Capitalism vs. Communism: The Showdown

<p>

Back it up for a second. Greed isn’t just the desire for money. According to Wikipedia greed is defined as the excessive desire for "money, status, and power.
[Greed</a> - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia](<a href=“http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greed]Greed”>Greed - Wikipedia)
So, are you suggesting that before economic systems humans didn’t have a desire for status (social standing, respect) and power (control over others)? </p>

<p>

Do you think a communal system would work on a mass scale? I understand why it worked for in the earliest stages of human development, but there’s a reason we began to develop systems of government and economics as early as 3000 B.C. Do you think that we could live in a communal system with a world population of several billion? Do you think there was a reason why we developed systems of government and economics?</p>

<p>Please answer all of my questions and defend your position.</p>

<p>This is the most uplifting thing I have read in months, maybe years. Thank you. I have tried so many times to articulate exactly what you have said here.</p>

<p>I think it’s important to emphasize something brought up here: communism and socialism are not the same thing. There are many different socialist philosophies that were brought up in the 19th century and they all attempt to use different approaches to achieve a “socialist” society that attempted to bridge gap in the social hierarchy in Europe at that time. Communism is a very radical means to achieve a socialist society, and one could argue that extreme conditions in Russia during the end of the monarchy (an autocratic and reactionary tsar, an incredibly radical intelligentsia, the problems from freeing the serfs, terrible famine) caused what we all know as “communism” to diverge far from its true intentions and even further from most socialist doctrine. Social Democrats for example believe in reform within the market economy. I personally believe this is an approach that allows true capitalism to thrive as it promotes equal access and has the potential to prevent monopoly and abuse.</p>

<p>

This is where the “nature of man” becomes circular. At some point, humans moved from a “natural” state of hunter-gatherer communities to agriculture, and that precipitated the development of civilization, and forms of inequality (like the subjection of women) emerged. The change was made for practical reasons. But was it unnatural? Why isn’t “civilization” man’s natural state (if it isn’t)? (not posing these questions to anyone in particular)</p>

<p>I feel like communism is less motivating but it is also less sinful…</p>

<p>Communism in the long-run gives off much less value and pay to those who actually work hard, whereas Capitalism pays off the hard worker.</p>

<p>

Let us go talk to some fingerless Vietnamese children about how all their hard Nike factory labor in the capitalistic system is going to pay off more for them than universal healthcare, food, shelter, and education.</p>

<p>Communism leaves room to hypocritical and corrupted government and denies human nature.</p>

<p>

Hypocritical government? Like claiming all humans are equal, yet treating them like anything but? Corrupt government? Like having billionaires and lobbyists influencing the lawmakers, nearly all of which are millionaires themselves?</p>

<p>Any government can be corrupted; communism seeks to limit government (after the initial temporary dictatorship of the proletariat) by giving all the power to the workers themselves. And it’s hard to have so much corruption if you truly eliminate class.</p>

<p>

We covered this before. This is bull. “Human nature” involves seeking out the conditions best suited for life, which communism can certainly provide for.</p>

<p>

Yet in communistic communities, they would receive the same benefits as a lazy guy who isn’t as hard working. In Captalistic communities, making money is no limitation. You can make as much as you want if you’re doing it right. Communistic communities, you cant. Which isn’t fair.</p>

<p>

Enough. They would have enough. Everyone should have enough, no?</p>

<p>

As I said, someone should really tell those fingerless children in Vietnam that. Or the entirety of the US working class. They can all rise to wealth as a whole, right? Right?</p>

<p>

In communism, the workers own the means of production and the concept of money is far different, and not so much limiting to how one lives.</p>

<p>

Why? Who are you to say that the system that lets more people eat is less fair, just because you don’t get to have as much excess? Why is it fair that all may eat, all may drink, all may learn, all may be free, all may live?</p>

<p>

Everyone should have what they worked for. Don’t bring up your Vietnamese argument again, as it is invalid. In a capatalistic society, in majority, wealth is derived from an education. Through that education, your hard work pays off. However without an education don’t expect any form of high compensation for your work. Education is free in public schools, and almost every person in America is given the right to education. If immigrants come to America, it’s their job to raise the next generation to be more educated, and produce money.</p>

<p>

The matter of limiting how one lives is strawman to what I initially meant. Communism limits business, and are the product of central economic policies. Who wants a government controlled business? Nobody who is a owner of a business would want to be limited by the government, and constantly regulated, and taxed heavily by them. If you were a business owner, what would you want? Freedom of choice, or letting the government babysit you?</p>

