I think this is good general advice, but just want to say I think it is a little kid/family dynamic dependent. The idea of our kid just giving us her opinion without our input/participation (other than when she absolutely loved or hated the visit) did not work for her. So, we did round robin of thoughts on the school for the google doc with D26 starting. Wife and I would try to start with the most obvious observations. That engagement by us opened her up more than just asking her to share her opinion. That said, our technique would be a disaster with some parents (and some kids). So, my advice is to tailor all of this advice to what would work for your family to get your kid most engaged and most comfortable sharing what they thought.
Precisely why it’s a good idea - especially the food quality - which for many, can/will be an issue.
In the end, if he had a positive experience where he ended up it’s all that matters!!!
Yeah, I don’t think there are many suggestions that should not be trumped by your actual kid’s preferred way of doing things.
I still remember reading CC diligently back when my son was still a junior, keeping track of all the things we “should” do on college visits. And then I ran into a wall of resistance from him on some of them. We didn’t push it, since it seemed more important that he feel comfortable and able to focus on those visits, and I think that was the right call for him. (It was the same with the idea of keeping notes, he just didn’t want to have anything to do with it.) But you are right, he knew it when he found it and had a great college experience. I feel like it’s my CC mantra, but every kid is different and parents shouldn’t beat themselves up if a few “shoulds” fall by the wayside.
Exactly - if a parent asks a question (and they do), the world doesn’t end.
We read of many who found the dream and wanted to leave. We read of others forced to go places due to parents or money and had the greatest four years ever.
I knew right away at the school my daughter chose - even though we looked at 30 more. When she told us - it was such a yawn ![]()
Every kid is different. I think the topic is great - best tips - but what works for one family may not for another.
Or if your kid is embarrassed (one parent, I think on a thread posted by @tamagotchi said their child said they were too close to the tour guide.
Whatever - they’ll never see 99.9% of these other kids again.
The important thing to me - most important - is, especially if you’re going to do a lot of visits - get those thoughts recorded / written down - whatever works for the family - immediately right after - because when you go back to compare schools in two months - you get a lot of I don’t remember, I can’t recall, etc. I personally like the recording because you get the raw emotion - the smiles, etc. if it was loved - but whatever works for the family.
The main thing is - whatever you were looking to get that day and maybe you need a check list - hopefully you get it.
We went on more than a few college visits where they had a tour for the students and a separate one for the parents.
My husband asked ONE question on one tour. He noticed there were no sprinklers or smoke/fire detectors in a dorm we were in, and asked. I thought our kid was going to crawl into a hole…but he was right to ask. As the tour continued, another father came up to DH and thanked him. He was a firefighter…and this tour was just after the terrible Seton Hall fire. The other father said he was about to ask the same question.
Other than that…college visits were for our kids, and we were sort of secondary.
I’ve been on many tours - probably 30-40 - never recall seeing that.
That’s interesting.
Instead of asking my kids something like “How was it?” (to which they’d say “Fine”), once we were off campus, I’d ask the kid to tell me about 1 thing they liked and 1 thing they didn’t care for as much.
This usually then spawned a 15-20 min more in depth conversation about what they thought of the college. Later that day, I made notes to myself of what the kid had said so we could remember it months later. That came in handy.
Before the on campus visit, I asked my kids to come up with 1 or 2 questions or pieces of info they were hoping to learn more about. Told them that they didn’t have to ask questions on the tour or anything (didn’t want them to be embarrassed). I told my kids that I might ask 1 or 2 questions on the tour, but I promised that it wouldn’t be anything embarrassing (they told me after the fact that my questions were not cringe-y).
I asked stuff like:
- What’s your favorite class you’ve taken here so far?
- What’s your favorite place to study that’s not in your room? You know, like, in case you need a more quiet place to study, in case your roommate is loud or whatever. (every time I asked this, there was at least 1 other parent or high school student on the tour who would say ‘Oh that’s a good question’)
- Where’s your favorite place to eat on or off campus that’s within walking distance?
I agree! With one college, we didn’t even get out of the car! ![]()
All excellent advice so far.
Here is one that hasn’t been mentioned yet.
As background, D26 and I did 30+ college visits.
On your visits, you will occassionally come across people who are AWFUL ambassadors for their schools. Kids, tour guides, even people in admissions. Sometimes people not affiliated with the school will do things that enter into the decision making calculus.
For example, we met an aggressive panhandler at Bates College right outside of admissions. I bet that only 1 in 2000 people had this experience. But it immediately turned D26 off to Bates which was a crying shame. I convinced her, with great difficulty, to ignore this and apply. She was accepted and did not attend.
Similarly, really bad tour guides at other schools (Dartmouth, Kenyon, and Bryn) turned D26 off.
On the flipside, at St. Olaf…D26 had a personalized tour by an extremely charming and handsome tour guide (lol) which biased her toward that school.
These were all “one off” situations that D26 overreacted to. Teenagers do this.
