Which ACT score should I send to business schools?

I’m applying to transfer to B-schools, including some competitive ones like NYU Stern and I can’t decide which one to send.
Sept 2016:
Composite: 32
Math:29
Science:31
English:33
Reading:33
Writing:8

Then I re-took it because I thought I could do better in STEM because I’d been taking calculus that semester, but I didn’t have time to study (work FT + school PT) so I managed to do worse on math, but slightly better overall (due to the bump on English & Writing)

Dec 2016:
Composite: 32
Math:28
Science:31
English:35
Reading:33
Writing:9

The reason I’m asking is that I’m applying to get a degree in Finance, and while I got good grades in calculus and statistics, I don’t want my ACT score to let me down. To the ones that superscore I could send both (still a 32 superscored but couldn’t hurt). But for the ones that don’t I don’t want them to think that my quantitative reasoning is sub-par. What are your thoughts?

Nice scores! You are so consistent there is very little difference between the two scores. Your Dec 2016 results are slightly better combined with a slightly better writing score but I doubt it makes much difference. Safe to send both or just Dec. Good luck.

I’m wondering whether my scores are good enough for me to be sending them to test optional schools. Because it’s been 5 years since I graduated, and I have 41 semester units, a lot of colleges aren’t asking for test scores - but I wonder if a 32 composite strengthens my application, is neutral, or perhaps even a detriment depending on the school.

I would argue that if it’s above a target school’s 50th percentile send away - top half of admitted class would a positive.

Most schools don’t have the percentile statistics for transfer students but I suppose I can compare the transfer admit to freshman admit rate, and adjust the 50th percentile approximately dependent on that