<p>

Who am I? A Central-left American. I believe everyone has a right to education and food. Which are given in America. However, I do not believe that the government should babysit the citizens. We have the right to freedom, and more government just limits that.</p>

<p>

Exactly. By working to produce an object, they should still own their labor, no? And yet, the means of production are owned by the rich, and the workers don’t have what they worked for, just a pittance that amounts to wage slavery.</p>

<p>

Why? Because it disproves your point that anyone in the system can become rich by working hard enough?</p>

<p>

And yet, 50% of the wealthy in America inherited family fortunes, and a good deal of the others were still born upper- or middle-class. We don’t like to say it, but we are still largely a society where birth determines your lot in life.</p>

<p>

Communism merely says that the factory must be owned collectively by those who work it. That the profits of their labor should be given to all the workers, not just one owner.</p>

<p>

Socialists. Not communists. Learn. The. Difference.</p>

<p>

  1. All of the workers would be owners, not the government and not the rich.
  2. It’s a stateless society, not one with a large government. Please please please learn the systems before debating them.</p>

<p>

I would only be a business owner in a collective, with all the workers having equal share.</p>

<p>

Big government is socialism, you’re terribly misinformed. And if you were a worker, would you rather have a wage-slave job with a profit-driven boss, or economic liberty? Now they have the choice to labor hard or to die.</p>

<p>

The economy is an economic oligarchy of the rich; you know that communism is a democratic economy, yes? And that it is a world, stateless, classless society, not “big government”?</p>

<p>

You fail to understand what communism is. A communism society distributes property among every member evenly. Not what you think that people who produce an object, they keep it. This is why in America, we have trademarks, and such to make sure it is ours and not someone elses. Not that this is a universal example, just one of the points I occasionally use. </p>

<p>

No, because it is a stupid argument, which has no real base value rather then to affect on emotions. Emotional issues is what most communistic-supporters are using as their arguments, which you have done. The emotional fact that fingerless children work hard but get no money, is simply a issue of education, not how hard they work. I am from a LOW-INCOME family myself, however, you don’t see me crying. I am actually working hard towards my education. Anyone has a chance to become middle-class/upper-class with the right education and will. It’s just that most low-income kids don’t even want an education in the first place.</p>

<p>

Yet, it was those wealthy families who actually got the education good enough to actually create a business that made money, and then put them in the family inheritance. If you go back to the roots of 90% of those rich families, it starts off with education. Upper-classmen sure have an advantage, but that advantage is due to their families education. However, if you put a rich kid (from a rich family) as the head of your business when he hasn’t had a single ounce of education, then the business would be sabotaged. What I am saying is that the next generation from the rich family still needs to have a good education. Most rich families give their kids high-class private education. I hope you don’t forget that.</p>

<p>

Are you serious? The tenants of Communism is that businesses are owned by the government/state (or the “people”). Learn. To. Comprehend.</p>

<p>

  1. That’s the thing. There is no room for a business owner in Communist Societies, or leadership positions. Since the government owns the business in the first place (or the “people”). This will lead to various issues among it’s effectiveness, as a business as well.</p>

<ol>
<li>You might need to re-check your understandings of Communism. Abolition of the state is just a fancy term used by communists, however it’s practice was never used. Marx’s definition was that he would like the government to control private ownership. The State is one of the leading principles of a communistic society, as the state (or the people in that case) is what owns everything. </li>
</ol>

<p>

That’s the thing. Communism in theory goes against Human Nature itself. We cannot live without a government of some sort to manage human lives to a small extent at least, and anarchy itself would be vehemently dangerous. Thus, any form of Communism would be automatically turned into socialism in practice. Communism’s central policy towards economy (government-owned everything) doesn’t help either. </p>

<p>

Say that to the face of textbooks and history itself. Most communistic states (Soviet Union, and China) in the past were authoritarian (stalin, Mao). Freedom is almost zero guarentee. You could be sentenced to years in prison for speaking what is in your mind. Deaths were in the million in communistic states (Mao, and Stalin anyone?). Is that your definition of a non “big government”?</p>

<p>Come on, to be human is to be greedy. It sounds bad but denying it is bull. You are greedy, I’m greedy. Don’t you even try to say no. Under certain system, this does not lead to catastrophe, but under the other, it will.</p>

<p>Just in-case you missed it since it was in the last page, i will re-post my arguments.</p>

<p>

You fail to understand what communism is. A communism society distributes property among every member evenly. Not what you think that people who produce an object, they keep it. This is why in America, we have trademarks, and such to make sure it is ours and not someone elses. Not that this is a universal example, just one of the points I occasionally use. </p>

