Can Student Deposit at Multiple Colleges Due to COVID-19 Visit Restrictions?

First I hear, would love to see more schools disclose their plans. What other schools have done so?

@SpicyPretzel my son has submitted the deposit for Bard College. They have communicated clear options for the Fall of 2020. We were very nervous about all the same things many parents have mentioned here: not being able to begin on time, our own job security, and what if students are not able to move in for the fall. We were able to have all of those questions answered on April 4 at a special webinar “accepted student day” and have had lots of communication from Bard ever since with the ways they are planning and adapting. It was hard to pay a deposit and commit, but ultimately, we had to think about what happens AFTER this fall, and our son wants very much to go to Bard. He had a full ride offer from Maine because of National Merit, and it was hard to turn down a free college opportunity when he may still be here in August and have to learn remotely. But doing that would require him to continue at Maine after this year and the opportunity to go to Bard would no longer be there. So…if he has to start online, we believe that EVERYONE will be online. Is that what we want? No. But we are pleased that Bard is doing everything they can to prepare for both situations and communicating with us now. It would be hard to pay a deposit without those answers. If the OP doesn’t have answers, then I can understand the hesitation to put down the deposit. However, he was also on a wait list at Oberlin until he decided to go with Bard, so I also understand why it is unfair to double deposit.

1 Like

A friend (yes really a friend) was told by their paid college advisor to put two deposits down and that it was done “all the time”. So many people who have the extra money have been advised historically to do so and are doing so now.
Someone asked why - what has changed? Besides the obvious, my son lost his chance to play his beloved Spring sport as its Captain. He will never get that chance to play again. However he is reaching out to one of his top two colleges and they are getting the coach there to get in touch with him to see if he has a chance to do a “walk on”. Not looking for any money, just the chance to try out, practice and maybe play. His other top choice of two has a great club team which if he had too would love to play for. But we are running out of time. We need the extra time because Things.Have.Changed.
An update is that one of these two schools has extended their deadline to May 15. The other has not> HOW can we deal with this? Looking for any ideas because many colleges have changed their dates and some have not. Has that ever happened before? I do not think so - therefore maybe we are being forced into putting two deposits down as things have changed and even colleges are not all playing with the same MAY 1 playbook and deadline.

As much as I rue the situation my senior and all others are in, ethics are ethics. It’s truly unfair to the students who are waiting for acceptance to double deposit. My daughter will 1) accept an offer by May 1 and (2) Immediately withdraw from all other accepted schools. My daughter wants to graduate from the school she selects. If she needs to go online, she will try it. If it’s truly awful, she will make a different choice next year. If she needs to learn how to distance learn, she will. If this virus taught me one thing, it’s to expect the unexpected. And to try to live life as best as possible by adjusting to circumstances. I would also like to add that I have been distance teaching for 15 years along with on campus courses. I teach writing at a university outside Philadelphia. My first course was rough, no question. I learned a lot. I improved a lot. So did my students. Lots of resources are being offered to faculty right now; why not see if you can talk to a current student to see how he/she are faring?

Just because someone is a college advisor doesn’t mean they are scrupulously. Look at the recent scandal and all the people that have gone to jail.

I don’t understand why people aren’t thinking long-term. If your kid prefers school x over school y, why not just send them to school x? At some point, campuses will open back up. If you send your kid to school y because their campus is open or they’ll let you defer, in the end your kid is still graduating from their 2nd choice school. But if they enroll at school x their degree will be from their first choice school even if 1 of their 8 semesters is online.

I don’t think many schools could actually have believable plans unless they are willing right now to put everything online for the fall. We received a very thorough discussion of plans from University of Portland, but at the end of the day, they did say that all they can do is keeping planning and be open about their decisions. Of course, I understand that most schools need to be unclear so that students will make their decisions and get those deposits in! I did appreciate UP’s starting to talk about the various issues, however. My son is trying to decide between this and another school and I am waiting to see if that other school comes forward with such a statement.

Parents can not double deposit bad bad bad, But colleges have no problem taking kids off a waitlist for their school after they deposited at another school, totally fine. Got it, and before I hear it is different , and not holding 2 spots really, remember with May 1 admission day and June 1 admission I could do the same thing, accept May 1 at school 1 and decide May 30 school one has said online school in the fall , no tuition reduction and decide school 2 is saying we will either be open in the fall for kids to stay on campus or we will offer a tuition discount, I can drop school 1 and than accept school 2 and everyone SHOULD be fine with this bc I never had 2 deposits at one time, I just choose my second school off my personal waitlist. Ohio State took an extra 6,000 kids , their waitlist will not be touched this year, what happens if their yield is wrong , no problem bunch of kids who thought they had doubles now have triples and an extra 100 kids in math 101. Seems like colleges want our decision deposits before they announce anything definite for next fall. I understand they may not know if dorms will be open but they could be more transparent on the pricing end if they are online one way or another, wonder why they are not being transparent?

