Capitalism vs. Communism: The Showdown

<p>

The USSR and PRC never put it into practice, they just claimed communism for propaganda purposes. Just like they did for “republic.”</p>

<p>

Obviously, since the world isn’t communist.</p>

<p>

So because it hasn’t been done, it can’t be?</p>

<p>

On the backs of the poor. Neo-colonial capitalistic oppression of the third world by the first has led to the matching decline of the former and rise of the latter.</p>

<p>Part of the problem is that Russia and China were not industrial nations. Concluding that Communism fails based on their failure is a bit like a woman reading an advice guide for men on how to ask out women, finding that it doesn’t help her get dates with men and deciding that it’s bad advice. It may well be bad advice, but the experiences of someone for whom it wasn’t written are really irrelevant.</p>

<p>@DolorousEdd Yes we should just do anarchism and get it over with. No system will fit all humans, so all humans should be their own leader and do what fits them.</p>

<p>Wow, in the few days I’ve been off CC this thread has really blown up. Well, time to jump right in.</p>

<p>

That’s kind of the point. So far, the few countries that have preached communism have used communism as a power grab. </p>

<p>

There still have been no success stories.</p>

<p>

Nope, but probably not considering how large many countries are. Do you think communism can work on a mass scale as a system of government?</p>

<p>

They also used “republic” and “democracy” as power grabs. Communism shouldn’t be defined by non-communist societies.</p>

<p>

Paris Commune, if it hadn’t been crushed from the outside. Of course there haven’t been any successful world classless societies yet; we must make one.</p>

<p>

System of economy. And no, it couldn’t work as a country, it would have to be the world.</p>

<p>

But there have been “republics” and “democracies” that haven’t been power grabs. The United States is an example of this. Many people in Europe thought that George Washington was going to declare himself king and that America would have an extremely strong executive and federal government. Initially, we had a weak federal government and no executive. The USA certainly was no power grab.</p>

<p>

I don’t think a classless society is possible. I believe that it is human nature to create classes, so trying to have a classless society is ridiculous. </p>

<p>

Do you think something that has only been used as a power grab in the past a good idea to try on a world setting? Do you think that every country in the world will set aside their different ideas about government and agree to be governed under one system of government? Do you think that it is practical to try to govern the whole world from a global system instead of a national system? Has it ever been done? Are there any success stories? What would be the consequences if the system of government fails? Do you think it is worth the risk to try a system of government that has never succeeded on a global scale? How would this work economically? Would the entire world have the same currency, or would each old country keep its own currency? If the entire world conformed to a new “world currency” what do you think the economic consequences would be? Do you picture the whole world ever adapting a world communist government? Do you think this is possible? </p>

<p>Please answer all of my questions. Explain each of your answers.</p>

<p>

The first “republic” was a power-grab by Roman aristocracy. And yet, we now have a functioning democratic republic. Of course, that’s an example of an actual (albeit bad) republic, as opposed to mere propaganda.</p>

<p>

Early hunter-gatherer societies did not have social classes. Whatever the influences on class, “human nature” is not one.</p>

<p>

Would the governments agree to be dissolved into a world, classless, stateless society? Most certainly not. It would have to be the poor and working class who overthrow said governments; and, while extraordinarily difficult, it is possible to convince enough of the poor to act dramatically in their best interest.</p>

<p>

There wouldn’t be a centralized state; workers in the collective would rule, which would entail organization into sorts of communes. Of course, there would be democratic self-direction of the whole of humanity, but not a centralized state in the modern conception.</p>

<p>

Has there ever been a world communist society? You know the answer to that. “No,” or “not yet.”</p>

<p>

If it failed, it would likely dissolve back into states, some retaining democracy, others ruled by despots. That’s a risk, but it’s not very different from our current world.</p>

<p>

I do. For the millions of children starving in the dirt, it is worth it. For the oppressed workers laboring into an early grave, it is worth it. For the wage slaves kept down by the rich, it is worth it. For the whole of humanity, for the workers, for the poor, for the children, it is and always be worth great risk to save them.</p>

<p>

Organization of humanity as a whole in a democratic economy where all are equal, self-direction of humanity to a common end.</p>

<p>

Countries would be dissolved and the modern concept of money would cease. There would be a system of labor exchange, which could be seen as currency, but not necessarily in a standard way.</p>

<p>

Currency would not merely be the price of labor, nor would it fluctuate in value, nor would people measure what the have or produce in variable currency.</p>

<p>

There would be some segments of the population who would dissent, but it is as such with any change. If world communism came about, it would mean that a majority of the world’s people (mostly poor/workers) had either risen or supported the rising, so it would have to adapt. There would be the steady equalizing of wealth until Africa was no worse a place to live than America, and all would have their needs fulfilled.</p>

