<p>“This is the kind of overgeneralization that miffs me. Are there some civil war buffs around? Sure.”</p>
<p>You here reduce the claim of official and public support for institutions that honor Confederate leaders, to an irrelevant claim of the existence of “Civil War buffs”. The existence of Civil War buffs was never an issue. The issue concerns using public money to build money, roads, schools, and other institutions in honor of people who aimed to perpetually dishonor human nature. It is especially heinous because the South uses the very lives of the sort of people it harmed to now fund the memory of those who fought for the right to harm them. Only in an inferior culture could such lunacy thrive. It thrives in the South.</p>
<p>“Aspects of the Southern history may not be a positive part of the US’s history, but it is part of our history, and part of some people’s family history.”</p>
<p>Honor and reverence for human nature would by no means permit an entire culture to compel the public honor of this ‘not positive’ history, using funds that come in part from the very sorts of people the culture once fought to enslave by its own Federal law. In my view, that alone demonstrates the cultural inferiority of the South.</p>
<p>“No one is doing re-enactments of selling slaves in the Charleston market, for petes sake.”</p>
<p>But they are compelling black folk via tax law to support the positive memory of the people who aimed to enslave black folks. Which is even more heinous. I personally would not care if the South did enactments of selling slaves, as long as it did it with private money on private property. But when it compels by use of public funds my honoring those who literally fought to deny my humanity, well, one might imagine that as an American I won’t take this lightly. This is what the South does each and every day. It is culturally inferior because of it. I do not think my saying this is out of line or in poor taste, however difficult it may be for you to handle. I do not attack any person, but instead the culture that permits such hick boorishness to flourish officially, BY LAW, as it now does in the South.</p>
<p>“But why is having some reenactment of southern history any different from Williamsburg? To speak as if this as some organized activity of every resident of the south is just downright insulting, as is drossel’s selective parcing of words and statements from posts that he then uses as a springboard for his own agenda.”</p>
<p>Well, I never said any of this. I do not care anything about re-enactments funded by private citizens. I could not care any less than I now do about it. I care about compelling blacks to pay for honoring people who literally fought for the right to enslave blacks. There is no honor at all in the South’s doing this. It is morally inferior because of it. That is quite a valid and even reasonable position for an American to take. It challenges the premise of this thread.</p>
<p>“Sure he’s been a longtime poster-- and from my recollection he likes to stir the pot and incite emotional reactions. That, poetheart, is a ■■■■■.”</p>
<p>I do not see how I “like” to incite emotional reactions anymore than the OP. He asked a question, and by golly I answered it. If he did not wish to be challenged with an answer, then perhaps he ought not have asked it publicly. I am telling why South bashing is acceptable, depending on the definition of “bashing”. It is acceptable because, even today, the South permits dishonor against human nature to be honored and even compels the very people it once harmed to honor this ridiculous dishonor. That, my dear friend, is cultural inferiority in a nutshell.</p>
<p>“He speaks about “the south” as if it is one congealed glob of earth and humanity, and in insulting terms, addressing stuff from centuries ago as if it was still a current event.”</p>
<p>But of course it is a current event. Lee-Jackson Day exists in Virginia, and since poetsheart is a Virginian, she is compelled to pay for it by Southern law, though both Lee and Jackson fought for the right to enslave people just like her. It is an utter abomination against human dignity. When Virginia’s government forced through its holiday, far from winning any victory, it merely proved its inferior quality and insensitivity toward dignity.</p>
<p>“He talks about being enslaved as if it was going to happen tomorrow.”</p>
<p>I do not. When blacks are forced to pay for their own dishonor by a Southern government, the enslavement already exists.</p>
<p>“Look, there are idiots in the north and idiots in the south. There are bigots in both places, and there were slave owners in both places . But neither have slaves now. Move on already.”</p>
<p>Very well. Let no one compel the public support of his own dishonor, and perhaps we pave the way to move on already. But while the South cries “move on already!” it is in every single southern place I have visited slipping in compelled dishonor. It wants to dishonor blacks, and have the blacks take it with no issue at all. There is no culture in America except Southern culture, that is so inferior, and so blind about human dignity, that such a thing can thrive as it does down there.</p>
<p>“And there are great, wise, cultured people in both areas as well. For him to put down the entire bottom half of the US is bizarre, to say the least.”</p>
<p>I only describe the very real and powerful insults against human decency that take place every single day in the South. They mean little to you because you were never told in official government documents that you were not human. And no one ever died to fight for the right to make sure you were never considered human. It is therefore quite easy for you to whine about ‘moving on’. LOL. The man who is aware of himself, of his place as a fully thinking human being, would be incensed that the honor of another creature of his specie is being treated with such cavalier disdain as that of blacks in the South.</p>
<p>“If he has a personal issue with his past, well I am sorry for him. But to insult everyone who happens to live here, to repeatedly use the word “inferior” at every opportunity is confrontational.”</p>
<p>I disagree. I think asking the question “Why is South bashing acceptable?” and then getting one’s bra turned backwards when one answers it is confrontational. My comments have nothing to do with “everyone who happens to live here”. Poetsheart lives there, and yet I do not insult her. I do not insult you, if you could just calm down and hear the actual point I have made here repeatedly, instead of projecting into this discussion your apparent insecurities about being a neo-southerner.</p>
<p>“He knows it- and so do you. You were just a tad more diplomatic. By his own report he hasn’t lived here in a long time. Things are probably quite different. I am glad he found refuge in the north. I like the north. I am from the north. But I don’t think it or its resources are “superior”…”</p>
<p>Great, friend. This is your opinion about the South. I disagree with it and have given my reasons. That is why these sorts of forums are so great. I have not attacked any person, any race, or any inherent feature of anyone. I have only rejected the abominable culture of a region, and even spelled out exactly why I reject it. In the process, I answered the question “Why is Southern bashing acceptable?”</p>
<p>“This wasn’t a thread about a history lesson. It was a thread about why people feel the need to insult and put down the south. Dross used it (and will no doubt continue to) use it as an opportunity to pour salt into the wound.”</p>
<p>I needed to refer to the history to answered the thread’s question. Apparently you just wished everyone would agree that speaking against the South is wrong. I am explaining why I have the need to put down the South. It is worthy of being put down for all the reasons I have given. That is my opinion. You need not be so touchy about it. It is not as if I have attacked you, your race, or anything like it. I am only attacking the very real and disgusting ills against human dignity that exists in Southern culture. I have explained this, and I think my reasons here are quite valid. This dishonor exists throughout the South and I think it lies at the cause of the South’s inferior culture. Historically, southern culture has suppressed valid human expression virulently, and still does.</p>