Would You Rather? (Grad School Admit standpoint)

<p>Take a student from a state school (let’s say San Francisco State) with vast experience in his or her profession through internships, or a student from a prestigious school (Stanford) with little experience (yet still present) in his or her profession? Assuming they both have the same grades (Even though the prestigious school is harder)–say a 3.8?</p>

<p>I’m asking this because my friend stressed the importance of the school, whereas I stressed the importance of activity. I felt regardless of the school, experience with the profession plays a large role in getting admitted into grad school. I know both experience and education are factors, but this is assuming that both students received the same high grades in their schools.</p>

<p>depends on what grad school you are talking of, right?</p>

<p>Law school would definitely prefer stanford w/ 3.8 no question.
Med school, i’d say, also would prefer stanford w/ 3.8
Business school, might prefer SF State w/ vast experience
(although, i don’t know. is SF State school comparable to lower UC’s?)</p>

<p>for science/engineering Ph.Ds, you do need alot of experiences (research, publications, etc etc)… so assuming SF State is at least in the same league as lower UC’s… i’d say you might have an edge if Stanford guy only did like one semester worth of research?</p>

<p>I would say the Stanford kid.</p>

<p>It depends on the type of graduate school. I feel like most types would give the nod to the Stanford kid. If the Stanford kid was serious about that type of grad/professional school s/he has better opportunities to improve the resume after graduation. S/he can stay on at school to do research for MD and Phd and has better access to recruiting to get a good job to improve the law school or MBA resume. Grad and professional schools would prefer an exceptional student from an average/low tier school over an average/bad student from a top tier school, but you gave the Stanford kid a 3.8 meaning tons of doors are open to him.</p>

<p>I think you guys are giving the Stanford kid way too much credit.</p>

<p>They went to Stanford for 4 years and all they did was get a 3.8? I’m not trying to belittle that achievement, but what so many great opp. available at the school, I feel like the student should have gotten an internship or something. </p>

<p>-I really do feel that the S.F kid has an advantage. Experience trumps in many situations. It makes them stand out even more in the crowd. </p>

<p>Seeing is how many on this site are college aged or younger, OP, I think a lot of the answers you will get are based on people’s perceptions rather than reality (Mine included-lol!)</p>

<p>Hypothetically, the kid from SFS would win out. But in reality, how many Stanford kids sit around on their asses? </p>

<p>You think you have great professional experiences coming out of SFS, but in reality you probably don’t. It’s sort of “the rich get richer and the poor get poorer”-type scenario. Kids at Stanford with 3.8’s will find it easy to get dream internships. As a SFS student, unless you network like crazy, you won’t even have a chance.</p>

<p>I too think the SFSU kid would get the nod. Certainly for law school, med school and business school, which rely most heavily on GPA and test scores, regardless of the undergrad institution. PhD programs would likely consider the strength of the undergraduate department (not the brand name of the school), but even then the extra SFSU student experiences would count for a lot. Educators make grad school admissions decisions, not staff in admissions offices, and educators care less about where you went to school and more about the educational opportunities you sought and exploited wherever you were.</p>

<p>I go to Stanford but even I would take the SF kid. No experience is a killer these days.</p>

<p>OP said the Stanford kid had some experience. This question has too many gaps in it to properly answer anyway. Obviously if the Stanford kid does 0 but study he’ll have a huge uphill battle with anything after graduation. However, if the Stanford kid has a little experience (say some research during the year or one internship) but did a lot of other random stuff on campus s/he might be very competitive with a SFSU kid with “lots of experience” whatever that means for a 22 year old kid right out of undergrad from a school that probably lacks strong research facilities and recruiting for the best internships.</p>