<p>

Such a revolution and subsequent establishment would be extraordinarily difficult, but it is possible, and I think it is worth fighting for.</p>

<p>

That is incorrect. The Roman Republic was initially founded to overthrow the Roman monarchy. </p>

<p>

Have you ever been inside a cafeteria in an educational establishment? Inside, you will find different “classes” of kids. Jocks, nerds, preps, whatever. Do you think these kids will act the same way as adults, or will they magically stop? </p>

<p>

Yep, sounds about right.</p>

<p>

Good luck with that. When you can get the poor of Israel to agree to overthrow their government with the poor of Palestine, call me.</p>

<p>

This ought to work out well.</p>

<p>

You’re proposing a version of direct democracy.I think there’s a reason why direct democracy doesn’t work. (By the way, could you please define “worker?” You’re being a little vague. Is the CEO of JP Morgan a “worker?”) The reason is that we recognize that the “worker” (or "average person) doesn’t have the knowledge in economics, history, public policy, law, international law, political theory, military strategy, and ethics to run a country directly. Do you think that the average worker has the necessary knowledge to run a country? Do you think that people act to protect their own interests?
Imagine, one “worker” given the opportunity to “rule.” Would he not only look after his own interests, or would he work for the good of society? If he has no reason to care about other people’s well being, why should he? For the good of mankind?</p>

<p>I have to go to dinner now, I’ll be back on later.</p>

<p>

…Because Tarquinius Superbus had alienated the Roman aristocracy, who then seized power. Romans could vote… out of the aristocracy.</p>

<p>

Social conditioning; each society does it different. It does not equal human nature. Anyway, there are “jocks” and “nerds” of all social classes, so they could continue to be as such in a world without them.</p>

<p>

I hope you realize we’re not talking about elections here; it requires upheaval and revolution. Tyrants seldom give power up willingly.</p>

<p>

Technically, the Revolution could be carried out wholly without either of those groups, though I think the Palestinians in refugee camps would have a lot to gain. Poor people in Israel, too, though I don’t expect the leaders or well off to join in.</p>

<p>

Mind explaining your objections? You were very insistent that I fully explain myself, yet you make comments like this.</p>

<p>

Universal education is imperative. Ignorance has been used by the ruling class to keep the poor down; that’s a reason to defy the system, not to conform to it.</p>

<p>

As in “a revolution of the workers,” I mean the proletariat, the workers who do not own the means of production, the current working class. As use in “workers’ republic” or a classless society ruled by the workers, I mean everyone, working with equal share and common lot.</p>

<p>

You are right about this. However, the Roman Republic lasted for a very long time and didn’t fail like the USSR did.</p>

<p>

I don’t think that the “jock” and “nerd” example is an example of social conditioning. It is an inevitable result of human nature. I will explain below. </p>

<p>People associate with others because they share interests. For example, the “jock” associates with the “jock” because they share an interest in sports. Likewise, the “nerd” associates with the “nerd” because they share an interest in PS3 and Counter-Strike (I’m only kidding…kind of :)). Due to their shared interest, they have something to relate to with the other party. Do you share any interests at all with your friends? Do you relate with your friends? Isn’t relating with one another how we form relationships?</p>

<p>Just like in personal relationships, we form political associations with others due to mutual interests. It’s perfectly natural. We form political associations with others because we share political interests. Bob the Farmer joins with Joe the Farmer to go to a Town Hall meeting to demand the tax on tractors be lowered. This is an example of a political association due to a mutual interest.</p>

<p>These associations provide benefits for the individuals involved that the individuals can recognize. They provide political and economic representation, protection, and influence. Bob the Farmer and Joe the Farmer get the the Mayor of the town to appeal to the governor to try to get taxes on tractors lowered. They realize these benefits.</p>

<p>By realizing these benefits, humans of all different interests will stratify society and only try to represent their own interests. Why should the “worker” try to represent the interest of the “ruling class?” It is illogical. So, once people realize the benefits of sticking together with those who share your economic interests, they recognize the existence of social classes. They will try to define their own interests, as “workers” or as “rulers.” These are social classes, are they not?</p>

<p>

You missed my point. My point is that it would be impossible to get every single poor of every country to agree to revolt over an ideology. Try convincing those in China who grew up during the Cultural Revolution…</p>

<p>

Gladly. . But first, I don’t understand how this could work economically. Without a centralized state, how will the currency be regulated? How will markets work? Will their be regulations? Without a centralized state, who will enforce these regulations? Will their be any laws, in general? How can they be enforced without a centralized state? Who will enforce them? Below, I’ll talk about education.</p>

