclusive, lucrative software development jobs ARE in quant funds/hedge funds/investment bank technology division where prestige means everything.</p>

<p>The most exciting software development jobs ARE in the tip top software companies like google, microsoft, amazon where you get to work with the latest technology. Guess where their target recruiting schools are…</p>

<p>There are plenty of exciting and lucrative jobs that don’t recruit onlt Ivies. For those jobs that do… well, I guess the Ivies get those. Good for them.</p>