I explained that she should disregard a “one off” event but fully recognize and consider a observed pattern in her decision making. Honestly, I did not fully get through.
There are also examples of great schools having bad admissions operations and average schools having amazing admissions operations. These things will influence your child.
And as others have said. Let your kid make their own college decision to the greatest extent possible. D26’s mother was way over-opinionated which caused many problems and distorted decision making in a bad way.
So true, maybe the best advice I read on CC was that one should be happy to knock one off the (almost always too long) list.
This is really interesting. Maybe this is something that kids can be armored against in advance, at least to some extent? This is another subject that is often talked about on CC, so maybe we discussed it with our son before we did our visit tour? I really can’t remember, but in general, he was not much affected by tour guides or admissions presentations, good or bad. Or weather - we had attended an accepted students day on a gorgeous day in Texas and I thought “this is it,” but no, he chose the school we saw the next day in cold, rainy Ohio.
That is a good thing! We were the opposite. When she would write down her impressions at the end of a visit…she always emphasized the “one offs” and they stuck with her all the way to her final decision day.
Many parents post on the up / down school list after visit - down because the tour guide stunk.
You’d think -
-
schools would ensure they have the best of the best for info sessions and tour guides - because it’s a sales job - but they don’t
-
you’d hope kids would discount that - because - well, it’s one person of thousands. I can see not discounting food quality, interactions in a dining hall or on campus, are kids walking together or alone, etc.
But the tour guide or admissions committee, both of which you’ll never see again after applying - nope.
But for many, it can make or break - judging by the many posts that say this. I didn’t love the campus but the tour guy was dialed in and funny - keep it on the list - doesn’t make sense to me but it does to others.
I am in total agreement with you. For a bad admissions operation, I would mentally note it and consider it if other school operations also seemed dysfunctional (indicating a potentially lacking organizational culture). But to be the sole basis for including or excluding a school on an admissions list…no.
But these things stuck with my otherwise very smart D26. And that was with me explaining that we would certainly have some “bad tours and info sessions at otherwise great schools” in advance.
In terms of tips for visits, the best tip our family got was about structuring visits early in the college admissions process (spring break of Sophomore year through fall junior year). The idea (which it looks like OP already had covered), is to start with a range of types of schools so your kid can sort out what kinds of schools they like. And, it doesn’t matter if they are schools your kid will actually want to attend at that point, it is to figure out what kinds of traits/factors they like in a school. So, for example, big, medium, small liberal arts college, women’s college, historically black college, public, private, religious/catholic, urban, suburban, rural, etc. And the goal is to see if you can narrow the field a bit and then have types of schools to explore more when the time comes.
Some of this may be able to be done close to home. For example, we have UC Berkeley (big/public urbanish), Sonoma State (smallish public), San Jose state (public/urban) Saint Mary’s college (small/catholic/suburban), Santa Clara (medium/catholic/semiurbanish) Stanford (medium size/private/suburban) and more all within about an hour of where we live. We did not visit all of those, but casually visiting a few of those early helped figure out a few key things. D26 liked smaller schools and religious schools were a no. From there, we had more direction for deciding on visits that required travel and expense.
I will also add that visiting a women’s college was valuable. D26 was not that interested in them pre-visit. After that visit (Wellesley) she realized she liked a lot of things women’s colleges have to offer and 2 of her top 5 schools she eventually applied to ended up being women’s colleges (Wellesley was not one of them). I think the same could have been true for HBCUs, but we could not convince her to visit one, which in the end was fine since she had plenty of good options on her list already.
I, of course, didn’t follow the ‘parents should be quiet’ rule. I asked questions if I had them. Not usually in big tour groups, but we didn’t have many of those. One kid was a recruited athlete so often the visits were arranged by the coach and included a meeting with admissions or financial aid, and I asked my questions. At one school, I remember asking ‘how the hell do students get here?’ as it was in a very small town and had taken us about 5 hours to get there. Oh, said the grad-now-working-in -admin office, they fly to Greenville and someone will pick them up. Greenville was an hour away. Not a good answer. School off the list.
At one school, I asked if parents had access to the theater wardrobe room as it had huge cutting tables, ironing areas, sewing machines and sergers. I was gaga over it. Prof giving the tour (private) said he’d see what he could work out. (my daughter, who doesn’t sew, wasn’t impressed by that room at all).
And probably not the person you asked either as he had students and regular duties to attend do vs a parent :).
Don’t curse and complain about the lack of available parking right before a tour. My immature temper tantrum unfairly tainted my son’s view of Boston College. “Well, I can’t go here because Dad will never be able to park.” Ha. Sorry BC. Totally my fault.
That’s funny - some are sparse or you need a PhD in following directions to their pre assigned parking miles away. At high point - no problem. Your name is on the board electronically. We self toured so no sign but we saw the welcome signs.
That’s funny though. Doubtful why he took it off but very funny.