<p>

How will we educate everyone without the centralized state? Who will design the curriculums? The “local communes?” How can we ensure that everyone receives a good enough education to govern themselves? Will there be any minimum standards? Surely there must, because we want to prepare everyone to be a “ruler,” right? Remember, everyone has to learn economics, history, public policy, law, international law, political theory, military strategy, and ethics? So, how will these be taught without a centralized state giving standards? Who would fund the schools? Without a centralized state, taxation is impossible. Is everyone capable of learning enough to govern themselves? Aren’t some people more naturally inclined toward academics than others? Doesn’t this system require everyone to have a graduate level education? Is every single human being intellectually capable of learning graduate level material? </p>

<p>And, you didn’t answer my questions: Do you think that the average worker has the necessary knowledge to run a country? and Do you think that people act to protect their own interests? Instead, you made an umbrella statement about education, and didn’t refute my specific point. Please do so in your next post.</p>

<p>

So, the current proletariat would be the ones in power. Thus, they would become the “power” class, the ones they sought to destroy. Doesn’t this seem like something that could be very easily used as a power grab? The proletariat would be in power, and if they’re the ones ruling, not everyone is equal. So, there would be class divisions, but they would be the “rulers” and not the “workers.” </p>

<p>Regardless, do you think that this wouldn’t be used as a power grab? This seems like the perfect opportunity for a power hungry individual(s) to gain power.</p>

<p>And, please answer all of my questions, including the ones you conveniently didn’t answer last time.</p>

<p>

Irrelevant to the discussion; we’re talking about pretenders. Rome technically was a republic, albeit an aristocratic one. Russia was never communist.</p>

<p>

Mutual association and social classes are two different things. You said social classes were a part of human nature; I pointed out that they didn’t exist in early human society (hunter-gatherer), you have yet to counter.</p>

<p>

All is impossible; the majority, with a beneficial geographic distribution, is not.</p>

<p>

The currency isn’t regulated, because it doesn’t work the same way. This isn’t capitalism, it’s not a market economy. Communes would, largely, be self-sufficient. Trade between them, and between workers of different communes, is necessary, though I don’t have all the details. Suffice it to say, the current system isn’t too hot anyway.</p>

<p>

First, I’d remove military strategy, as hopefully it would be unnecessary. The schools would be locally driven, but again, there would be a sort of central democratic agent, but not a powerful centralized state. Laws would be universal, and usually locally enforced. Everyone gets education to a certain point (~HS), and has the opportunity to go further, or, barring that, trade school or other skilled labor training. Remember, “From each according to his ability, to each according to his need.” Not everyone has to be a rocket scientist, but everyone should have the opportunity to go where they are able and want to.</p>

<p>

And I said: Not currently, because the poor are kept in ignorance by the rich. Of course, we’re not talking countries, and communes have more practical needs, but yes, there has to be education to help with empowerment.</p>

<p>

They do; hence their starving children prompt them to defiance. And the key is to make the interest of all mankind collective, by destroying the class system.</p>

<p>

I answered, but I just did it again, too. I go point by point through yours, while you pick and choose from mine.</p>

<p>

That is stage 1, the “dictatorship of the proletariat.” It is a part of the transition into a classless society; eventually, there will be no proletariat or bourgeois, only people. But you knew that, from the first definition of worker I gave you, which you conveniently forgot to quote.</p>

<p>

Yeah, it is. Hence, the leaders of the revolution would have to be the kind of people not to seize power, and the people of the revolution would have to be on their guard. Saying “things can go wrong” doesn’t make change from a system of starvation and oppression any less necessary.</p>

<p>

Bull- I have quoted your questions point by point with answers and explanations. Now, answer all of mine:</p>

<p>1.) Do you believe the current world system is working for all of humanity? Why or why not?</p>

<p>2.) How is it just that millionaires and billionaires live in decadent mansions and palaces while the children of the world’s poor wallow in the dirt and starve to death? What did those children do to deserve the fate?</p>

<p>3.) If communism is not the answer to these problems, then what is? What could possibly alleviate the starvation and oppression and death the world faces?</p>

<p>4.) Is capitalism even remotely functional for those not in the top few percent of the world?</p>

<p>5.) Why are you trying to micromanage the smallest issues of a commune to see if it’s okay while current world governments are oppressive, let people starve to death, and violate human rights?</p>

<p>6.) Is it okay that children in the third world are either starving to death or losing their fingers in factories making Nike shoes for 6 cents an hour? Why are the children of the rich any more deserving of life and liberty than they are?</p>

<p>7.) How can the poor or working class have economic liberty when they are basically in a system of wage slavery, in which they do not own their means of labor, not its product, but rather must sell their labor for a price significantly lower than its value, just to produce a profit for someone else? How can labor ever approach its proper value when third-party (bourgeois) profit is an issue?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>How the hell is anyone on CC supposed to answer this question?</p>