Chance/ Match rural Kentucky student interested in environmental science/engineering/biology w/34 ACT, needs merit aid [4.0 GPA, <$30k]

THIS! She isn’t against engineering, and I know she is capable, but she just isn’t SURE. And that is understandable! So her dad wants to start out in an engineering major but that rules out some of the schools she otherwise loves and we could get money from, like Centre in KY.

2 Likes

We do need to add Rhodes, not sure why we haven’t! But again, it sort of depends on the money and the engineering factor.

On our tour, she liked the atmosphere at Georgia Tech and that it was in a city. She liked that it felt very diverse and the students seemed to be happy together. She has NOT gotten that same feel at other colleges that I won’t name. Her dad (an engineer) loved their course offerings and facilities.

1 Like

I have definitely added Drexel to the list, as I think she would love Philly.

I will talk to her about USC and Miami, but I think I assumed those would be too expensive, haven’t ran the NPC on them yet.

SUPER helpful, thank you so much!

1 Like

So many of the schools on the list are exactly what you mentioned, only an option if she gets merit aid which we know is a big time stretch. Just getting in seems like a big time stretch!

I SD and Idaho would not be on her list for the reasons you stated.

I am looking further at Lewis & Clark, Clark U, U Maine, Drexel, USC and U Miami.

If it is helpful, the reason she loved Wash U was that it felt inviting, collaborative, and not uber competitive. She LOVES that it is near Forest park with the Zoo and Botanical Garden for both research and pleasure. She liked the campus feel, more enclosed and cohesive. As for the programs, I think she would be great to do something like the Ampersand, which lets you cross over into different areas since she is still undecided and has so many strengths. We would do ED if we could afford it, she is that sold.

She is an enneagram 5, which means she loves to study and do a deep dive on all things, and also means she has trouble picking until she learns EVERYTHING she can about the option.

2 Likes

I note as you were describing the set up and before you got to her list, I was already thinking WashU (where my S24 is currently a junior) could be a great fit. And so I obviously agree with her reasoning!

Rhodes does offer a number of merit scholarships. D27 would need to be 100% sure about not intending to pursue engineering.

This matters! Then, D27 should definitely apply!

Yeah, basically I could have titled the thread with - she WANTS WashU but we can’t afford it without merit…

I have no idea how realistic merit is there, we would need full tuition scholarship and then could pay room and board on our own.

Does the NPC show she would receive any need based aid?

Do keep in the mind that WashU is need-blind only for direct domestic admits in ED, EA,& RD. It is not need-blind for waitlisted applicants. WashU will meet 100% demonstrated need for every applicant admitted from the waitlist.

WashU Need Blind Financial Aid Policy

My kid felt the same way about Georgia Tech when he visited. He is an engineering major there. We thought he was all set on Notre Dame or Northwestern but GT knocked his socks off when we visited and it was our last college visit. We are from a relatively OOS rural area and he has just thrived there. As has been stated, they are very tough on giving aid to OOS students. Good luck with everything she is a good candidate.

1 Like

Yes, it showed we would receive about 30K in need-based aid. We are in that upper-middle-class donut hole…

1 Like

I think the start in engineering mindset is because short of an LAC that offers a four year engineering program (Lafayette, Bucknell, Union, Trinity, etc), it’s likely hard if not impossible to transfer in. But it’s zero issue to transfer out.

So if there’s any modicum of chance, that’s the way to go vs a W&M, as an example, which doesn’t offer engineering so you’d need to do a Masters or a 3-2 like at Centre -either way more school.

My guess is if she’s not sold on engineering, it’s likely not for her but if it might be, that’s the way to go - in my opinion.

That is good to hear! I wish we were in-state or had a similar option here in Ky…

How has the transition been for him from rural to urban area? And does he feel lots of pressure in their engineering program? I often worry because thus far, everything has been
“easy” for my daughter. Having nothing to compare it to, I worry about a rigorous first year shock to her system!

This is sound advice. We only added William and Mary because I got some feedback that it was similar to WashU in “vibes” if nothing else.

Centre has a 3+2 engineering degree WITH WashU…so that could be a plan for her. She is a great candidate for their Lincoln Scholar program, but who knows the odds there.

USC and Miami meet need whereas Drexel doesn’t make that assurance.

I’m a big fan of finding some that meet your budget up front b4 the possibility of merit. Of course, if you are applying to UK, Louisville, WKU, Murray Stare, etc. you already have that covered.

Question- have you run the NPCs on schools that only offer need based aid, to see if they’re feasible? As a high stats kid from KY, she’ll be very desirable. The threshold for need varies from school to school- for example, there are families at Harvard making over $200k receiving need based aid.

I’m also from KY, our S23 is an engineering major at Brown, our D26 is at Vassar. If you’d like to DM me, I’m happy to give more details. In my son’s class, there were only 13 kids from KY his freshman year- it’s definitely a hook.

For your DD, check out Brandeis- it initially came in on the higher side tuition wise, then they offered D26 a merit scholarship that brought the cost way down. Strong in science, they have an Environmental Studies BA program that’s quite interesting along with a minor in Climate Justice, Science & Policy. Mid-sized and in a great location.

She also received fantastic FA from Dickinson, which has both Enviro Science and Enviro Studies, as well as a huge organic farm on campus. Lots of ES majors and a beautiful campus, strong merit aid and lots of study abroad options. Also consider Smith, it has both Engineering as well Enviro Science, tons of fantastic research opportunities, and does offer some merit awards. Same with Mount Holyoke - minus the engineering. Very impressive schools if your DD would consider HWCs.

Your DD will be competitive for the Lincoln Scholarship, my kids both have friends at Centre who like it quite a bit- I’m glad to arrange a tour w a current student if you want the behind the scenes/non-admissions dept experience. My spouse is a prof at Transy- she should also apply for their Premier Scholarships, they’ve expanded the number of full tuition scholarships in the past year, she’d be competitive. Also, for her awards list- are those how they are listed in her CA? If so, you might consider re-ordering them a bit. The Yarmuth Book Award and KyAEA awards will be more impressive than NHS or graduation usher. Best of luck!

3 Likes

If abortion-related restrictions and their additional effects on women’s health care are a criterion, you and the student may want to check listing of what the status is in each state.

2 Likes

I’m not sure from a female access POV there’s much difference from some states listed like Missouri, and some I listed. I may be wrong. But WUSTl, of course, is a reach.but I don’t think Missouri is friendly to issues raised.

If you end up the LAC route, check Whitman. If she likes Atlanta, check Ogelthorpe. Whitman is in Walla Walla so cute town and nature and says you’ll be charged 10% of income. Ogelthorpe is in a wealthy part of Atlanta and you can take classes at Tech and Emory (but have to get there). They would charge you UK tuition.if she’s ok with small and female, Agnes Scott is another in Atlanta, same consortium as Ogelthorpe. So may get close to budget.

1 Like

You are. Quite a difference in health care access between Missouri and both Idaho and SD. Just look at some of the sources UCBalumnus linked.

3 Likes

I will look at these. We make over 200K, so that is out. But we did run the NPCs all the ones that I have listed that she is applying to. She is not interested in a HWC but I love Brown…just not sure she has a shot there?

IF she were to get the Lincoln scholarship at Centre, she would run toward it and not look back. It offers some great opportunities and I think it would help her forget that it is in a small town.

She is applying to Transy and will apply for their Premier, so it is on the table. Northern KY, Western, Louisville, MSU are no’s for her.

I copied this list from her brag sheet, but I will pass that on. I am going to DM you with some other questions!

1 Like