@NJdad07090 hit the nail on the head. It’s hypocritical for colleges to say a kid cannot deposit at more than one school, yet use the waitlist as their safety net and pull kids who had committed to other schools. Most of the top schools create huge waitlists, raising false hope for many, knowing that a vast majority will not get off the waitlist. Someone said the waitlist is the dark secret of the college admissions process and that is somewhat true. In some respects, waitlists are a marketing tool for colleges to hand out “soft” rejections artificially expanding the market for their application pool. I am not saying it’s all bad - many kids do get accepted off the waitlist and it serves a function to ensure colleges fullfull their class targets. However, and putting aside all the other things that are wrong with college app process (“elite branding”, common apps enlarging applicant pools, articifially low acceptance rates and class size limits, etc.), if schools can play the game and allow kids to de-commit to hedge against their bets, kids should be able to deposit and commit to more than one school if they are undecided and that’s what they want to do. Sure, it takes up a potential spot for another student, and it’s more advantageous for kids from families who can afford to do so, but it’s not permanent and eventually the applicant will have to make a decision - at that point, the school can offer the freed up spot off the waitlist. That’s why some waitlists are used deep into the summer.

I personally believe that when one signs an attestation or makes an oath to be truthful, it’s unethical to do otherwise. There’s no partly ethical.

It’s also the same type of situational ethics bending that gets people in trouble. Yes, I stole some of the money, but they are a rich company and don’t understand my situation. They won’t even know or miss it. I intended to pay it back. That sort of logic.

There are so many students on admitted lists and waitlists. There are millions of parents is in the same boat having to make a choice with incomplete data.

If one accepts both a May and June offer simultaneously, it’s good for you and bad for others.

Say you drop the May deposit in June or July. The May school waitlist students certainly could have dropped after a month or two thinking they where not in the running. It might have been the most affordable option for that family. It could be a bigger deal than one thinks. They lose their opportunity because of this and it’s just not ok.

Or they reach into the waitlist in late June and these families are scrambling, the school you misled now has to scramble - it effects another school, other families, opportunities are lost for others that you never even met and more plans are upended.

It’s like driving in heavy traffic. If we all went along at the same speed and stay in our lanes it runs smoothly. However everyone is focused on their singular commute. Jumping in and out. Creating backlogs and breaking. Slowing it down for everyone.

If everyone plays by the same rules it works better for the collective. It’s hard to do.

And I totally understand not wanting to play the waitlist game as it is a tool for the university more than the student. Decline the offer and leave the game.

Make the best choice you can and adapt if necessary. It’s tough for everyone.

YES, @NJdad07090! I’m not sure that I would argue that it’s comparable to a “waitlist” of colleges from the students’ perspective in a normal year, but in this year with colleges demanding deposits when they don’t have any idea what the fall term will look like, I don’t see anything wrong with depositing at a May 1 school and then changing one’s mind when/if more information is available about how coronavirus will impact the choice.

I commented yesterday and included links so it was flagged for moderation: the Chronicle has published and updated a list of schools that are doing the right thing and making public their considerations for fall. Also on Twitter.

@mom2jgd San Francisco Chronicle? maybe put the google keywords that will get us there? thanks in advance

Sorry! Chronicle dot com. Chronicle of Higher Education. Also on Twitter.

Chronicle.com is OK to post.

Maybe for you! Since you’re a moderator, perhaps you could link to the full article without getting bounced?

Here it is: https://www.chronicle.com/article/Here-s-a-List-of-Colleges-/248626

Please don’t reprimand me @MaineLonghorn!

If it posts without being filtered or held for moderation, it’s OK!

@25Raider: colleges have been set up this way for years and years. Not sure why you now think it’s unethical to have wait lists. Gaming the system is possible, sure. Double deposit away. But as several of us have said, it’s unethical and unfair to waiting students.

Everyone who is unhappy with colleges: can we please at least agree that none of us know what the fall will bring, either. Some of these posts make me happy I am not an admin at said colleges. Look, most if not all colleges want to open as normal. Their survival depends upon it. But if online is all that we can do … it’s all we can do. I don’t expect to pay room or board or fees for my daughter if she is home next fall. But yes, I do expect to pay full tuition for the classes. And I am happy to do so.