Will transferring to a "better" school get me a better education?

<p>I’m currently going to UT Dallas, which is a perfectly good school, but its main focus is on science and engineering, and I really want to be an English teacher.They do have an English major, but their main teacher certification program is math/science only. I think they offer teacher certification in other subjects, it’s just that there isn’t as much stuff geared toward that. For instance, they don’t offer Latin, Greek, or Old English, although they have professors qualified to teach in all those areas, because there just isn’t that much demand for them from engineering students with busy schedules.</p>

<p>So, as far as I can see the benefits of transferring would be:

  1. More classes available in my subject area
  2. More challenging classes (admittedly, I’m taking all intro classes right now, but I’m bored out of my mind)
  3. Being more qualified to teach and more all-around educated
  4. Possibly more options to develop extracurricular activities I’m interested in (for instance, I really want to learn a new woodwind instrument, which UTD doesn’t offer, and if not that I’d like to learn to sing, but their program is really for people who already know how to sing. There doesn’t seem to be much on campus for beginners, but I don’t know if that would change at other schools.)</p>

<p>The drawbacks would be:

  1. Money. I’m getting a full ride right now, so I can’t really justify a transfer unless the educational quality is really a lot better. My parents are willing to pay for graduate school right now, too, and that wouldn’t be guaranteed if I wasn’t paying my own way through school. And since I won’t be making a lot of money after graduation, it seems irresponsible to pay too much for school when I don’t have to.
  2. I’m in the honors program here, so I don’t want to transfer unless I can get into the honors program somewhere else or the school is just really, really good for all students.
  3. Because the English department is smaller at UTD, I might get to know my professors better than at a school that emphasized the liberal arts more.
  4. I get stressed easily and might not do as well in a more competitive atmosphere.</p>

<p>So what do you think? If you’ve transferred schools for similar reasons, do you think the transfer was worth it? I’m not looking for “chances” for a specific place, but if you happen to know a school that would be a good fit for me, and since scholarship money and my chances of getting in to other schools are factors in whether or not I should transfer, here are my stats:</p>

<p>HS GPA: 3.79 (almost all pre-AP and AP classes)</p>

<p>College GPA: 4.0 (intro calc (A+), intro psy (A), intro govt (A+), honors intro econ (A); will be taking more honors classes next semester and summer classes in Greek at UT)</p>

<p>HS extracurriculars: flute 9th-10th grade, debate 10th grade (but didn’t really compete), took 5 years of Latin but didn’t join JCL, UIL Literary Criticism 11th-12th grade and my team won state</p>

<p>College extracurriculars: pep band, 1 semester</p>

<p>Test scores: 2400 SAT, 237 PSAT, 4 on AP Chem, US History, and World History; 5 on AP English Lang, English Lit, Latin-Catullus and Ovid, Latin-Virgil. I took 6 more AP classes but only took one test senior year because I felt like I hadn’t learned anything from the classes I’d tested out of the year before.</p>

<p>Essays might be decent; recs would be terrible. My high school recs were good, but my classes are so big that I feel like my professors would really have no interest in getting to know me.</p>

<p>Just a note: your parents usually won’t have to pay for grad school if you go PhD. Those people get stipends :slight_smile: </p>

<p>Also, “Because the English department is smaller at UTD, I might get to know my professors better than at a school that emphasized the liberal arts more.” That right there could be worth more in the long run than you think. Connections, especially after you get your bachelor’s, are essential. You’d be surprised how small academia is! </p>

<p>Good luck! </p>

<p>P.S. Sorry I didn’t answer your question fully, though I think I’m not qualified to respond in an accurate manner.</p>

<p>Actually, that helped a lot =] I was kind of freaking out over the lack of a classics department, but since I’m not planning to major in that anyway, I think I can just take care of that by taking summer classes elsewhere for the stuff UTD doesn’t have. And it might be nice to take some of those upper-division classes with like 6 people in them…it’s probably just that I don’t like it right now because they’re making me take all my core classes immediately. So I think I’ll probably stick it out…</p>

<p>You can also go to grad school to get your certification to teach after you finish a bachelors in English. You might even be able to graduate a year early so you can go to grad school sooner.
It seems like if you continue to do so well where you are and are already in an honors program you’ll be able to go on to a great Grad school. The classes also will get much harder after freshman year and intro levels.</p>

<p>Thanks, I’m hoping so! My professors all seem really nice, and the English professors I’ve met do seem very educated in their subject, so I think I can just take care of my more esoteric interests in summer school or grad school.</p>

