Where should I apply?

Bio:
-Citizenship: US
-State of residence: Illinois
-Class: 200k income
-Race: White
-Gender: Male

School:
-Type (Public/private & size): Public. 2500 kids.
-Graduates (How many go to Ivy’s/top 20): Very few people go to Ivy’s/other top colleges.
-AP’s Offered: 13-17 don’t know for sure

Academic Profile:
-Unweighted GPA: 3.85
-Weighted GPA: 4.66
-AP’s: 10 AP Courses. AP Chemistry, AP Physics I, AP Bio, AP English Lang, AP English Lit, AP US History, AP World History, AP Calculus AB, AP Psychology, AP Government. I’ve also taken 4 years of Spanish
-ACT: 32
-SAT: n/a
-SAT II: n/a
-Rank: 5/584
-Course Rigor: Probably taken the most AP courses out of all my classmates

EC (In order of importance/commitment):

  • Baseball all 4 years. Varsity for 3 years
  • Freshman Mentor. Junior and Senior year.
  • Worked a summer job at a restaurant as a cook. I worked probably 40 hours a week.
  • Played on a travel baseball team for 6 years and played summer baseball for my high school
  • Student Athlete Leadership Team

Schools I’m looking at:

  • Northwestern
  • Case Western Reserve

Those are my top two I guess but I need more to apply to

Intended Major: Cognitive Science, Neuroscience, Chemistry?? I don’t know for sure. Also I’ll be Pre-Med.
Intended Minor: Spanish probably

What I’m looking for in a college.

Urban setting. A smaller school. Private. Good sciences and Pre-Med. Good sports would be a plus but aren’t needed. Willing to give financial aid to someone who still makes 200k.