What schools should he visit as target schools?

Hi! K is a sophomore and took SL IB MATH year 1 at school, AP Calculus AB through self study and a summer camp with college credit the year before, scored 4. Next year plan to take 4-5 IB HLcourses and the full IB Diploma. He’s taken a few computer courses offering college credit. A stats course underway and is awaiting SAT math subject test scores. What are realistic target schools he should visit in the next year. Thank you.

What is his GPA? Does he have any test scores yet? It is hard to define a “target” without that info.

In addition, does he have any preference for size? What is your home state? Financial situation?

If he is a rising sophomore, it is early to do much visiting. Maybe just hit a few local schools soph year to see how he feels about size & type (large university? LAC? Technical focus?).

Thank you for your response.Currently he has an A in the IB SL (11th grade class) and rest all As except Spanish language in Pre IB HL courses. Not sure what GPA that calculates to. Took SAT ACT to assess areas of strength and weekness and wants to retest in December. We are in TN and willing to support his strongest academic placement of choice financially. Thank you again. Also he is a rising Junior.

What are the test scores he got on first attempts? Financially are you saying you can cover $250,000+ for his undergrad education? Or might you be eligible for need based aid? Those things all affect the types of schools we would recommend.

Any thoughts on school size or possible major? Has he visited anywhere he liked or disliked yet (and do you know what he liked or didn’t like)?

It sounds like your son will have lots of great choices. So have fun with the search and think about it as finding a terrific school that is a good fit for him, as an individual.

Yes, parameters are important. He’s young, his interests might change, so it’s probably hard to nail those down right now. Maybe explore a few schools close to you in TN. Depending where you are, you have UT-Knoxville, Vanderbilt, Belmont, Rhodes College, and many others in the state. Do any of these resonate with him? Does he love the big environment of UT? Does he light up at Rhodes, with it’s smaller, Hogwarts vibe? Make it fun, not a slog, it’s just exploration.

Then think about some basic parameters:

1–Would he like an urban school, with more restaurants, theaters, etc. or a college town, or a small rural campus? There are great schools in all these types of locations. Some students would love one kind and abhor another.

2–Is he the kind of kid that would get lost at a large school? Or would that be just fine? Does he want SEC football? Or would he rather have only 40 students in his freshman chemistry class?

3–Is he a kid who would thrive being far from home? That can be a great way to get a new perspective, see new ways of living. It can also be a challenge for a student to be far from home and friends, even if their fellow students are in the same situation. Could you see him living in LA and going to UCLA? Could you see him at Bates, a terrific LAC in a small town up in Maine?

4–Would he like to leave the South for school? There are lots and lots of great schools in NY/PA/New England and the Upper Midwest. They often have bitterly cold weather. Is that okay for him? Would he get out of bed at a Case Western in Cleveland or at a Dartmouth, in a quaint New England town, and walk to an early morning class on icy walks when it is 10 degrees outside?

5–Would he want to go to a STEM school, where the emphasis is on science, engineering, and math? There are terrific ones–besides the most famous: WPI, Case Western, RPI, RIT, Rose Hulman, etc. That’s great for lots of students, some want to have access to a broader array of classes.

6–FINANCIAL: College costs vary greatly. The whole merit aid/need-based aid setup is very complicated, and depends very much on an individual student and family. For example, say, he got into a Top 30 school without aid, that costs $250k (4 years) v. a somewhat lower ranked school that costs a total of $100k. You might figure out what you’d like to spend per year. Then as you start to find interesting schools, run the net price calculator (NPC), which is available on the websites of all schools to get an idea of how much that school might cost you, to see if it will be affordable. Here’s a link to a very nice, simple chart for Miami of Ohio, just to give an idea how merit aid might be available and might work.

http://miamioh.edu/admission/merit-grid/

The great news is that there are truly many, many outstanding schools out there. Have fun with it!

“there are truly many, many outstanding schools out there.”

Yup. That is the issue. It is hard to narrow it down without more information.

However, you still have time. What we started doing during the summer between sophomore and junior years was visiting schools that were relatively near where we live. Be sure to sign up for a tour. Before our first visit one daughter even said “of course I don’t want to go here, but since it is nearby I am fine with visiting it first to get a sense of what we are looking for”. By a year later (summer between junior and senior year) both daughters knew where they were going to apply. We revisited their top choices after acceptances came in – but you still have time before you get to this point.

We eventually got to visiting a few schools that required an airplane flight (or a two day drive), but not until our daughters had narrowed down their search by a lot. You don’t want to get on an airplane for your first visit and then realize that the school that you are visiting is not even close to appropriate. Both daughters also sat in on a few university classes and got to talk with a professor at a few schools. However, we didn’t do this until after several visits and several tours.

