So I have a daughter graduating next year and a son graduating in two.
Both are smart, motivated nerds-but average applicants in the selective context. Daughter has 4.0, 1570, many APs, math at college, writes for school/local paper-but nothing crazy. She’s spending the summer hiking, reading, with her friends, with visiting family. No idea what to study-she’s thinking literature/linguistics/anthropology, probably more than one. Son is more oriented-he wants to do law, does internships, clubs, instrument, shadowing. And due to high assets and income, we don’t qualify for any need-based scholarships.
I explain that to frame my question-where are kids like mine going?
Kids who don’t have hooks but are smart and passionate. Kids who are not really wealthy, not first-generation, not an athlete, not Einsteins, not related to faculty or celebrities.
Obviously, there are state flagships. But what I have noticed about my daughter is that she thrives when she’s around people who are smarter than she is and she has to struggle to get ahead (though not to keep up). She is realizing this too. She does well when teachers are good and the expectations are high enough that she doesn’t want to coast. Surely others have similar kids.
So the way I see it there are some tiers of schools:
There must be a tier of schools where unhooked students like her don’t get in. (Maybe one percent would if binding.)
Then there must be a tier of schools where unhooked students like her get in and pay full and students who are hooked get in and get academic scholarships.
Then a tier where unhooked students at her level get in and get academic scholarships and unhooked students a little below her level get in and pay full.
And so on, n+1.
Another dimension is that schools in tier 2 are looking to become tier 1, and tier 3 to become tier 2, etc. So tier 2 is offering scholarships to the hooked kids who get into tier 1 to lure them into coming to them. And tier 3 to the tier 2 admits, etc.
For her, we’re looking at tier 2/3, where the school is made of people who are academically generally at or slightly above her level but where she still can get in and maybe get academic scholarships.
What are those schools? And what should kids like mine keep in mind when they apply?
PS: I know it’s crass to say kids are above or below each other as applicants or as students. But the kids at Husson, the flagship and Bowdoin are different.