What Is The Problem With My Business Ranking

<p>I applied to 12 universities for Fall 2008 for my major: accounting. I got accepted at University of Illinois-Urbana Champaign, Syracuse University (my safety) and got rejected from UTEXAS McComb’s for having too many credit hours.</p>

<p>Can anyone answer the following question with reference to the following table.</p>

<p><a href=“ImageShack - Best place for all of your image hosting and image sharing needs”>ImageShack - Best place for all of your image hosting and image sharing needs;

<p><a href=“1”>b</a> What is the problem with this ranking.</p>

<p>(2) Should I prefer UIUC over Cornell. I want a strong accounting programme and prestige of the school synchronously.</p>

<p>(3) How would you re-rank the universities in that table.</p>

<p>Rankings are the only way I can judge the prestige of a school both overall and business-wise.**</p>

<p>I need BIG HELP!!! Please help me out!!!</p>

<p>Okay–although I don’t exactly agree with your methodology–since trips to the school would be preferable, I guess this is one of the few ways to decide when trips (apparently) are unavailable.</p>

<p>Looking at your methodology, I see a trend here:</p>

<p>Group 1–University of Virginia
Group 2–USC, NYU, UC Berkeley, Cornell, UIUC (Illinois)
Group 3–Washington Univ in St. Louis, Indiana Univ, BYU, Georgetown</p>

<p>Plus you said you applied to 12 schools, were rejected from Texas, and (probably also Wharton), leaving the 10 schools above.</p>

<p>Let’s consider for the moment that any school in one of these groupings is essentially equivalent to the other for purposes of getting an accounting degree, prestige-wise and career-wise.</p>

<p>Now, let’s add three more considerations:</p>

<p>1–Cost to you (Cost minus free financial aid–loans don’t count)
2–Location where you want to live and work (will you be locating near one of these schools, or do you plan to move to New York, Boston, Chicago, or LA upon graduation?)
3–Does rural versus metropolitan matter?</p>

<p>If you don’t mind rural, money doesn’t matter and you plan to move after graduation, then Virginia, UIUC, and Cornell move up the list.</p>

<p>If metropolitan is your thing and you don’t want to move later–but want to be where there are already positions to be had where you can do internships, then USC, NYU, and UC Berkeley should be your choices.</p>

<p>Once you’ve narrowed it down to these two groups (rural versus metro), then consider the pros and cons of each–do you still need to reapply for the business school (you do at Virginia and UC Berkeley, but not at the others). </p>

<p>Do I want a very organized business program that is considered the best program at the school?–it is at Virginia, USC, NYU, and, to a point, at UC Berkeley, but not so much at Cornell and UIUC–which are much more focused on engineering.</p>

<p>Do I want a school with extracurricular athletics–or mostly academics? Obviously, all of these schools but NYU have big athletic programs–while NYU is academic only and has almost nothing in the athletics area.</p>

<p>Do I feel comfortable in a large diverse group of students–or do I need to be in a school that has a large group that is mostly my ethnic background? UC Berkeley is about 70% Asian, USC and NYU and UC Berkeley have more international students than the other schools percentage-wise, and UIUC is mostly white. The largest Hispanic population is at USC. I have no idea which school has the largest black population.</p>

<p>Do I plan to attend this same school for a graduate program?–If so, you should probably attend somewhere near you plan to locate permanently.</p>

<p>I’m sure there are many more questions that can be asked–and upon which you can base your decision. And you may even not like some of the ones I’ve listed above (I’m sure some people might consider me bigoted just for mentioning the one about diversity–and I would encourage people to be open-minded about mixing with other cultures and ethnicities, but I do agree with those who say that students study better where they feel comfortable). </p>

<p>Anyway, best of luck to you with your decision. I’m sure you’ll pick the best place for you after sorting out all the factors.</p>

<p>I think the problem with the list is that you’re applying to numbers on a list rather than judging them on their actual merits and characteristics and that you haven’t even really visited them to see what you really like. Sure it’s important for a school to have a good program for what you want to major in but it’s only as important as how much you’ll enjoy the school.</p>

<p>I don’t want to sound ethnocentric but I am not there for party or to adore the campus (I am not a nerd as well). To me, overal prestige, location and strong major programme holds relative import for me. Coming from NYC, I am kind of cynical about moving to Urbana-Champaign (city of the farms and cows!)</p>

<p>Excellent response, Calcruzer. Well thought out. Thanks for taking the time.</p>

<p>OP, “what Calcruzer said.”</p>

<p>Everyone’s saying you can’t visit, kenien. Is that true? It seems like you’re only really considering UIUC and Syracuse right now. I’d visit UIUC if I possibly could if I were you, before I’d dismiss the location or the school.</p>