Which one is better?

Which set of extracurriculars would you rate higher?

1 :
Varsity soccer 9-12

Red Cross 10-12

Chiropracting volunteer for a few weeks in summer 10

Church welcoming club once a week

Work in the summer 11-12

Summer volunteer camp 9-12 for 1wk, approx 30 volunteer hours

Community based organization for college preparation 9-12

2 :
Writing club 10-12 (editor)

Writing workshop 10-12 won a contest

Volunteer being assistant teacher in a tutor center 10

Work in the summer 11-12

Summer volunteer camp 9-12 for 1wk, approx 30 volunteer hours

Community based organization for college preparation 9-12

Thanks!

Please guys and gals!

Why does this matter? One isn’t necessarily better than the other. Your extracurricular activities should match either what you enjoy doing or exploring potential career options. The difference between these sets of activities is negligible in terms of admissions.

Which do you like better apples or oranges?
They are both perfectly fine but neither set of activities will get you into a school you are not otherwise qualified to attend.

I’m asking because the 2nd set has. A clearer focus while the 1st one is well rounded