What School Should I Attend?

Hey everyone,

TL;DR at the end for those interested. The last of my decisions came out yesterday, and I have narrowed my choice down to two schools, the University of Pittsburgh and RIT. I plan on being a CS major, and while I could potentially change it to something very similar like computer engineering or IS if it would provide me with a better college experience, I’m not interested in doing something completely unrelated to CS.

My main issue with my decision is with Pitt. I toured both campuses, and I absolutely loved Pittsburgh as a city, and I quite liked the campus too. Basically the opposite goes for RIT, in that while I don’t mind the lake effect snow that they have, I found the city of Rochester to be relatively boring and with many fewer opportunities. However, when I visited Pitt for their accepted students day last weekend, there were several red flags. First, when every student was separated into their respective colleges, rather than actually getting to see some of the facilities and services Pitt has to offer, or even better, what an actual class would look and feel like, we had a two-hour long lecture. While this might have been excusable, after the first 30 minutes or so of talking about the school, the presentation seemed to focus on letting us know why we should be interested in tech, which seemed completely unnecessary considering every single student in the room had chosen either CS, IS, or Computational Biology as their major.

The day progressed, and while the rest of the tour went much better than the initial lecture, I still never got to see any of the CS classrooms or anything. So, after the campus tour, I asked my tour guide where the computer science related buildings were, and he told us that the majority of them were in one building, and the rest were in a different building with the IS related spaces. We went to the first building he mentioned, and all we found were two floors that were either office spaces or old looking computer labs. It was a Saturday so no classes were being held, so we got to explore almost every room, and needless to say, I was not impressed. Strike two.

However, I do understand that sometimes a program is good because of the professors rather than the facilities, and since it was a Saturday I could not really sit in on a class or get a first-hand account from the student, although those things probably should have been offered at some point in the day anyways, considering it was an accepted students day.

The final blow came when I went to talk to an admissions counselor about making an appeal for a scholarship. I’ll spare you the details of that conversation, but in short what the person I talked to said, which was confirmed by someone who claimed to be on the scholarship committee, was that apparently the School of Computing and Information had just broken off from another school to become its own entity, and because it was the program’s first year, they could not offer any students in the program any form of scholarship.

To me, that logic was completely backwards. I would think that if they were starting a new program, even though technically they claim that their CS program is one of the oldest in the country, they would want to offer more scholarships than usual to get applicants who otherwise would not attend to go.

At this point, I was very concerned that throughout the entire day there, the only information that I had received about the school of computing and information was that Pitt was unwilling to invest in facilities to accommodate students or the students themselves.

All of that being said, Pitt is still ranked as one of the better computer science schools in the country, at least according to US News and World Report’s best CS programs, where it ranked 49th compared to RIT’s 68th. I am fairly convinced from both my visit and what I have read online that RIT has one of the better programs out there, so what am I missing here? I am giving Pitt the benefit of the doubt because if their program was even close to as good as RIT’s for CS I would go in a heartbeat because of how much more I like Pittsburgh than Rochester, but I am worried about the quality of education I would recieve at Pitt. For additional context, for both schools it will cost me about the same to attend.

TL;DR: I really like Pittsburgh but I’m not sure if I should go to Pitt because I think their CS program might suck, and Rochester isn’t as great but I think RIT’s CS program is pretty good.

Thanks for reading, and if any additional info would help feel free to let me know.

Try Pitt for a year. If the teaching is not good & the facilities are poor, then transfer. Pitt has a very healthy endowment so there is no reason that Pitt should have dated facilities.

Pitt because you love the city & because you are only speculating about the negatives since you visited on a Saturday.

How much would you have to borrow to pay for each of these schools?