<p>

No, because it is a stupid argument, which has no real base value rather then to affect on emotions. Emotional issues is what most communistic-supporters are using as their arguments, which you have done. The emotional fact that fingerless children work hard but get no money, is simply a issue of education, not how hard they work. I am from a LOW-INCOME family myself, however, you don’t see me crying. I am actually working hard towards my education. Anyone has a chance to become middle-class/upper-class with the right education and will. It’s just that most low-income kids don’t even want an education in the first place.</p>

<p>

Yet, it was those wealthy families who actually got the education good enough to actually create a business that made money, and then put them in the family inheritance. If you go back to the roots of 90% of those rich families, it starts off with education. Upper-classmen sure have an advantage, but that advantage is due to their families education. However, if you put a rich kid (from a rich family) as the head of your business when he hasn’t had a single ounce of education, then the business would be sabotaged. What I am saying is that the next generation from the rich family still needs to have a good education. Most rich families give their kids high-class private education. I hope you don’t forget that.</p>

<p>

Are you serious? The tenants of Communism is that businesses are owned by the government/state (or the “people”). Learn. To. Comprehend.</p>

<p>

  1. That’s the thing. There is no room for a business owner in Communist Societies, or leadership positions. Since the government owns the business in the first place (or the “people”). This will lead to various issues among it’s effectiveness, as a business as well.</p>

<ol>
<li>You might need to re-check your understandings of Communism. Abolition of the state is just a fancy term used by communists, however it’s practice was never used. Marx’s definition was that he would like the government to control private ownership. The State is one of the leading principles of a communistic society, as the state (or the people in that case) is what owns everything. </li>
</ol>

<p>

That’s the thing. Communism in theory goes against Human Nature itself. We cannot live without a government of some sort to manage human lives to a small extent at least, and anarchy itself would be vehemently dangerous. Thus, any form of Communism would be automatically turned into socialism in practice. Communism’s central policy towards economy (government-owned everything) doesn’t help either. </p>

<p>

Say that to the face of textbooks and history itself. Most communistic states (Soviet Union, and China) in the past were authoritarian (stalin, Mao). Freedom is almost zero guarentee. You could be sentenced to years in prison for speaking what is in your mind. Deaths were in the million in communistic states (Mao, and Stalin anyone?). Is that your definition of a non “big government”?</p>

<p>

No, that everyone benefits from their labor and what they produce, not just the owner.</p>

<p>

Low income, eh? Means a lot of different things. Could be bad luck, or rural poor, or inner city, or foreign worker, or starving African child. You being “LOW-INCOME” doesn’t give you authority to say that anyone can rise. You say anyone can go up with an education? The poor are kept from a decent education. I mean, you’re oversimplifying, but it’s a consideration. As for the foreign children laboring to build America’s shoes, they have neither education, fair labor, upward mobility, sufficient food/necessities, nor economic liberty.</p>

<p>Do you believe that if someone cannot move out of poverty, they should stay there and die? Because if everyone in the world had enough, the rich could not be rich.</p>

<p>

The workers in collective, but not a government. The workers in the particular of the situation.</p>

<p>

You could be a manager/CEO of a factory or other labor organization, you would merely be elected to that position and continue to get an equal (and not greater) share.</p>

<p>

The state does not directly control, the workers control. There is, of course, a type of universal societal organization for direction, which could be called government, but does not carry all the connotations and functions of a modern “state.”</p>

<p>

There has never been a Communist country (someone brought up Paris Commune, and a case can be made, but that’s not what’s at hand). The People’s Republic of China was as Communist as it was a People’s Republic. It’s called propaganda; why buy into one half of it but not the other?</p>

<p>

Just because you feel greed for money or wealth does not mean you should generalize it to the whole. Again, human nature is not greed for money, it is a desire to seek out the conditions best suited for life. Communism can accommodate this for ALL, not just the few, the rich, the elite.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Tenants? There are people that rent rooms from communism? This. Is. Fascinating.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Abolition of the state isn’t a fancy term. It’s pretty simple. And the “practice” argument is great. It’s like Manny Ramirez.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>lolno. this could not be more ****ing wrong. There’s even a section in the manifesto that rails against Socialism because it’s just a way for the bourgeois to cling to power.</p>

<p>

  • Red is a color
  • Blue is a color
    Therefore blue is red.</p>

<p>There’s no logic there.</p>

<p>

ok you might be an angel but most people are like me. So what do you do about us? Give us the power of a communist system and see what we can do? Do you even dare?</p>