<p>I understand your concerns, and before beginning let me say that I really appreciate what you’ve said here. So many people think about transfer admissions because they simply want to go to a higher ranked or more prestigious school that it’s refreshing to see someone who purely cares about the education. Beyond that, I really understand your concerns. Money is always an issue when considering higher education, and getting a full ride is a big deal. Giving it up, particularly if that makes paying for grad school, is thus a very serious consideration. On the whole however, I really think you should transfer for a number of good reasons. </p>

<p>The best reason to transfer is that, from what you say, it really does seem like you can’t fully pursue the education you want at UTD. If UTD is as quantitatively oriented as you say it is, then I really don’t think you’ll be able to get a good education in English. Usually at science and math oriented schools the humanities are a sideshow, and they get very little of the attention and funding that the big programs in math and science get. You’ve already seen this in the relatively limited course selection vis a vis languages, the lack of certification outside of Science and Math, and the small size of the English faculty. </p>

<p>At a less quantitatively focused school by contrast, English and other programs in the humanities won’t be a sideshow. They’ll be major departments with a good breadth of courses offered. It’s true that at many schools the faculty will be larger, but this is a strength not a weakness. While you lose some intimacy with a larger faculty, you gain a greater diversity of minds and opinions, and greater flexibility in a department. The larger faculties are a major reason why these schools can offer so many humanities classes, and I think you’ll find that the heterogeneity and breadth of a large faculty will be just as appealing as the intimacy of a smaller faculty. Additionally, the best minds in the humanities tend not to go to quantitatively focused schools, because they know that they won’t get the attention that the science and math programs get at those schools. Instead, you’ll generally find them at more balanced schools, where they don’t feel sidelined. Finally, you’ll also find lots of other students like you who share your interest in the Humanities. Thus, straight off the bat, one reason to transfer is that the social and institutional situation for you will be better at a less quantitatively focused school than UTD. </p>

<p>Beyond that, the other reason for you to transfer is that you could go to the best schools in the country. While EC’s, professor recommendations, and other holistic factors have a part in the transfer process, transferring is fundamentally a numbers game, and your numbers are fantastic. Your high school GPA is very good, your college grades are outstanding, and your SAT is awesome. You have better chances than almost anyone else I’ve seen on this site of going to Harvard, Yale, or Stanford, not to mention the other Ivies and their peers like Chicago and Duke. I know that may sound hyperbolic, but your college grades and 2400 on the SAT will make any admissions officer sit up and take notice of your application. </p>

<p>Of course, as the title of your post says, does going to these schools mean you’ll get a better education? I believe that it does for two reasons. First, the best minds in the country are at these schools. They pay the best, they’re the most respected institutions in the field, and they offer the brightest students to teach. It’s no accident that many Nobel prize winners are also on the faculty of these schools; the best minds and the best schools really do go hand in hand. If you go to a top school, you’ll thus be able to learn from and interact with the best minds in the world, which is a tremendous advantage. Listening to Chinua Achebe talk about African literature, or Ernesto Zedillo talk about Latin American Politics is a priceless educational experience, a kind that can’t really be replicated in a book and can further only really be found at a top school. </p>

<p>The second reason why going to a top school would give you a better education is that the caliber of student at a top school is higher. Being around very intelligent people does lift up the level of discourse, and innately provides a harder challenge. To match their intellectual efforts, you have to work harder than if you’re simply competing against more average people. It’s also the case that talking to other intelligent people helps you learn. It exposes you to ideas and ways of thought that you generally wouldn’t get if you talk to less intelligent people. Finally, intelligent people tend to take a deeper interest in subjects than less intelligent people. If you want intellectual compatriots who share your interest in literature and can talk about it in depth and with passion, you’ll be more likely to find them among the intelligent students at a top school. Of course not everyone at a top school is intelligent, and there are a depressing number of intellectually lazy or unmotivated people at top schools. Still, a top school will generally have the best classmates to further your education. </p>

