<p>Pizzagirl, I know Grinnell is a great school and that’s why I was pointing it out. Yes, there’s Northeast perspective in my comment as it’s the only place I’ve lived, except for when I applied ED to a top LAC in snowy Ohio
and loved it there for 4 years. So I’m an admirer and beneficiary of that experience, not a detractor.</p>
<p>What I meant about Grinnell – and several other Midwest, cold weather fine LAC’s on my mind, such as Oberlin, Carleton – is this. I believe there are top-achieving h.s. students across the country who make lists that sound something like this: prestige Ivies + top LAC’s + State U for safety. And a few more matches/safeties to cushion.</p>
<p>Lists from high scorers on CC often read like this: several universities from HYPSMBCorD…and (sometimes) several LAC’s from here: Grinnell, Claremont/Pomona, Amherst, Williams or Swarthmore… and Homestate University (Honors Program). List further rounded out by a few more safeties, hopefully!</p>
<p>Setting aside finances completely, imagine a student with such a list. Once acceptances roll in, assume there are some acceptances and some rejections. That student if accepted to several of the above would have to Love Grinnell to decline the others for Grinnell. </p>
<p>Why? The Ivies have the word “Ivy” that dazzles perceptions. Among the LAC group I listed, those other LAC’s are ranked higher than Grinnell on USNWR, a popular list that turns heads for some, not all, applicants. Claremont/Pomona beckons with an equivalent LAC experience AND nice California climate. </p>
<p>If the list sounds along those lines, then I feel any student who has a mad crush on the Midwest top LAC on their list, such as Grinnell, Oberlin, or Carleton, should let that crush be known clearly. It’s not an obvious first preference. If it IS, then say so by “showing the love” in the many ways available to students.</p>