Women still usually change surname on marriage -- why?

@Mom22039 - I certainly agree with your first point and in fact I do even more than this.

I give full names even though I did (patriarchally :wink: - I make fun of myself but I do think it’s because of the patriarchy) take DH’s name, and we all have the same name.

Our surname is common, so often there are other kids in whatever group who share it. So I say, “This is Jane Smith, mother of Bill Smith” lest there be confusion with Bob Smith who is also on the team.

Our estate attorney’s practice mailed draft documents to husband and me addressed to Mr. His-first-name Our-last-name and Mrs. My-first-name Our-last-name. At least I was Mrs. Mary Smith and not Mrs. Bob Smith, but I still found myself offended. I’ll have a word about it. I think Ms. should be the default.

@HouseChatte, that’s coincidental - we should be receiving similar draft documents any day now. I’ll see how the attorney’s practice addresses the envelope and report back!

Fingers crossed your attorney is practicing in this century, Ms. @MaineLonghorn !

At school I - and all of the other married female teachers - go my Mrs. The unmarried female teachers are Ms. I’ve yet to hear a single complaint TBH - not from kids or adults. Once again, I learn something new on this board (that people are offended by it).

I’m pretty sure when we signed up we got to select the title of our choice (as some go by Dr, male and female, if they have the degree for it).

I know kids each year ask what I want to be called. I tell them as long as they don’t use “idiot” or “moron” or any equivalent, it doesn’t matter. They can choose what they like and we’ll get along fine. I let them choose what they want to be called too and work hard to memorize their preferences. Sometimes it’s their name or something related to their name. Other times it’s completely different. The most memorable was a young lad (high schooler) who wanted to be called, “Blueberry.” Fine by me. I wonder if he kept that post graduation
 haven’t heard back from him yet.

@Creekland preferences of others don’t offend me a bit, and “Blueberry” is adorable. Like you, I think everyone’s decision should be used and respected. I guess what bothered me was to have someone not use what I consider to be a more neutral default (Ms. rather than Mrs.) in a business setting.

It never bothered me when people with whom my husband worked used Mrs. They were being polite and professional, I saw my contact with them as based on my being married to him – I actually felt the Mrs. title fit well in the context.

I like both titles, Ms. or Mrs., but lean towards Ms. and have a different comfort zone depending on the circumstances.

I’m just happy when people spell my first name correctly which really isn’t hard at all but most people don’t pay attention and get it wrong. :slight_smile:

@Scipio re: #237 - I don’t live in the biotech world. But I also don’t live in a bubble. A lot of people are still most definitely using Miss and Mrs. And I don’t know a single female teacher in our area that goes by Ms! I’m sure there are some but not any that I know.

Nearly all the female teachers at our school go by “Ms” including me.

My single niece, a 5th grade teacher, goes by Ms. My married sister (not the niece’s mom) is an 8th grade teacher at the same school. She goes by Mrs. I think that is fairly normal in that part of the country.

My uncle got married in the mid '70’s. His wife kept her name. The kids had their dad’s last name. She started teaching Kindegarten in the 80’s and went by Mrs. her last name, the Mrs. to indicate she was married I guess. I asked her once if she used Ms or Mrs and she said Mrs and that it didn’t bother her, so ok whatever.

We have friends who are in their 60’s, each kept their own name when they got married. They hyphenated the names for their kids to moms last name-dad’s last name. (let’s say Smith-Jones) Their son’s girlfriend (last name White) just had a baby. The babies last name is hyphenated to baby’s mom’s last name-daddy’s dad’s (grandpa’s) last name, so the mom’s last name replaced the dad’s mom’s last name (White-Jones).

My D is unmarried and teaches kindergarten and goes by Miss Last Name. When I help in her classroom I am Mrs Last Name. This doesn’t bother my D and it doesn’t bother me.

The only request I have is when a family doesn’t share a family name they not go ballistic when someone makes a mistake. We had a family at our school (and I happened to work with the husband too) and the wife was Ms. X and the husband Mr Y and the kids X-Y. If you called the kids just “the Y kids” or called the mother Ms Y, she had a fit. She’d cross out name tags with a big ugly swipe and write in XXXXX on hers, or if they’d written Mrs. X-Y (like her kids’ name) she’d cross off the Y.

It was really ridiculous. Neither name was common or special, they were just two last names.

My sister doesn’t have the same last name as her husband or kids, but she just politely corrects people and says “Hello, nice to meet you, but my last name is Z.” If someone uses Miss Z or Mrs. Z, she usually just lets it go.

