What schools should I aim for as MB/Premed Major? Mean words from college counselor :(

See post #13

I can afford full pay at a private but financial aid would be preferable. No geographic constraints at all and I would like to major in either premedical studies or Bio/Psych. I prefer large cities and bigger schools but if the school program is better, I wouldn’t mind being in the country/smaller schools. I hope this helps!

As previously mentioned, Whitman would be a great pick - they have an excellent record for the sciences.
All the California privates that were cited.

For good city universities where your stats would be competitive and where you might get merit aid look at Drexel, Temple, in Philadelphia, Fordham in NYC and UPitt in Pittsburg. NYU and BU would be reaches and probably won’t offer any merit aid. I will leave it to others to suggest schools in other areas of the country.

University of Alabama Huntsville is one that is often suggested here for high stat students because they give excellent merit aid.

Premedical Studies is rarely a major and not a good one even when it’s offered. Pre-med is a set of courses students take in addition to (or conjunction with) their primary major. You can major in Bio/Psych if you wish, but honestly, anything works, so pick something you like as you’ll enjoy your studies more when it’s something you like. My current med school lad majored in Brain & Cognitive Studies and Bio (double major) and then picked up American Sign Language and Psych as minors.

For schools, yes, look at U Pitt, Case Western, U Rochester, U Miami, U Alabama, and similar schools. Any of these could give you merit aid as well as being larger schools with research opportunities, etc. If you don’t need/want to stay in CA for college, then take the four years to explore somewhere different. Living somewhere else gives one its own type of education about our big, wide, world - more than merely traveling somewhere does. You might want to be sure where you go has relatively easy access to an airport for travel purposes. Two of ours went to schools that did. One didn’t. It definitely made a difference in ease of getting home for breaks!

There is literally nothing about your current record that will be a barrier to ultimately going to med school.

Students with the opposite issue - a very high GPA but low standardized test scores - have a bigger cloud over their heads as potential premeds, because no matter how well they do in college, MCAT scores matter, and a student who struggles with the SAT/ACT is not likely to knock the MCAT out of the park four years later as a matter of course.

Your situation is this: If you want to go to med school, you’re going to need to A) get into a college that will prepare you well, and B ) get significantly better grades at that college than you’ve gotten in high school.

Both A and B are positioned against the UC system as a college destination for you. The fact that your options are open from a financial standpoint means that even more so, you should be looking elsewhere. It’s brutally competitive to get med-school-worthy grades in the UC system. Applying to med school from California colleges, just from a geographic-demographics standpoint, is also brutally competitive. And your counselor is right that with an under-4.0 weighted GPA, your admissions prospects at the UC’s are “meh” anyway.

But meanwhile, there are truly excellent liberal arts colleges that would give you a great premed education in less of a weed-out environment. Your strong scores, combined with strong essays and recommendations, should give you a lot of good options even though your GPA isn’t perfect.

You sound like singing and choral music are important to you. Take a close look at St. Olaf in Minnesota, which is one of the top schools in the country for singers - a large percentage of students there participate in music, such that it permeates the culture of the school in a way that you might love. It’s also very highly regarded in math and sciences, and you could get a top-notch premed education there. If you were to visit and fall in love with the school, their Early Decision acceptance rate is more than double the overall admit rate. You might well get merit aid. (Similar scenario to Whitman, which MYOS described and which would also be a fantastic choice - my mind just went to St. Olaf because of the drop-dead-amazing vocal music there. Their annual holiday concerts are available to watch online if you want to see the quality of music for yourself.)

Lawrence University in Wisconsin is another music-centric LAC (it’s a “university” because of the music conservatory, in which many students double-major or participate as non-majors) that could be a great premed school. Oberlin is another LAC+conservatory, although there’s not as much LAC-conservatory crossover there as at Lawrence.

Both St. Olaf and Lawrence are “Colleges That Change Lives” LAC’s, and there are many others on that list that could be great premed choices and that might well offer you merit scholarships. There’s a tradeoff with some of the more isolated ones, in terms of having access to premed shadowing and research and etc. during the school year, but you can also devote summers to that stuff… or you can look to schools like Rhodes College, which has many opportunities through the nearby St. Jude Research Hospital, or Agnes Scott College (if you’re female) which has cross-registration with Emory University and many opportunities through the medical centers and the CDC in Atlanta.

(Also, in the “if you’re female” vein, schools like Mt. Holyoke, Bryn Mawr, and Scripps are also excellent premed choices, and relatively easier to get into than coed peer schools simply because the applicant pool is smaller.)

Emphasizing again that you do NOT need to be a science major to be premed. In fact, premed music majors have one of the highest rates of med school admissions. Math, social sciences, humanities - whatever you love and can do well in is fine, and in fact often better than blending into the vast oversupply of people who major in biology because they incorrectly assume that they’re supposed to. The med school prereqs are on the order of magnitude of adding a minor to a non-science major - there’s plenty of room in your schedule for them in just about any BA or BS major. (Harder with a heavy-duty BFA or engineering program, although some people still do it.)

Bottom line is that you want to land in the sweet spot of going to a strong and reputable college, but the goal should not be to storm the barricades of a school where you’ll be in the lower half of the stat-pool and have an uphill battle to get top grades. Your test scores attest to your abilities, but you’re going to need to raise the bar GPA-wise in college if you want to go to med school, and there’s no point having to swim upstream to make that happen - go someplace where you’re on the bell curve (not an outlier) but solidly above average. You’re a strong enough applicant that there are plenty of very well-regarded schools in that category for you, so you can then narrow down by desired attributes like music programs, geography, urban-vs-rural, etc. Going to an ULTRA-competitive school does not advantage you in med school admissions, at all - it just makes it harder to stand out. Get to know good schools that are in the zone where the average GPA of admitted students is a little below yours - then your high test scores will make you stand out and likely score you some merit aid, and you’ll be in great shape.

LaSalle is a lesser-mentioned college that is 1) in a big city (Philadelphia) 2) has relatively low tuition for a private, and 3) has a very supportive premed program with an excellent med school placement rate.

Look into Loyola Marymount. I believe they have a lot of support for pre med students.

I second the recommendationof St Olaf for a strong singer who wants to be pre-med (look into Mayo internship, Science Conversation, St Olaf Christmas festival, St Olaf Choir).