<p>Beyond that, I really think it’s also worth considering the practical benefits of going to a top school. Your odds of going to a top graduate program increase significantly if you come from a top school. Grad schools have a great amount of respect for the Ivies and other similar schools, and it’s no accident that many top graduate programs feature a lot of people from those schools. This is partly because they respect the caliber of education from a top school, and partly because they tend to have positive experiences with previous students they took from top schools. This is oversimplifying it of course, but it is nonetheless the case that a degree from an Ivy or similar high quality school will put you in a much better position when you apply to grad schools than a degree from UTD. The alumni network of top schools is tremendously powerful, and can open doors for you in academia, business, government, and other areas of life that would also be closed. It doesn’t hurt to that at a Harvard or Yale or other high quality school, many of the people you go to class with and get to know could one day go on to positions of great esteem and influence. I realize that the educational aspect is your primary reason for transferring, and I applaud that, but it is worth considering the practical aspects of attending an elite school. </p>

<p>I know at points I’ve oversimplified the case, but I do think that the case for you to transfer is nonetheless tremendously strong. I have no doubt you could both make it into an excellent school and significantly improve the quality of your education. I hope this helps, and feel free to contact me if you have any questions, comments or issues about what I’ve said.</p>

<p>Wow…that was really nice. Thanks. I don’t know if I could get into somewhere like Harvard/Yale/Princeton/Stanford, mainly because I don’t know if anyone could get into someplace like that because by all counts admissions are evil and basically select applicants at whim based on the cycle of the moon, but I appreciate the thought. When I was looking at colleges in high school, I really wanted to go to Southwestern University or the University of Chicago. Chicago is like my dream school but they offer no merit-based aid to transfer applicants…and I really liked the honors program at UT but they don’t accept transfer students. And Southwestern’s really expensive, too.</p>

<p>I’m really wishing now that I’d just applied to these places when I was in high school instead of just giving up and only applying to UTD. I was having a really rough time junior and senior year and I pretty much just collapsed and got freaked out at all the applications. When I realized I would have to share a room with a stranger if I went to college, I just decided to give up and go to community college. The only reason I’m going to UTD now is that my dad didn’t feel like driving me all the way there and it’s closer. I didn’t realize how little aid there is for transfer students… I just had so much difficulty concentrating in high school because I got really upset about something that happened in the summer before it started. I mean, it wasn’t exactly a big deal, and I don’t know if it would have upset anybody else besides me because it wasn’t a huge thing like rape or cancer or death or anything, but it was like at first I was just a little more on guard, so I didn’t interact with my band directors or private instructors or the other students as much, and I just didn’t care about it as much as I used to. And then I tried to do debate, and my friend made some harmless joke and it reminded of me what happened and I got so upset that I never went back or did any of the tournaments. It was like one day in junior year I just stopped caring about school. I pretty much went from being an A student to actively ignoring my teachers. My method of studying for AP chem tests was to ask my friend what chapter we were on the night before the test, then read the chapter summary the morning before the exam. I failed European History. Which is pretty sad, considering my teacher gave us two extra credit projects to bring in food and go to an art museum, and that I actually went to an art museum and kept the ticket stub and just didn’t give it to him because I hated talking to people that much. I hate this whole transfer process. It feels like, if you’re having a bad couple of years, you’re pretty much stuck and nothing good will happen to you ever again. Now that I actually want to start doing stuff again, I feel like nobody really wants me anymore.</p>

<p>I really want to go to a school that has an actual English department…and maybe even a classics department…but really I just don’t want to talk to English majors here and hear them complain about how a certain class was hard because the prof “made me use all these literary terms, like ‘alliteration’ and ‘allusion’” or hear my friends from high school talk about how they’re writing essays over the Oresteia or doing projects to learn about the parametrization of curves while I am doing well in an honors economics class and I’m pretty sure I still wouldn’t be able to pass my high school economics final. If it were my money, I’d go for it, but I’m not sure I’d be able to convince my parents to go from paying nothing to paying that much just because if I go to X school I can read Beowulf in the original to prepare me for my job at McDonald’s. My friend got full tuition to UNM just for being a National Merit Semifinalist. Isn’t there something like that for transfer students with good stats? A big state school would at least probably have a classics department and some interesting programs for English majors. I wish I could have gotten great merit aid to somewhere I really want to go, but I’m trying to be practical looking at this from a transfer perspective. I’m not looking for another full ride, but if there’s anything at all or if it’s a school that has a reasonable price tag in the first place, I think it might be easier to convince my parents.</p>

<p>Unfortunately there’s almost no aid for transfer students. The money goes to freshman, they don’t put aside much of anything for transfers. Some schools have small amounts of need aid available but there are no merit scholarships for transfer students. Sorry :/</p>

<p>In response to the subject: yes, i believe that it probably will.</p>