Applying to LSA
28 ACT ( 28 English, 30 math, 27 Reading, 26 Science)
9 honors and APs
3.9 unweighted GPA
Service hours: 200+
Active in 3 clubs for all four years
Played 2 sports all 4 years
Brother Attends now
Out of State : NY
Your scores might be below average but your GPA is definitely above. You have great community service and seem well-rounded. I’d definitely say that you can consider UMich your high reach/low target school.
Your GPA is slightly above the mission average of the past. As the admission status has been going up gradually in the last few years, your GPA would definitely not make you stand out. In contrary, your ACT score of 28 is 2 points below the 25th percentile last year. UMich would be a moderate to high reach for you. Note that high reach is at the other end of spectrum farther away from match.
I would agree with billcsho… Having your brother attending now does help though. Good luck!