People sometime seem to think that a college is like a corporation. The Executives are all that are important, while everybody else is a worker who can be replaced.
At a college, presidents come and go, provosts come and go, Deans come and go. None of them hold their positions for more than a few years. The people who are there for decades, the people who make up the REAL part of the college, the people who do the job for which a college exists, are the FACULTY.
Any agreement that ignores the faculty sets a college on the path to losing it’s mission.
Yes, there are colleges which have taken this corporate business model, which is why we have issues like grade super-inflation and disappearing academic standards. That’s the real reason that faculty have become disengaged, why they are losing contact with what’s going on. Faculty are being told to keep the students happy and keep enrollment up, rather than try and educate the students.
Worse, at the same time the administration increases the demand that faculty bring in research money and increase the college’s ranking by publishing. So faculty are told not to care about students other than as a source of income for the college.
Getting rid of unions so that a college can “sell” better is tantamount to saying that the college is nothing more than a for-profit business, whose purpose is students satisfaction, not student education. Faculty are employees who work at the pleasure of the administration, while the entire job of the administration is to make sure that the business is profitable.
Furthermore, getting rid of faculty unions reduces the ability of the college to hire the best faculty. Of course, if Faculty are nothing more than easily replaceable employees whose primary job is to generate profit for the college, then hiring the faculty who are the best teachers and who produce the highest quality research is no longer a goal. The goal is to find the cheapest faculty who can provide the highest satisfaction for the paying costumers at the lowest price.
Bottom line, it’s better to close a college, rather than keep it open, if the price of keeping it open is to make it easier to fire faculty for no real cause.