There is nothing wrong with depositing at school A on May 1. If you decide by May 15 that he’d rather go to school B, then you can deposit there - but you have to let School A know within a reasonable amount of time that you are withdrawing your acceptance. Is 15 days reasonable? Probably, and his hs is not going to send a final transcript by June 1 (since many schools go beyond June 1 so transcripts aren’t final then).
@Vorpals - I respect your comment that it is unfair - “unethical” I am not so sure that is right. I think it’s not right that colleges overload their waitlists, try to get kids to change their minds deep into the summer - and given what’s going on, many are refusing to extend the May 1 deadline. Just because they have been doing it for years, doesn’t necessarily make it right, especially if things change. If colleges want kids to act ethically, they should do the same by having uniform deadlines and creating realistic waitlists with specific deadlines for themselves.
@25Raider you act as if the colleges are intentionally duplicitious. That is what puzzles me. The only reason colleges extended deadlines this year is the virus. As for waiting lists: at least then kids have a second shot. No one mandates that you join a waiting list. You can move right on to the next school. I understand your dilemma. My own kid is torn between three schools and cannot visit; she is making the best decision she can based on the information she has. It is ethical to accept a position on May 1 then later withdrawal if accepted off a waitlist elsewhere. It’s always been ethical. What is not ethical is double depositing to give your kid more time to make up his/her mind when others are waiting for a spot. You can certainly disagree, as ethics are often individual. I hope your students ends up in a good place and I hope mine does too.
Here is a likely unpopular view: teach your kid to deal with life on life’s terms. In this uncertainty, I think my student better prepare for some element of distance learning if she wants to graduate from her school of choice four years from now. She needs to make a decision with much less information that she had hoped by May 1. Those of you who totally oppose paying for online learning should look for local schools for next year (area community colleges). And I expect to pay the same tuition for online courses. Does it suck that my kid cannot tour her schools and must decide like we did in the olden days? You bet. It sucks more than many students will not be able to afford college now. Let’s keep our perspective.
@Vorpals - I certainly don’t mean colleges are committing intentional misconduct or conspiring against our kids. They are looking out for their own interests - not necessarily the interests of the kids facing one of their most important decisions in an unprecedented environment. There was a national deadline of May 1 - they could have extended the deadline uniformly. I guess I just have a more cynical view of colleges. What do you think about depositing at school A with a May 1 deadline - and then depositing on May 30 with School B that has a June 1 deadline, and withdrawing from School A. I would guess this is a dilemma facing many kids.
I think keeping the May 1st deadlines, for the schools that chose to do that, does take into consideration the best interests of their students. They are able to get moving on planning the best they can (with more information at hand) for a productive fall and at the same time by settling their freshman class while moving kids off waitlists, maybe bumping spring admits, appeals, transfers - whatever each school has as part of their overall student body. The sooner they have firm numbers to work with, the sooner they can have orientation (even if online) understand their course registration loads, housing, plan perhaps for some classes in person, those that need to be online, etc. Waiting for another month to do that inconveniences other aspects of a schools operations. I think each school is doing the best they can to serve all of their community - students and staff - with what info they have to work with each day.
As a side note, the people I know with students facing a decision want May 1 to come and go and be done with it. There is nothing like the feeling of committment and moving forward with the decision. It can be a big hallelujah!
@CADREAMIN - Almost no school will snow what they will have on campus or the virtual classroom in the fall until one of two things happen, They show up on campus or the payment for fall is due. Many colleges have said even with May 1 they will really have no idea if their numbers will hold up. The Bucknell president that very thing a few weeks ago. Schools may not know if they can open and that is fair , bc they do not control that But they do control the tuition they charge in the fall. I expect campus will be closed and I also expect tuition and fees ( which most folks think will be waived) will not change for the large majority of kids/parents.
I received email last night from president that the 3.5% tuition increaser next year was cancelled to help families deal with the pandemic. I hope we can return to campus this Fall. While professors were awesome with remote learning (especially with no lead time to prepare), it’s not the same as being on campus and the spontaneous interactions that happen naturally - miss Bucknell
Well now that it is May 2 most folks had their kids commit by yesterday, it will be interesting how many colleges will use waitlist, if they have not yet used them and how many colleges will try to change kids minds who committed to a different school.
Many schools have already gone to the waitlist, including some very good schools, like Princeton, Lehigh, U Chicago, Tulane to name just a few.
Wash U, Ga Tech , UCSB, Va Tech, NC State, GW, UGA, Notre Dame, UCSD, Cal Poly SLO, U Miami , UVA, Santa Clara, UCI, UCLA all have gone to their waitlists.
Adding: U Richmond, Providence, Emerson, UNC Chapel Hill, U Mich.
This is an unprecedented number of schools going to the waitlist before May 1. Some schools like U Chicago and Lehigh commonly go prior to May 1, but others like some of the UCs and UVA, hardly ever.
This year was going to be different post May 1 anyway, due to the DOJ NACAC lawsuit settlement. So in addition to continued waitlist action (several hundred schools have a June 1 decision date) throughout the summer, schools will be allowed to contact and recruit (likely via more $) students who have already committed elsewhere. This is allowed for both incoming freshman and transfer students.
“Can”? Of course they CAN if they have the funds just as they always have been able to do so. If anything, things have opened up more in terms of allowing these sort of things. Whether one believes if it is morally proper or if schools that find out, take some sort of action (Can they legitimately anymore?) is a whole other issue . But, yes, students CAN multI deposit as they always could. I know many who did in the past 30 + years and some who are right now.
UCLA has already put out 3 or 4 waves of OOS and IS acceptances off the waitlist - the first two were before the May 1 deadline.
Here is the thing, though. Students signed that before Covid-19, i.e., with the expectation that colleges would be offer in-person classes and the full college experience.
anyone know what to do in a transfer situation? double depositing - one is UCLA the other is USC. i have my top choice waitlisted for UC Berkeley.
so my financial aid package almost did not come in until like now and this is the answer I got from my counselor when i emailed her about extending. what should i do in this situation.
"Unfortunately, we can’t extend your commitment date. However, You are also welcome to use the deposit waiver to safe a space in the class. It’s also fine to wait until you receive your financial aid packet. "
please tag me as I am very panicked lol and the deadline is june 1st