Women have more choices now than they used to, and that’s great. I think feminists should pay attention to the fact that men still don’t have the same choices. It’s still very unusual for a man to change his last name to his wife’s, or to stay home with kids while she works. Girls playing with toy robots are OK and often encouraged, but if a boy plays with dolls, we start thinking about transgender surgery in his future. If the society had moved away from these types of prejudice, we wouldn’t be having these discussions, it would have been just a choice husband and wife both make.

Speaking of married women in schools generally being referred to as “Mrs.” across the board while single teachers are referred to as “Ms.”
is this only true with regards to married teachers who changed their names?

I have always thought that the title Ms. is neutral and can be used with any woman’s name scenario, but that “Mrs.” is ONLY used with the surname of the man a woman marries when she does change her name to his. (i,e, Mrs. denotes the female counterpart of the man who carries that surname.) I had never heard the term “Mrs.” used as a title for a married woman in combination with her unchanged/given surname until I moved here. I always assumed that if a woman is of a mind to keep her name she is also non-traditional enough to not want the title “Mrs.”

So when people called me “Mrs. inthegarden” (especially in school settings) I assumed that either people didn’t know that my husband has a different name, or that people didn’t know (what I assumed to be) the correct usage (Ms. being rarely used at all here) or maybe that people were just uncomfortable using the term Ms. and refused to do it. So it has kind of irked me a little when (usually in schools) people who knew my husband had a different name would still call me “Mrs. inthegarden” though I rarely cared enough to speak up about it. Am I incorrect in assuming this? (Talking about the formal, evolving etiquitte rules of titles, here, not judging whether or not to change a name. Maybe my assumption about this has been wrong!)

@yucca10, on some levels I agree with you (my daughter used to take a lot of ballet and it’s difficult for boys in ballet, for example).

I realize there’s stigma and SOME roadblocks for men to make certain untraditional choices , in some cases more than for women to make untraditional choices, but a man CAN change his name or be a stay-at-home dad. But I think there might be more opportunities for men to be stay-at-home dads if there were fewer glass ceilings for thier wives/female partners. If women were paid the same as men, (and also if traditonally “female” professions were better-paid for men and women both) then more men could be freed from the burden of being the primary wage-earners or to stay in “male” professions.

I believe for every stigma a man currently deals with in the present for making choices usually considered “female”, women have had to suffer social stigmas just as, or more severe in past generations and to persevere through it without economics or law or politics on our side. For generations women were ostracised and punished for being “tomboys”. Women were refused admittance to all kinds of professional schools, but pushed for it anyway. Suffragettes were jeered at and rejected and thrown in jailed and had to go on hunger strikes to be taken seriously. And we still don’t have wage parity or other equal opportunities. So, if men want to lift stigmas and roadblocks well, men should go to work to change things, not just expect things to change magically. Women have never had the option to have things changed for them automatically.

Sorry for all the grammar/spelling mistakes! I don’t write quickly and well without a LOT of editing!

I wonder how much less money and time would have been spent on changeover to Real IDs if everyone simply kept the names they were given at birth.

There is nothing sweeter to my ear than a little girl called me Ms. ‘firstname’ (i feel super respected AND adored). I am pretty casual and most of the time my kids’ friends just called me by my first name. Once in a while a kid would call me Mrs. ‘lastname’, which i also like.

I am 100% sure i got out of a traffic ticket because, not sure what possessed me that day, I kept say this to the woman cop “I am so sorry Ms., I was so confused I messed up. Yes Ms. I am sorry Ms.” The cop was all smiling. I have always called the cop “officer”. I had no idea why that time i didn’t call her “officer”. DH said “she loved you b/c you called her Ms! Why did you call her that anyway?” I had no idea LOL

@inthegarden re: using “Mrs.” only when the woman uses the husband’s surname - this is what I have also believed to be true. Your post is a perfect example of why I wish we would just use Ms. or Mr. It shouldn’t be such a complicated thing!

^This! In most things, I’m all for people just doing what suits them best. I’m all for myriad choices without too many value judgements. In the past, a woman’s marriage status affected every realm of her life so it made sense to convey it with her name. Today, I feel it’s not the general public’s concern; not something to “wear” in public under all circumstances. Somehow men have been able to communicate marital status when they wanted to without it being attached to their names, and surely women can too. I don’t judge other women for choosing the “Mrs” designation but I wish we could just simplyfy things with “Ms.” It seems more private, as well as simpler.