Capitalism vs. Communism: The Showdown

<p>Wow I didn’t know we had Communism experts on this forum for high school kids.
and
Wow I didn’t know we had Capitalism experts on this forum for high school kids.</p>

<p>If we ever become a Communist society (true Communist within my life time) I will eat my conservative views for breakfast. Until then I will ponder on how it will actually be able to work in a modern society.</p>

<p>Sorry, but I will include a reply to you guys probably tomorrow or something. I don’t have quite alot of time at the moment.</p>

<p>^ I am not a capatalist. I am something of the middle between capatalist and socialist. However if we break it into percentage, probably…</p>

<p>70% Capatalist
30% Socialist</p>

<p>However, my political views are:</p>

<p>Central-Left. </p>

<p>I am a liberal. </p>

<p>inb4imonlyinhighschool</p>

<p>

With all necessities, a good job, a stake and pride in your work, equality in society, universal peace, and a common goal for humanity, how many people would look at their neighbors and desire to impoverish them for their own gain? Some, surely, but when everyone has the power to stop them, it’s not so bad.</p>

<p>The former upper class would be discontent, but the vastly larger former lower class would be far better off.</p>

<p>

With a few score hours of reading, some philosophy/economics courses, and staying informed on world issues, one past the age of reason can become well enough informed in this.</p>

<p>Also, I’m out of high school and TCBH is in college.</p>

<p>

Better than the current world workers for the large majority of humanity. How can you criticize communism for not being able to work when our current world is such a miserable failure for the bottom 90%.</p>

<p>Well, age isn’t really too much of a limit. Im a rising sophomore in High School. Well, even though I love debating/politics, doesn’t mean I will be good at it. But I try my best to be civil in debated and use critical thinking.</p>

<p>civility is overrated</p>

<p>I can criticize it for not working because it never has happened ever. Lol when something never happens that generally means it doesn’t work. It can’t be better if it never existed. That would be like saying that witches (real magic and potions) are better then humans because in theory they… </p>

<p>I just mentioned the fact that it’s a high school forum because many people on here are either in college for undergrad, grad, or are currently out of grad school and get a kick out of debating with high school kids.</p>

<p>

Civility is for the ones not starving to death.</p>

<p>

Yeah, like democracy was impossible before it was ever implemented.</p>

<p>

Because known science disproves the possibility of communism?</p>

<p>

It’s mostly high school and undergrad.</p>

<p>You guys endorse savagery?</p>

<p>Wow, I am now contemplating as to whether I should even continue debating.</p>

<p>

I am contemplating as to whether I should even explain a joke. Though mine was, actually, the truth. We who are not starving may prize civility, but I blame no one for rising in earnest when their children starve.</p>

<p>D you are really not acting reasonable. </p>

<p>Democracy existed in some primitive tribes so when was the before it was era?</p>

<p>No because saying something that does not exist is better than something that does exist is false in any context because ideas are much different than what actually is. </p>

<p>Really? Didn’t you say you were in grad school or were you out of it already?</p>

<p>Which is an act of emotion. You would let a poor guy kill your family for their money/food?</p>

<p>Emotion/Morality=/=Politics/Government</p>

<p>We are born with equal rights in America, and to say that someone who is starving should have more rights to act savage (or “act in earnest”) then other guys who aren’t starving is a bad argument, which I suggest you should never use. Poor people have no more rights then rich, nor vice-versa.</p>

<p>

[Primitive</a> communism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia](<a href=“http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primitive_communism]Primitive”>Primitive communism - Wikipedia)</p>

<p>Apology accepted.</p>

<p>

When what is is murderous, an idea of a better world is commendable.</p>

<p>

You must be thinking of someone else. I’m starting at Notre Dame this fall.</p>

<p>

I wouldn’t begrudge a group of poor people organizing to overthrow capitalism.</p>

<p>

America is the world, now?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Primitive tribes = beginning of time?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Any context? I feel pretty confident in saying that the iPad3 will be better than the iPad2, if the iPad3 ever comes into existence.</p>

<p>

It’s where I live in, so it’s my world. However, feel free to add other countries as you please.</p>

<p>

Interesting.</p>

<p>

… Is it really that easy to forget the rest of humanity?</p>

<p>

World politics is interesting, but I am assuming things on the basis that I believe America is one of the main bastions of civilization. May not be the best, but up there.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>A communist would tell you that that’s a myth. The wealthy are born into a world with very different rules from everyone else. The system they’ve set up marginalizes the majority. So why would a majority acting in its own rational self interest not do what it can to change that system?</p>

<p>In many ways it’s not too different from Locke’s ideas on just political rebellion.</p>

<p>I suppose I was, sorry about that usernames are easy to mix up.</p>

<p>You use one definition of Communism when it’s convenient to you, one post Marx’s Com. is not the Communism you’re talking about and another it suddenly is?
Clearly not but I doubt those single celled organisms really had any form of government or class structure. Oh wait-are they communist? </p>

<p>You can’t be sure of it though until it’s out. One new version of ipods was regarded as worse than the last so the next version was nothing like the old, so no you aren’t right until it’s out. It was the smallest one when they went from a little square to like a little stick.</p>

<p>

A strawman argument. Economics =/= Rights. Rights according to law are equal amongst everyone. Wealthy may be able to much more then the poor, however, that is not a measure of how much rights are given inside America.</p>

<p>

No problem.</p>

<p>

It wasn’t Marx’s definition of Communism, it was the list of short-term goals labor parties should pursue while in their states, to prepare for the transition.</p>

<p>

We can’t be sure world communism will work, but the atrocities of the current system means that a change is worth a shot. Like going from monarchy to republic, when republics were untried.</p>

<p>

I do not think that means what you think it means.</p>

<p>

What are rights without reality to back them up? Where is our right to life? Is that in the Constitution? Right to food, water, shelter, safety, health? A good job? Economic liberty?</p>

<p>What would these rights be, even if they were written, without enforcement? Where is the enforcement of alleged equality? Where is the liberty for wage slaves? The life for the starving?</p>

<p>The rights for the rest of the world?</p>