We started off visiting a nearby large university and nearby small school (a well known LAC) which allowed our daughters to get a sense of how they compare. One daughter wanted to visit large schools in a big city (BU and Northeastern) as well as large schools in smaller locations (U.Mass Amherst and UVM and UNH). Again this gave us some sense of the tradeoffs between schools.

I think that you should think hard about the finances. Full pay at many schools can come to something like $280,000 for four years. In the US the majority of students do not graduate in 4 years, so you should make sure that you will not have a disaster if it goes 5 years. Also, for majors other than computer science and engineering, many students are going to need a master’s degree these days, which adds one or two more years to the price. We found very good choices (for near straight-A students) ranging from well under $100,000 total to about $280,000, with the academically strongest school that either daughter got into being the second least expensive. You don’t need to spend $280,000 to go to an academically strong school that will give your child a very good start on their life and their career. Details will however vary enormously between students.

Thank you so much for all the support and advice. His SAT subject test scores for Math posted today and he scored 800. I also spoke to him about his future plans and he is adamant he wants to pursue pre-med. He loves to sing and has made the AllWestTN & All State Choirs. He wants to be able to sing with a pre med track. Does that help narrow school choices to visit and consider? He is a full IB Diploma student and wants to take a few APs through self study. If he scores a couple of 4s is it worth the effort he will put in? Thanks again.

His scores are between 32-35 but he has a slow processing speed yet doesn’t want the extra time label. His earliest evaluations showed markedly slow processing so he started to work harder and made Top10 in middle school Mathcounts Tournament. His intelligence helps him but with the length of the ACT he loses his ability to time. We are trying to use some coffee and carbs to support that. We have counseled him on extra time but he doesn’t want to be different and has started putting in more time prepping and mock testing. His teachers can see the issue but his profound giftedness gives us hope that he will compensate his time management in the more tedious sections like he has in Math. His teachers feel he is academically very strong but time is his challenge. It is his life and end of the day he should be happy with the pace of life he chooses so we are recommending retesting till he is satisfied or gives up. Without timed testing he regularly gets perfect scores telling us he knows his basics. He’s a good kid but sometimes I feel overwhelmed and unable to help him. I am trying to give him options through visiting colleges to find a best fit school. Thank you again. Your time means a lot to me.

URochester might be a good school to look at as a baseline, outside of your own region.

The music opportunities there are phenomenal - even nonmajors can take lessons at Eastman, and there are tons of ensembles and generally a great music culture. It’s also a top-notch place for premed - tons of research and shadowing opportunities through the med school. It’s not dominated by grad students. And it has a very flexible, open-ish curriculum that lends itself to blending interests.

It’s mid-sized and full of extremely bright kids, but is more down-to-earth than the super-elites. It’s in a city that’s big enough to have urban opportunities, culture, etc. but the campus itself doesn’t have an urban feel. It could be very best-of-all-worlds for a student like your son who needs the challenge of a highly-intellectual school with lots of arts to feed the soul, but perhaps slightly kinder and gentler than some of the single-digit-admit-rate schools.

St Olaf may give him merit aid, has a great math program (if he’s interested), strong music opportunities, and is decent for premed. The val from D1’s HS class went there and is a physician now. With merit, you might save some for med school, too, which is very expensive.

He’s doing great. He’s fine if he can achieve those scores without extra time. I’d think that even if they weren’t so high. I speak as someone with a very similar kid–off-the-chart test scores and math ability, processing speed in very normal range but not synced with raw ability, and some subtle learning disabilities.

So as a parent who’s done this, my best advice is to take a deep breath, think about and appreciate what a wonderful kid you have, testing and all that aside. Keep providing him opportunities–and it sounds like you are doing a great job–and just let hm grow and learn. Actually about the biggest things that young people 14-18 can do is to learn about themselves. Who they are? What are they passionate about? What motivates them? Who makes them a better person? When kids are 14, what their peers think is very important to them. Ideally what they think becomes more important. This will have to come from within him. He’ll need to drive the process. The better he can do those things himself, the better he’ll be able to make decisions that are great for him, including choosing a college, and many beyond that. As part of that, I think it is important to think of high school as high school, not pre-college. It’s it’s own thing, and it can be a very challenging one, especially for an intellectual kid. And learning from it, and meeting the challenges, is important to growth.

In terms of schools, I like this example for your son: Case Western Reserve University (CWRU “Crew”) in Cleveland, OH. It’s a mid-size national university and a top STEM school. It has an excellent med school and a research university very immediately adjacent to campus. He would walk past that every day.

