<p>
</p>
<p>One needn’t be totally sure. It’s possible to make decisions based on perceived probabilities.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>One needn’t be totally sure. It’s possible to make decisions based on perceived probabilities.</p>
<p>
Lawl, I’m sure you’ve offended a whole lot of people with that.</p>
<p>It says clearly in that article that Marx and Engels are the one’s who pointed it out.</p>
<p>That was a reasonable response. I do agree that it is worth a shot but I don’t like the idea of a society were everything is equal. I don’t like people not having a place to live or enough to eat. I don’t like that there is so much suffering that goes ignored by people (especially in America). I really don’t like it so I try to help the way I know how to, by charity work and donations. I know I can’t help everyone that way but helping 1 is better then ignoring them all.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>It’s not a strawman argument. A strawman argument is something where you distort someone’s argument then prove the distortion wrong.</p>
<p>
The law is not the truth.</p>
<p>
Who called it Primitive Communism first; which is understandable, since they were writing the Communist Manifesto at the time. The dynamics of hunter-gatherer societies were already known as such.</p>
<p>
Charity can’t fix the problem, it just sort of makes things kind of better for some people for as long as they can collect donations/supplies. You have to change the system to fix the problem. Until we can do that, charity is a noble thing, but not the true means to the end.</p>
<p>
You need to read it up, because what you replied with is indeed a strawman. It had nothing to do with my argument, so either you mis-understood, or posted something irrelevant purposely.</p>
<p>
You need reality to know about the justice system? As I said, I think you misunderstood what I said and are posting strawman arguments. My reply to him was about our rights in the justice system/constitution. I am sure the justice system is pretty fair inside America. Bar a few cases in law, however that is because many people inside juries cannot take away emotions. Emotions =/= Law. They can’t comprehend that.</p>
<p>
The justice system is fair? Okay, way to minimize the discussion from world economics to the American justice system. Of course, it isn’t, as racism is prevalent, the poor get overworked/underpaid public defenders, and the rich can hire high-powered attorneys to get them off just about anything.</p>
<p>Now can we get back to world economics?</p>
<p>
I have a knowledge of what a strawman is. Thank you. I was talking about the justice system and rights by the constitution, and he went off talking about economics.</p>
<p>
We have been talking about communism this whole time. Your segue into the justice system was so subtle, I can’t see it. You seem to be saying the poor are fine because they have rights in the US.</p>
<p>I think the best system is going back to our hunter-gatherer days, or simply one-man-for-himself type thing.</p>
<p>
It only got to this point because you were the one talking about not caring about the poor doing what he wants overthrowing the rich, or what you might think are capatalist pigs. However, what gives them more right to overthrow a capatalist government that you think are full of rich people? Do you want a disparity in rights among the poor and rich? Do you want the poor to have more rights then the rich in accordance with the law? Since currently in Capatalistic America, the poor have the same rights as the rich. It’s just that they don’t have the same opportunities. However, opportunities aren’t for everyone, anyway, it’s pretty late, so I will elaborate more tomorrow.</p>
<p>
So, communism?</p>
<p>
So, anarchism?</p>
<p>Evolution layed out by Darwin was competition. Only the best survive. Communism only tramples on mother nature. There isn’t enough resources to equally feed everyone.</p>
<p>
Hey, kids, as you were lucky enough to be born in America, each of you could be the next President! Um, except you can’t because you’re poor. But yeah, go America!</p>
<p>
Let’s legalize murder, theft and rape. Survival of the fittest FTW!</p>
<p>
The defense of oneself and others?</p>
<p>
For it to be a “no,” there would have to be no classes.</p>
<p>
Funny thing… When you’re overthrowing a government, it’s usually an illegal action.</p>
<p>
Yes, but too few. With so few rights, it is possible for some to be rich and some to be poor, and for the rich to oppress the poor. All in accordance with the law. Thus, the law is wrong.</p>
<p>You cannot justify slavery by saying the enslaved had the right to enslave his slaver, if he had been free.</p>
<p>
Why shouldn’t everyone have the same opportunities? Shouldn’t that be a right?</p>
<p>
Take up “capitalism” next to the other atrocities committed in the name of Social Darwinism.</p>
<p>
There are, if spread evenly.</p>
<p>
You equate “best survive” economically in this case with theft, rape, and murder? I don’t even…</p>
<p>
You don’t seem to be disagreeing with what I said. Opportunities. Rich have more opportunities. Im glad you agree with me.</p>
<p>
He’s saying that if we are holding ourselves to Darwinian animal standards, all protective laws are useless. Let the weak die, so their genes aren’t passed on. Let the strong do all they can to pass their genes on. Is that what you want?</p>
<p>
They have more opportunities. The opportunities for life. To equalize the situation, we must rise.</p>
<p>
So you would support a illegal action, only if it is by someone poor? Yet you wouldn’t support a capatalistic turnover of a communistic government would you? </p>
<p>
What is wrong with classes however? Classes don’t change the amount of rights each in there gets. Acknowledging rich and the middle class isn’t bad. However, when you get to the poor inside America. Majority is due to lack of education. Now, are you going to argue with me about this? Or do you want me to pull out some sources.</p>
<p>
There are at this moment. However, communism fails long-term, in the fact that evenly spreading resources over a vast population would ofcourse deplete available resources. </p>
<p>
Why should it be? If everyone had the same opportunities, there wouldn’t be any diversity. Opportunities are a privilege, not a right. Opportunities like getting a Iphone 5 is a privilege. Not a right, wouldn’t you say? </p>
<p>
Wait, you are saying Communism gives any more rights to people? Unless you show me a example of where practiced communism actually gave more rights to the people, then I will ofcourse be convinced. Since I am 100% sure that the Soviet Union/China which were failed Communist ideals are not examples you would pull, then there no examples.</p>
<p>Anyway, im done for today. Can you reply tomorrow or something for convenience?</p>
<p>
I support those acting out of necessity. Trying to replace communism with capitalism is not necessary for anyone’s rights to life.</p>
<p>
Most poor people are poor because they were born poor. For there to be the rich, there have to be more poor, people lacking the resources the rich have in excess. If you educate one, he may rise. If you educate all, then education becomes less powerful in class and readjusts (“BA is like the new HS”).</p>
<p>And legal rights mean little when your children don’t have a home.</p>
<p>
Communism would direct all human labor to a constructive end. How many resources to we spend on killing each other for the economic interests of a few?</p>
<p>
I don’t care about the opportunity to get an iPhone, I care about an opportunity to rise from wage slavery, have a fulfilling life, have your children not lack for necessities, pursue your interests. What is equality, if we aren’t born equal? What are rights, if we don’t have the opportunities to exercise them?</p>
<p>
Basically the only example would be this: [Paris</a> Commune - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia](<a href=“http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_Commune]Paris”>Paris Commune - Wikipedia)</p>
<p>In that brief span, the communists gave the people far more rights and liberties than they had before. It wasn’t perfect communism, but it was a good thing.</p>
<p>Idealized communism, in Karl Max’s theory, is not that bad. But in practice, it’s been terrible. There has been not a single success story. That alone, shows how the theory works and how out of touch it is. Capitalism, on the other hand, has built great countries.</p>