Wouldn’t the Impreza be the smallest and least expensive Subaru sedan or hatchback (matching preferences for not too big, AWD, and not too expensive)?
If AWD is not required, then there are more choices of cars if you are not that picky. If winter brings a lot of snow, another set of wheels with winter tires would be a good idea (AWD or no AWD).
If something comes up now, can you drive it to Syracuse and store it at a family member’s place until you move there?
Do not buy a used vehicle in this market. New vehicles are less costly–especially if financing.
Try to get a Subaru Outback XT (the XT is given to those models with a turbocharged engine = 260 hp). If your credit is above average, Subaru offers a 1.90% finance rate up to 48 months if I recall correctly. Otherwise, many credit unions offer 1.99% interest rate for up to 84 months.
You can finance a new Subaru Outback XT (Onyx or Touring) for less than $600 a month over 84 months if the interest rate is around 2% as you would be financing about $45,000 all in except for car insurance.
If you prefer a smaller vehicle, the Crosstrek MSRP can be quite low = $28,000-$30,000.
In between the Crosstrek & the Outback is the Forester. No turbocharged engine available for the Forester and no need for a turbo engine in the Crosstrek.
The Subaru Outback, Subaru Forester, and the Subaru Crosstrek are all rated at the top of their categories by Consumer Reports.
We bought an Outback Onyx XT & a Forester Wilderness. I have not driven the Forester Wilderness (it just sits in the garage), but I really enjoy driving the turbocharged Outback. No complaints other than the infotainment system is a bit too complex for an anti-technology person like me.
Honda CR-V was nice & affordable.
I do not like Fords anymore, but apparently Ford Escapes offer incentives & are low priced.
I agree that the thread has been dominated by our experiences which resulted in buying two Subarus. I used Consumer Reports. Test drove several other makes, but disliked rotary (Ford) and push-button (Honda) gear selectors which eliminated many brands in addition to Ford & Honda.
(Ford & Honda car dealerships are the closet to us (within a short 15 minute drive) so we started with those brands first.) Test drove Jeep & Toyota as well. Tried to test drive a VW SUV, but all were sold & tried to test drive a Chevrolet SUV but it was sold as we drove to the dealership.
Ended up buying our first Subaru without a test drive. Dealer told us it was “in transit” & we placed a deposit instantly based on Consumer Reports review. Bought the second vehicle in the same manner from a different dealership. We also preferred AWD or 4 wheel drive option.
We had to wait over a month for our first purchase,and over 2 months for the second vehicle.
Although satisfied, I would like to test drive the Lexus RX although none were in stock when we were looking.
I encourage others to share their experiences–including yourself.
According to CR, the Crosstrek offers a choice of engines. Depends upon whether one prefers riding higher than the typical sedan.
If regular car level is acceptable, the Honda Civic or Accord is worth investigating. I only test drove Honda CR-V & the Honda Pilot SUV & the Honda Ridgeline pick-up. Honda CR-V was fine, but the model that I test drove was a 2021 so it did not have the new, troublesome push-button gear selector. The Ridgeline was fine, but we declined because of the gear selector.
For the moment, I believe my D likes the Toyota Corolla Cross, which is a new Toyota model (not the Corolla obviously) that someone alerted me to up thread. But it’ll ultimately depend on what’s available when we legitimately begin our shopping. We may have to zig, if the market zags.
My daughter bought a new car last fall. She did buy an EV but reported that Hyundai had more vehicles on site than other manufacturers.
We loved the Hyundai that we had. It was a good value and required very little in repairs. Drove it for over 200,000 miles.
I do think that a new car would be a better value in this market. Could lease. I know many are against leases but you get more car for less per month. If you are happy making car payments at this point in your life, then it’s an option. Doesn’t have to be a forever option
My D bought her first new car in May of 2018, a Subaru Crosstrek, which she loves. Because she has worked from home (and will continue going forward) for the past two years the car only has 30K miles on it. I have driven her car a few times and really like it. When my 2014 Acura RDX is no longer drivable I think I am going to get a Crosstrek.
Re average annual mileage, I put 15K on my car a year taking the kids places easily. That will probably drop down precipitously when the last one goes to college in the fall. But my 2017 Bolt has 78K on it right now. Love that car.
@hyperJulie you might want to consult with your more northern peeps about this (I’m in the South), but what I would consider since this market is so hellish, is either getting a brand new car, or getting an old beater with a good engine that looks ugly for cheapish. The middle of the road used cars are so expensive right now. It’s my understanding that a lot of folks who drive in heavy winters like to have a beater car for all the salt on the road, etc.
We are in the market for a used car right now for D22 and this market just sucks.
The car is almost 4 years old so much of the 30K miles has been for road trips since 2020. Her work commute was 30 miles a day round trip, so that would have been an additional 15K miles on her car in the past two years. Instead she has enjoyed many skiing, hiking and camping trips!
It depends what specific new and used vehicles. In general used vehicles are less expensive than new, but there are certain exceptions for near-new vehicles with from recent years with low mileage.
Continuing with the Outback example, the new price varies with specific features and model, such as your XT example, but the 2022 news seem to have a mean near $40k. The average used prices listed in the link from my earlier post. Once you get more than ~1 year old, used prices appear to be notably less than new.
That said, used car prices have often had large increases recently. The link also notes that used Outbacks had a ~20% increase in price over previous years. New cars also increased, but not by 20%, so new cars may be a better relative buy than in the past.
The cars with the highest increase in used prices are often less expensive models for persons who do not want to or cannot spend $40k on a new Outback. For example, if you only want to spend $10k, then your options are more limited. Pre-COVID, you could get a reliable used Honda/Toyota type car for $10k. Now it’s far more challenging since this inexpensive, reliable subgroup of cars has had such large increases in price.
In my opinion, it’s a good time to sell cars – not buy cars, regardless of new or used. I recently sold a non-running used car with serious mechanical and cosmetic issues for ~90% of what I paid for it 15 years ago, when it was running well and had no cosmetic issues. I don’t plan to get a replacement at this time.
Mine were stolen last year off my Tundra. Thieves took a sawzall while we were hiking. Parked on a busy road, middle of the day. Had to accept aftermarket because Toyota was 30 days out to even place an order. Can’t imagine now.
The police took my info and said it was becoming a common occurrence.
Grrrrrr…. My husband heroically cleared out the garage so we can park the old Tundra in there instead of in our driveway. If the catalytic converter gets taken, the repair at this point would be more than 1/2 of the truck’s value!
I don’t drive much. My car is nearly 4 years old and approaching 20,000 miles. Mostly we run errands that are a short distance from our home that are less than 30 miles that our electric power refills in under 5 hours. Only need to put in 4 gallons of gas or so a few times/year.
Thanks, this is super helpful! It definitely seems with the financing available for new cars this would be a better deal right now. It seems like the Crosstrek or the Impreza would probably be a good fit for our budget/preferences!
The main hangup is whether we have any chance of being able to find any of these vehicles ready to drive off the lot if we’re not picky about features/color. Has anyone been able to do this lately or are new vehicles just inherently backordered for several months?
Hahahaha!!! This truck is 22 years old. The only places it is going to are HD and dirt yards. There is no way in heck anything will be installed on it. Thanks for a good laugh.