Euclid Avenue, a commercial road with lots of restaurants, etc., bisects campus. The Cleveland Orchestra, one of the best in the US, performs at Severance Hall, a beautiful venue on Euclid right next to campus. Students get free and/or subsidized tickets. He could walk to shows from anywhere on campus.

https://www.clevelandorchestra.com

The Cleveland Institute of Music is also adjacent to Case and is a partner.

https://www.cim.edu/aboutcim

So that seems like a real possibility. And then that’s where fit comes in. It has a science nerd vibe, though that certainly doesn’t describe all students. Fraternities are relatively chill. There is the usual alcohol and drug use, though it seems to me there is definitely use of academic performance enhancing drugs. I don’t think anyone can say with confidence precisely how it is relative to other schools. It’s very cold, often under 20 in January and February. It’s urban–near downtown Cleveland (about like Vandy relative to downtown Nashville), which is actually a pretty nice city. It’s in the main cultural district (museums, music halls, etc.), though there are some higher crime areas just a few blocks away from campus. It used to be Case Institute of Technology and Western Reserve College, which were on either side of Euclid. Freshman cross Euclid every day to get to the main academic quad. How would that environment be for him? That’s the big question, the fit. He could pull up and not want to get out of the car. It is a good idea to get out of the car–sometimes we are all pleasantly surprised–but if it doesn’t work for him, that’s okay. Or he could fall in love and spend two years pining to get there.

Personally I loved the college trips as ways for kids (and myself) to see new places and for them to get to learn about themselves. For example, we were at Chicago with my youngest. They felt really intellectually inspired by the whole setting. It made them think that different schools can bring out different sides of a person. They are also very social and thought that Chicago would maybe turn them in more of an intellectual direction and another school might turn them in more of a social direction. (Is ending up taking an intellectual direction, not at Chicago, but another great school.) But what I liked best was that they came up with that on their own. They self-reflected on how they felt about being at Chicago, and it made them think about how a school could affect their development. (I’m not patting myself on the back–parenting is very hard, sometimes I do well and sometimes I wish I’d done better. I do try to learn though.)

So relax, explore. He sounds great, you sound supportive. So trust it will turn out well, and enjoy the experience. It will go by quickly.

Sorry to add to my long-winded post. Just thought later that Oberlin College and Conservatory makes a great contrast with CWRU. It’s a top LAC located about 35 miles west of Cleveland. It also has a very renowned conservatory program. (I’m not sure how things work in terms of, say for example, a math student who also wants to be very involved in music. Schools are separate.) To my mind, if you visited both, you’d have a great look at two schools that might have a lot to offer your son. Maybe one would click more than the other, or maybe both, or maybe neither. but it might be helpful. A student would certainly get outstanding pre-med preparation at either, though they have different strengths. And if you ever visit, check out downtown Cleveland, really an underrated city.

https://www.oberlin.edu

Lawrence University is another LAC with a music conservatory, and there is much more crossover there - both large numbers of double-majors and lots of participation in the “con” by non-majors. Academically it’s particularly strong in the sciences, and it prides itself both on its freshman core (with common reading list to encourage intellectual discourse throughout the entering class) and the prevalence of 1:1 tutorials with faculty.

I would expect schools like Lawrence, Oberlin, and St. Olaf to offer your son a wonderful experience initially. The caveat would be that if he were looking for an accelerated trajectory in a narrow subject area (higher math for example), they wouldn’t have the availability of graduate-level coursework that schools like Rochester and CWRU would provide. But for a broader undergraduate program and solid premed coursework with lots of music, all of them would work fine.

I’m a big fan of Rochester too! Absolutely top-notch university, very competitive, but less so than some hyper-competive bigger names with similar academics. And a potentially great fit for your son.

I second and third the suggestions of checking out Case Western, Lawrence U., and St. Olaf…fit will be very important so definitely visit these very different and excellent programs! Oberlin is FULL of super smart, quirky kids, and I think might be an excellent fit; even the “regular college” kids are much more artsy and musical than at your average LAC (access to the world class Conservatory concerts and students is a huge draw for many musically inclined students who are majoring in non-musical subjects). And the Math program is excellent. There are a lot of high level opportunities for non-Conservatory singers at Oberlin, including the Musical Union (large choir for non-Con students). Several excellent singers audition into the College Choir every year (especially males, sigh), which is really an excellent, intense, professional training choir for Conservatory voice majors. Voice lessons are available to college students either by upper class VP majors in the Conservatory, or by audition for a select few, from Conservatory faculty.