Check out A-2 - colleges supplying 50 or more applicants.
I dont see Carleton on this list. I do see Pomona (64) and Middlebury (66).
There are 2 ways to interpret this.
- Higher number of applicants points to strong premed program at these small schools.
- Lower number of applicants points to less competition from your peers applying from the same college because they are choosing other fields.
A few years ago, a parent at admitted days heard how many people apply from Stanford to medical schools and said openly that her daughter will go to MIT instead because there will be a lot less competition for med school from MIT. In this chart Stanford shows 223 to MITs 85 for a 50% larger student body size at Stanford.