What do you think of this college essay?

<p>Please rate this essay. </p>

<p>Common app essay on failure:</p>

<p>The ringing phone jarred my mind back to reality as I turned from my computer workstation and answered.</p>

<p>“Hello?”</p>

<p>“Hi, Dear,” the young voice on the other end replied.</p>

<p>I stood silently for a moment, unsure how to reply: this was clearly not my mom. Then the voice became familiar to me. It was that of an adult who had stayed in my home for a few months last fall. The troubled woman needed the security of a family. We reluctantly allowed the “intrusion,” counting the days until our disarrayed schedules would return to their comfort zone and the irritating clamour of incessant chatter would cease. I remember so clearly how my mom and I stood at the door as our visitor said her eventual “goodbye”: we looked at one another, sighed deeply, and then remained motionless as we enjoyed the first quiet moment we had in many weeks. Somehow I think that, without a spoken word, we both determined that this sort of “outreach” would not—must not – happen again.</p>

<p>Standing there with the phone to my ear, I opened my mouth to formulate an excuse for rushing off, fearful that somehow this renewed acquaintance would again turn into an unbearable disruption in our lives, but I found myself unable to speak. Instead, my mind instantly went back to another young woman that I saw just three months earlier – a young woman who, in need, reached out to me, and whom I had miserably failed. This earlier young woman worked in a local stationer’s shop, a place that I frequent. At one time, several years ago, we shared a friendly acquaintance, but over time, various events began to drive a silent wedge between us. Eventually, I found myself avoiding her gaze, turning a deaf ear to her complaints and grumbling, and doing as little business in the stationer’s as possible. Then the shocking news came: she had become overwhelmed with the cares of life and succumbed to the desire to end her own.</p>

<p>I sat numbly as Vince Gill’s “Go Rest High…” filled the funeral chapel. I somehow couldn’t manage to take my eyes off of the pale, lifeless form that I earlier could not bring myself to look at in passing. It was as if I were telling myself, “Look! Try to see what you have missed for so many years of indifference! What might you have noticed that could have made a difference in this life? Would it have cost so much to simply smile and speak a friendly word? Would lending a listening ear have been too much for a few moments of time when this one, in so hopeless a state, needed a friend?”</p>

<p>All at once, the guilt, the self-condemnation, and the pain of failure came crashing down upon me, and I determined, amid sobs and sniffles, that I would never again disrespect a human life – however bothersome – by looking the other way. Irritation is often a cry for help, and many times just a caring word is enough to soothe a would-be fatal wound.</p>

<p>Once again trying to pull my thoughts together to respond to my unwelcome phone caller, I decided to listen for a while (in spite of the fear of getting involved again). I even made pleasant small talk. When the conversation drew to a close, I found myself saying, “Hey, thanks for calling me.” And for once, I believe I really meant it!</p>

<p>Unique and I really like it </p>

<p>Good job, I think it’s really well-written!</p>

<p>Well, no matter how unique it is, this essay was rejected by Colgate, Connecticut College, Bates, Colby, Earlham, Gettysburg and Skidmore :slight_smile: </p>

<p>I feel like there may have been other problems with your app, if that’s the case. The essay couldn’t have been that much of a deal breaker. </p>

<p>I think that while the writing was really good, I didn’t learn much if anything about you. Over half of the essay was description of other things beside yourself. I also don’t see how this failure would translate to academics, and there was more written on the failure itself than dealing with the failure. College essays are less about writing and more about showing qualities that colleges want to see, such as perseverance in the case of the failure prompt, which was not covered at all by this essay.</p>

<p>I hope you got into a college you are happy to attend despite the rejections :)</p>

<p>Well-written indeed, apart from a redundance: “incessant chatter would cease”.</p>

<p>Now about the content:</p>

<p>It really sounds forced, and is therefore unconvincing. I fail to see a single genuine quality of yours which is reflected in it. Did you really want to let the adcoms know that the only thing that made you respect other people was someone’s death? Also, you convey subliminally that you were somehow responsible for that person’s death(of course you weren’t, but the suggestion does not help you here), and this obviously has a negative impact on your readers.</p>

<p>I sort of smelt hypocrisy on first reading, and now your comment makes me believe I may have been right. You wrote about your personal “failure”, which is supposed to be the main part of your essay, and therefore more important than that person’s death? Seriously? And you’re even bragging here about how unique it is? </p>

<p>If I were an admission officer, I would feel inclined to plead for your rejection after reading this essay. But I’m only a high school senior, and you can’t be sure that this essay really was the reason for your negative results. I found in your other thread that you’re an international who can pay only 8000$ a year. This really, really hurts your chances at need-aware schools, I’d say especially at smaller ones.</p>

<p>Thank you everyone for your great opinions! :)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>(It’s not redundant, just contradictory.)</p>

<p>Depends on which meaning of “incessant” you see here. I think the intended meaning was “uninterrupted”, not “never-ending”.</p>

<p>It isn’t terrible or anything. But the main point made above is that we learn very little about you. You might have worked on it a bit. But it starts off very boring. It does come off self serving. It is overwritten. Not just ‘guilt’ but ‘guilt, the self-condemnation, and the pain’’ not sobs but sobs and sniffles. Take heart they undoubtedly read worse this season. You tried at least.</p>