Over the last six months, we’ve had three offers on a slightly used (<5K miles) Kia. Two were from local dealers and one (solicited, just out of curiosity) from Carvana. I received a letter from one dealer with an offer that H inquired about when he took the car in for a recall repair. It turned out that they’d only “pay” that amount if we bought a car from them and traded in ours, so clearly they’d mark up the new car to offset it. If we wanted to just be paid cash and not buy another car, the offer would be $2K less.
I think we are just going to bite the bullet and lease a Tesla. We had been looking at used cars for a while but now we wanting to give the Telsa a try with a lease. We are not interested in buying anything new. I’m sure with gas prices rising we may have to wait longer for the car to be ready, but we can make do with one car for a little while. I’m so annoyed we need a car during all this madness.
Recently sold a used car to CarMax. Offer from CarMax was about 40% more than the offer from Carvana. Area dealers confirmed that CarMax was making unusually high offers for used vehicles. Ours had over 123,000 miles.
Out of curiosity, do you have any notion as to why CarMax is paying such high prices? While we didn’t sell them (we traded in both our cars to the dealer/manufacturer), the prices they offered us for both cars were pretty much the very best.
CarMax needs inventory to sell.
CarMax needs inventory to put on display on its lots. The used car dealers that work on an order / delivery model do not need as much inventory.
However, any of their pricing algorithms sometimes result in unusual prices: Carvana bought my seven-year-old car for more than I paid brand-new - The Verge
The cheapest new car in the US, the Chevrolet Spark, will be discontinued later this year.
https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a38961880/chevy-spark-discontinued/
This does seem to continue the usual pattern of car companies’ vehicle lineup decisions being some years behind the conditions. Vehicle planning often needs years of lead time before the vehicles reach buyers in exchange for the buyers’ money, but market conditions including fuel prices can change much more quickly.
- In 2008, car companies had fleets of thirsty vehicles and had to rush to offer more fuel efficient cars as gasoline prices spiked.
- In 2015, car companies were introducing new highly fuel efficient cars as gasoline prices crashed.
- Now, after recent discontinuation of low cost fuel efficient cars, both gasoline and car prices have spiked, so many buyers are priced out due to lack of (relatively) lower cost offerings.
On the other hand, if car buyers looked at the big numbers on the window stickers and considered the volatility of fuel prices over the time that they will have the car, would their choices be different?
Those links must be paid for by Jeep. That should tell you something when you have a Toyota dealer asking double the MSRP for a RAV4 and Jeep is discounting. ![]()
Thank you for the links. As I said, I’ll be looking for a small SUV for D18 in a few months.
If you look closer, the top two Jeep vehicles, #1 and #3 on the list, do not even have safety ratings, while both of the top ranked Subarus, #2 and #4 on the list, receive perfect 10/10 safety ratings. In short, I agree that the rankings must have been influenced by Jeep.
While other vehicles on the list are rated on three different categories,the top two Jeeps were only ranked based on two categories. And, if Consumer Reports–a different rating service–is used, the two Jeep vehicles score poorly in the category of safety.
P.S. If you are considering the Subaru Outback XT–which is a station wagon / small SUV mix, I urge you to test drive the stronger engine which is turbocharged (260 hp) and not the 182 hp engine. Unfortunately, the turbocharged version is hard to find.
The Honda CR-V was comfortable & adequately powered. Subaru Forester is fine, but hard to find currently.
Many project the vehicle shortage to stretch well into 2023 due to shortages of computer chips and certain other parts & metals.
Toyota announced today that it will cut back vehicle production in April, May, & June due to supply shortages of chips & other materials.
Car shortage almost certain to last until 2024.
Expect significantly higher sticker prices (MSRP) for vehicles over the next 2 years,maybe longer due to inflation and high demand & low supply for many vehicles. I do understand any confusion as some manufacturers are offering prospective car buyers incentives for slow moving models, but there is a lot of pent-up demand for hard to find models which is likely to last into 2024.
Personally, I am ordering accessories for our 2 new Subarus. Some parts are on back order worldwide with no expected delivery date. (These particular parts are made of steel.)
I’m not going back to see if someone has mentioned this in the last 700 posts. But we just bought a car through Volvo’s overseas delivery program. It’s a really good deal anyway, and they have not made market adjustments since the prices came out for the 2022s. So we got 7% off MSRP, and two plane tickets to Sweden.
The biggest downside is you have to plan pretty far ahead, and you have to start making payments a few months before you actually get the car back to the states. Given what is going on with the car market overall, that’s a lot smaller inconvenience than it used to be.
However, the turbocharged engine has worse big numbers on the window sticker, which can be relevant if you are concerned about fuel prices.
It’s hard to find a Kia Forte in CA? Heck, I didn’t even know the car existed before you posted that link. ![]()
The chart labeling is unclear. The column title says “% Used Price More than New”, but they appear to be instead measuring how much the used price has increased over the previous year. A more detailed review of the latter is at Used Car Price Trends - CarGurus Pricing Index . You can look up how much price has increased for a specific make, model, and year. Some example numbers are below. Simple, reliable, inexpensive models with reasonable fuel economy seem to have greater increases in general, as expected. Kia Forte was interesting in that it averaged a high 52% increase over all, but when controlling for year the median dropped to ~35% increase, so it looks like much of the large price increase from last year relates to buying more newer models this year and more older models last year.
2012 Toyota Prius – 42% increase over last year
2012 Honda Civic – 41% Increase over last year
2012 Toyota Corolla – 38% increase over last year
2012 Kia Forte – 34% increase over last year
2012 Honda Accord – 30% increase over last year
2012 Honda CR-V – 29% increase over last year
2012 Honda Odyssey – 25% Increase over last year
2012 BMW 3 Series – 24% increase over last year
2012 Mercedes C Class – 22% increase over last year
2012 Ford Mustang – 21% increase over last year
2012 Jeep Wrangler – 13% increase over last year
2012 Porshe 911 – 13% increase over last year
2012 BMW 5 Series – 11% increase over last year
2012 Ford F-150 – 10% increase over last year
2012 RAM 1500 – 9% increase over last year
2012 Maserati GT – 5% increase over last year
I’m curious from experienced car buyers what you’d do in our circumstance.
We’re moving from Brooklyn to Syracuse, New York. When we moved here a few years ago, we got rid of our high-mileage 2007 Subaru (gave it to family who needed it) and Syracuse has no public transit to speak of so a car will be a necessity pretty much as soon as we get there. In the meantime, we have no safe/reliable place to park a car here. We’ll be able to rely on family for the short term to get groceries and the like when we get there, but we’re definitely not in the position to wait several months for a new vehicle. We also want to keep our car payment on the lower side (ideally less than $600/mo) because we’re looking to buy a house in the next 6 months to a year so, and don’t want our DTI to be too high. Technically we have the money to pay cash, but would prefer to finance so we have more liquid cash for downpayment/closing/etc. on a house.
My husband is the driver, and he likes an all-wheel drive vehicle that isn’t too big (like a hatchback or sedan). He likes the idea of another Subaru and doesn’t care too much about features as long as it’s reliable and has good safety ratings. He also doesn’t want to buy anything without test-driving first.
My brother thinks we’re nuts for considering a used vehicle in this market but with our budget and the need to get something we can drive off the lot, do we really have many other options?