Our state university definitely had the best tour of anywhere we visited. They had a number of different guides (all well trained) who were in different majors and after their introductions you could pick who to follow depending on your interests. More targeted to sections of campus and curriculum questions.
Going against the grain a tad but I certainly asked questions along the way. Somebody needed to.
Best advice here though is withholding your opinion until you’ve heard from kid first. And certainly don’t fall in love or hate with a place before hearing their opinion. If you love it and they hate it, definitely drop it.
And I might have said a word or two about paid parking when I should’ve held back…
My advice is to study the website before you go. Almost everything you want to know beyond the student experience is going to be on there. Nothing worse than having to listen to people ask questions when the information is right in your pocket.
One thing I recommend for kids with niche interests, known majors, or strong passions is to spend time outside of the tour in whatever building houses those activities. For us, it was S23s major. We looked at bulletin boards with club notices, advising notices, and conference posters. Checked in the major advising/ career advising office if they had one. Looked at any displays they had and got to talk to student with similar majors. None of these things were on the tour, but they were the ones that really gave him a sense of the schools he was most interested in.
Yes! And my best tip is to suggest to the kid that they contact clubs and teams of interest at the school beforehand. Often these clubs and teams have people who specifically handle outreach, are actually happy to meet with students, and may even show them around. At pretty much every school, my kids were amazed at how students were willing to take time to talk with them, in some cases even when my kids didn’t email them until the night before! Talking to students outside of a scheduled tour setting can also counteract the effect of a poor tour guide.
My son was a tour guide for three years, and he always said it was much easier to give a good tour if people asked questions. Otherwise, it was like talking to a blank wall, with no idea who his audience was.
We did a bunch of tours because it was just a way to spend time with the kid. But it is more efficient to just tour the ED, REA and SCEA schools. The rest can be applied en masse, and you can tour them after getting admissions. Make sure the kid writes ahead and attends a class.
Talk to your own school kids on campus that are a year or two ahead — take them out for a meal. Have the kid spend the night with them if possible. We got 1-1 tours from kids we know that are already students there, and whose interests are better aligned with our student’s interests. Talk to other kids that go to that school from your HS. More one on one conversations are better than less. Certainly eat in the dining hall. Tour the department the student is interested in. Ask the kids in the department you are visiting what they hate about the place, how is the job and internship scene etc. How easy is it go get into classes at the start of the semester, how responsive are the profs and TAs, how soon are homework and exams graded? How cutthroat / friendly are fellow students. My kid may have talked to some 10-20 people (people he knew) over the junior spring and senior fall for the 3 schools he was interested in for REA, SCEA, whether it is on a campus visit or outside.
My S24 started with an SCEA in mind, but then effectively dozens of possible Reach, Target and Likely colleges. So he benefited from visits to narrow down the application list itself.
And in fact, the school he ended up attending (WashU) did not start as a guaranteed application. It was only after visiting that he became really interested, to the point it was almost an ED2 choice–although he held out for his SCEA after being deferred, so was admitted to WashU RD.
He then revisited WashU as an admitted student, meaning it made his short list among many other offers he did not revisit.
So I am not sure he would have even applied if not for exploratory visits. And even if he applied, I am not sure if would have made his post-offer short list. Same deal with his eventually #2 choice (Carleton), which he also visited before applying and then revisited. Without the first visits, I am not sure he would have known to be so interested in these colleges.
That makes sense. I guess the process depends on what level of information / clarity the kid has coming into the process.
Visits are great if you can and have the patience.
It’s easy to pick schools on paper. Some you visit b4 applications and remove them. Others you visit after getting in and it’s a hard no - so a visit would have saved that app and money.
And then others - like my son - first loved Wash U but then Purdue blew it away. But then he goes on a college visit as required by the school for a hang out day with friends - nothing more - and ends up there.
If you have the time, patience ( many get burned out on visits), and money - then sure visits are great.
But both parents and students don’t usually have the time and often the money - and the burnout is real which is why in many cases we didn’t do the organized stuff.
On the flipside, with my daughter moreso than my son who was burned out on visits, it was a great 1:1 bonding time flying and driving all over together that I’ll always cherish.
Visiting always helps one way or another - if all things work out - but time, money or burnout - one or more of the three will often get in the way.
Yes, absolutely there are practical limits for anyone, and then long-distance, overnight travel visits is a luxury many families cannot afford at all.
I do think if possible, doing a sampling of visits locally, even of colleges not really under consideration, could be helpful pre-application. But sometimes that is also not feasible, and that’s fine too.