I’m a bit uncertain about where I stand compared to other students, as my high school career has been slightly unusual. Starting junior year, I started doing a full time dual degree program at a local community college, because I wanted to experience more diversity than my very homogenous high school had to offer. My high school did offer ap classes, which I did not take because I was a full time dual degree student. I also couldn’t take a fourth year of language, which I know a lot of top colleges look for, because it wasn’t offered at the community college, but I have taken the most rigorous courses I could find. It was a bit hard to connect with teachers in that setting, so I’m not sure what my teacher recs will look like. I have a 3.83 unweighted gpa, 35 on the act (36 E, 35 M, 34 R, 34S), and no sat subject tests because I didn’t know that they existed until very recently. I don’t have any significant awards, but I have some interesting ec’s–mountaineering, art, two jobs, captain of the ultimate frisbee team, cross-country, underground music venue volunteering. I will probably submit an art supplement, (I did a pre-college program) which I think will be pretty strong, along with an extra teacher recommendation from that program. I’m interested in studying art,writing, film, and architecture. I’m looking at colleges like vassar, wesleyan, Reed, Oberlin, and Macalaster so far (along with a safety.) If I have any chance at a school like brown or perhaps UChicago, then I would apply ed1, and probably ed2 to Wesleyan. Let me know if it seems like I’m applying to about the right level of competetiveness given my credentials. Thanks!!
Based on your current choices, you might be a good candidate for a few of Kenyon’s overlap schools (as well as Kenyon itself): https://www.kenyon.edu/admissions-aid/admissions-statistics/#companywekeep. Your matches may begin at schools with acceptance rates of about 25% or higher.
Thanks! I’m interested in all those schools, including Kenyon. For a reach school, do you think Brown would be too much of a stretch to even apply for ed1? I also think I’d be a pretty strong interviewer–I realize there’s no way you’d be able to tell–so that might add context to my slightly unusual circumstances
Brown is a quirky place. If your application is excellent, your stats shouldn’t keep you out. If you truly love the school, more then all the others and can afford it, I don’t think you lose much by going ED. But understand that just like everyon elese, your chances are miniscule. The other schools you mentioned are also incredibly difficult to get into. Weslyan and Vassar have very low acceptance rates. You do need some match and safety schools. Take a look at Emmerson and Ithaca for potential safeties or low matches. They are both very strong in your areas of interest. I know many people who are incredibly happy at Ithaca.
Since the students currently attending Brown would appear much like yourself (though without, on average, you exceptional ACT score), I’d encourage you to apply. And why not ED1 since the school obviously appeals to you? If you don’t get in, you can regroup and apply elsewhere. The key might be to consider whether each of your applications would be appropriate, as applications to highly selective colleges generally would seem to be in your case, @CoLeGe2001.
Thanks for the responses! I visited just visited Brown and Wesleyan. I loved both, though the competition for Brown is a bit intimidating. I’m also considering applying to Bowdoin, although I hear it has a more distinct preppy vibe, and has by-and-large less creative-minded students.
If you like Brown and Wesleyan, look into Connecticut College for a somewhat less challenging admit.
@CoLeGe2001 You’re a good candidate…work on how you present your ECs…they sound intriguing…make them tel a story (and let me know if you need a reader on your essay…I read a lot of them around here).
@CoLeGe2001 My son is starting his Junior year at Bowdoin. He is distinctly not preppy. He wears mostly old t-shirts from high school activities or that he picked up at gift shops on trips, and typically keeps wearing them long after they should have been replaced – same with most of his clothes. He, his roommates since Freshman year and a large circle of friends all seem very into arts and creativity. He has a friend who spent the summer writing a draft of a fantasy novel while Bowdoin paid her to do it as a fellowship. I’ve read about the preppy claim here before so I sometimes ask him at breaks and he’s never indicated any sense of that vibe on campus, beyond seeing a lot of Canada Goose coats in the winter.
Hamilton would be worth your consideration for its combination of traditional and creative aspects.
Thanks for all the help! One concern I have for Wesleyan is that I am interested in both film and studio art, which are rumored to be the most rigorous majors there, meaning I might not be able to do both. At a different school (which is, in most ways, just as rigorous) might this be easier because there isn’t as intense a focus on these two programs?
Wesleyan would be great for a combination of film and studio art under most scenarios. However, there appears to be some risk that you could be boxed out of the film major entirely:
Honestly, I’d find the possibility of this to be somewhat dispiriting. As advice to you, though, I don’t think you should be deterred by this single factor.
As you explore your options further, you may also want to, in particular, consider colleges with notably flexible and unrestricted curricula, such as the above-mentioned Hamilton.
I believe Wesleyan has intro film courses which have a grade cut-off for the major. I’d have to put in a lot of effort in these courses, as I’m sure they are quite difficult, but if I want the major badly enough, hopefully it will work out. My understanding is that Wesleyan has no core requirements, but is not completely “open curriculum” like Brown.
With sincere effort and interest you will be fine, both in your application process and through your college education, @CoLeGe2001.