<p>Here’s something I found online that I’ll paraphrase:</p>
<p>An object rolling on a flat surface will eventually stop due to friction. However, which way does the friction force vector point? If it points in the opposite direction of the rolling direction, it slows down the lateral motion but also speeds up its rotation. If it points in the same direction, it slows down the rotation but also speeds up the lateral motion.</p>
<p>(The answer was posted on the site, but no fair looking :))</p>
<p>If an object is rolling, isn’t the point touching the surface at any time stationary? Then the friction with the surface would be zero. Maybe the friction has something do do with compressions and tensions in the surface.</p>
<p>The point touching the surface is stationary and is the axis of rotation. The forces applied to it do not contribute to rotation. Therefore the rolling friction points to the opposite direction, to slow down the linear motion.</p>
<p>correct me if im wrong but at any point of time only one point of the sphere should be touching the ground.now that one point is not actually moving horizontally with respect to the surface it is actually moving upwards therefore i think friction in this case is downwards preventing that one point from lifting off the surface.
please correct me if im wrong i just passed my 10th grade and tell me if i think like a prospective MITian cuz thats where i wanna go.negative comments accepted.</p>
<p>“The point touching the surface is stationary and is the axis of rotation. The forces applied to it do not contribute to rotation. Therefore the rolling friction points to the opposite direction, to slow down the linear motion”</p>
<p>Actually, that point is only stationary for a moment. A force applied either backward or forward generates a torque since that point is not the center of mass.</p>
<p>“correct me if im wrong but at any point of time only one point of the sphere should be touching the ground”</p>
<p>Ah, there’s the rub. Remember, we aren’t dealing with an ideal case. There’s friction, after all. Now the question is, where does the friction come from? If there were only one point on the object touching the ground, there would be no friction (I think).</p>
<p>please correct me if im wrong i just passed my 10th grade and tell me if i think like a prospective MITian cuz thats where i wanna go.negative comments accepted.</p>
<p>Well, I remember reading about this in HC Verma’s “Concepts of Physics.”
conwoman - the axis of rotation is a diameter of the sphere</p>
<h1>2) jaymerchi - the friction does act in opposite direction to the motion of the sphere as a whole (leftwards if wheel’s moving rightwards), not upwards.</h1>
<p>Actually, there are three forces acting on the wheel or sphere, the weight (downwards from the center of the sphere), the normal force (upwards - i’ll come to it later), and the friction (leftwards, assuming the sphere’s moving rightwards).</p>
<p>But while rolling, both the sphere and the ground deform, so the point of contact is not really an infinitely small point, but an area. Now the front part of this area pushes the ground more strongly than the back part, so the normal force is shifted a little to right. This normal force then creates an anticlockwise torque, and the net torque causes a deceleration.</p>
<p>“A force applied either backward or forward generates a torque since that point is not the center of mass”
“the axis of rotation is a diameter of the sphere”</p>
<p>Actually, any axis can be taken as the axis of rotation, not just the center of mass. For the static equilibrium the sum of torques must be zero and the pivot can be chosen at any point. The rotation at constant speed is a case of equilibrium. Taking the bottom point as an axis makes most sense, cause it eliminates both normal force and friction from the equation.</p>
<p>There is another puzzle on the rolling motion. A spool of thread is lying on its side. The diameter of the wound thread is smaller than the diameter of the spool, and you pull the thread from underneath the spool in the direction parallel to the flat surface. In which direction does the spool move? The force is applied forward, but the torque relative to the center of mass should make the spool move backwards…</p>
<p>“while rolling, both the sphere and the ground deform, so the point of contact is not really an infinitely small point, but an area.” that’s what really happens. I half agree with mercurysquad.</p>
<p>When the object continues to roll(assuming to the right), the original curved surface on the right of that flat contacting area will continue to deform to be a flat area. So there’s another repelling force to make this happen. To the object, it’s upright, and it produces a anti-rolling torque which is bigger than the pro-rolling torque produced by the friction. Because that force is upright, although it may be bigger than the frition, its horizontal component is acctually smaller than the friction, and that’s why the lateral motion slows down.</p>
<p>wy007- you described in detail what i said in one sentence :)</p>
<p>conwoman - yes of course! i missed that (and also, my second post above :D), but i always tend to think of rolling as rotation + linear motion, so i mostly take axis of rotation for a problem as the geometrical axis (or the one most apparent).</p>
<p>“Actually, any axis can be taken as the axis of rotation, not just the center of mass. For the static equilibrium the sum of torques must be zero and the pivot can be chosen at any point. The rotation at constant speed is a case of equilibrium. Taking the bottom point as an axis makes most sense, cause it eliminates both normal force and friction from the equation.”</p>
<p>I think you can only choose your axis in statics. In dynamics, you have to account for everything. I’m not sure though…</p>
<p>There is still one point at which the (average) normal force is applied. It is still more convinient to select the axis at this point to get rid of the unknown forces (normal and friction). Since the pivot point is not the bottom one but is slightly shifted to the direction of movement, the gravitational force creates a counter-clockwise torque to slow down the rotation, and this is the only torque relative to the selected axis. The friction force can have a little torque relative to this pivot point, but it is negligable in comparison to the gravitational torque.</p>
<p>Yep conwoman. If you select that point as the pivot, you get rid of normal force and friction, in which case you use the little (counterclockwise) torque from the sphere’s own weight to explain its slowing. If like me, you pass the axis from the sphere’s center of mass, you end up with the weight having zero torque, but the friction and normal force having non-zero ones. Normal’s (counterclockwise) torque is greater, hence the slowing.</p>
<p>Yep
But if you look at the spool puzzle from my earlier post, it won’t be that easy to explain if you select a pivot point at the center of mass. The spool rotates in the direction in which you are pulling the thread, even though it creates an opposite torque. However if you choose the pivot point at the bottom, everything starts making sense.</p>
<p>The motion of the cylinder requires an upward movement of the point touching the surface, and friction always acts to oppose motion. Thus at that point, the frictional force vector points downwards.
As an aside, frictional forces are independent of surface area, so the whole discussion on whether the thing is a point or an area doesn’t matter at all.</p>