Will he or won’t he...

My son got a 35 act score and a 1530 sat score. He never did homework freshman year … resulting in b’s on his transcript. Since then he has gotten all a’s… perfect sat 2 scores, plenty of 4/5 on ap’s… an Eagle Scout, lax, football, pres of mathletes…

His guidance counselor is scaring me about his chances of getting into the colleges on his list… do you think he needs more “safe schools”? Vassar, Villanova, Lafayette, Boston college, Amherst, union college

If there is any debate, you don’t have a safety. My DS with similar stats already has an acceptance in hand with a merit scholarship that makes it affordable.

Union won’t be a reach at all. The rest are all super competitive, but he certainly has a equally strong profile. If these are all RD applications it will be fingers crossed.

Have a couple of less selective matches and safeties (but not less attractive in reality) added to the selection.

He’ll be fine.

Agreed that there should be a true safety on this list as you never know.

None are safeties for anybody, though Union college may be a solid match. The rest have acceptance rates of less than 30% (Amherst is 13%), so none can be considered safeties, and barely matches.

So your kid’s GC is right - he needs a safety.

Union will almost definitely be an acceptance. The probability of him having more acceptances from that list is, imo, high. (Vassar is an easier admit for males.)

With that said, there is a possibility, slight but real, that he ends up without a choice or even less likely, without an acceptance. He might want to throw in one more true safety just in case.

In other words, this list isn’t that risky but it leaves a tiny opening for things to go wrong. Really up to you and him if you are comfortable with that. I would probably say it’s fine, especially if you are full pay and don’t need to worry about affordability. Your GC wants you to close that gap.

Interesting list.

BC, Villanova, Union & Lafayette in one group;

Vassar College & Amherst College in the other.

Does your son intend to play any sport in college ?

Intended major ?

Any further comment on why he is targeting these schools ? (What is he seeking in a college ?)

P.S. He should be admitted to Union & to Vassar College. Any plans to apply ED ? In need of financial aid ?

I think he can get into Union. There are a lot of great schools out there he can get into. Cast a wider net…

I think he has a great chance at all of those schools. His stats are great. What is his overall UW GPA? I would however, add one or two safeties. Maybe Providence College (always seems to be a safety for BC kids), Loyola MD, or Hobart & WS.

My best friend’s son had very similar stats and EC’s last year. They were stunned when he got rejected from Villanova and waitlisted at Trinity (CT). Also waitlisted at Georgetown. But he got into BC, Holy Cross and several other great schools. It really is a bit of a crapshoot with these top schools.

He plays lax and football… would be at a club level

I would hope union is a safety school as both mom and dad are alum

Engineering is a possibility but he is unsure

^ And Union is a wonderful school.

I personally love the idea of a safety/match rolling admissions school, to have “one in the bag” as the other decisions come in. Also do any of the schools on the list have EA? It’s nice to have some decisions in hand in December, in time to add more (due in Jan) if you need to widen the net.

Union is an excellent school and if you have double legacy even better.
I would not lump Amherst in is a safety. Ever. And they are in D 3 Nescac. There isn’t club football. Maybe flag football, but if you son is interested at that level I would not consider him an athlete for either Amherst, Trinity or for Union for that matter. All those schools recruit heavily for Football and lax. HC may be more of a safety.

I think folks here are giving you excellent advice. And @privatebanker is on the money, pardon the pun. :wink:

Amherst is a a reach for almost any applicant, now matter how stellar, given there are lots of smart, excellent, interesting kids applying.

Vassar could be what some call a high match - meaning it’s not a shoe-in. Could also be a reach.

Union would be a safety or a low match.

I might include a place like Connecticut College if you’re looking for a low match or Safety.

Any of the schools in the “Hidden Ivy” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hidden_Ivies category will be competitive and there are always surprises with them come admission time. For example some of the top ones have acceptance rates hovering at 9% - 13%, others, closer to 40%.

Some schools like Bates College quickly went from an 18% admit rate in 2018 to 12% in 2019 because the school got popular and had lots of applications.

You didn’t talk about cost, so I’m assuming you’re either full-pay or you’re not chasing merit aid, since a lot of these schools are more need-based for financial aid.

Does Union offer merit aid?

Some excellent, but less selective schools (in your safety or low match range) might offer some merit aid to a high-stats kid like yours. Like St. Lawrence. Hobart and William Smith College. Muhlenberg, Gettysburg, Dickinson College, Ursinus, etc.

Best of luck. Sounds like you’ve got a great kid there with a bright future ahead of him!

I think your GC is erring on the side of caution, and I think your son would be wise to add at least one more school that falls into the safe category. I wouldn’t describe Union as 100% safe. The rest are reaches for the most part, except Villanova. Probably a good idea to add another match school of genuine interest.

@Theoden Lol. ?

You’re always funny!

OP. Good luck I think it’s now about executing applications the reflect his unique assets and what the school espouses as their preferred characteristics. It’s good to research their online presence to pick up clues.