Chance me ED 2 Boston College, US[+Canada] citizen from small Canadian town weak ECs[4.0 UW, Test optional]

I note that as many smart and ambitious kids get going with their actual college experience, they start understanding college more as an opportunity for an education and other experiences, and less as a badge of merit determined solely by the name on your sweatshirt.

This is part of why so few people actually do transfer, even though more surely could. They quickly realize that doing really well at their college is going to actually give them the experiences and opportunities they want, and that transferring would disrupt that path for no good reason.

Of course you don’t have to decide that now, but I think you would benefit from being open to the possibility of coming to a similar realization. Meaning pick the best bet for the best possible experience, and only transfer if you really end up thinking that would actually be in your interests.

7 Likes

This.

Also don’t count on getting accepted as a transfer to tippy top schools many of which take very few transfers, and sometimes…zero.

4 Likes

Well I know, I’m not talking Harvard, Yale, Stanford etc. I mean places like USC, Emory, Wash U, which have transfer rates ~ 20% and reaching for places like Dartmout, Penn, Duke, Notre dame, G-Town which have rates from 5-10% I’m not counting on anything, but I don’t think there’s any harm in trying to transfer. It’s just more motivation to do well first year.

Or a recipe not to engage and enjoy your first year.

What did you decide?

You want to be an engineer - you’re not getting any farther with the schools you mentioned than UMN.

2 Likes

And transfer rates vary from year to year.

I hope you have chosen a college where you can stay, reach your goals and can pay the bills to attend.

Which college did you choose - did top ChemE win out or Honors/Jesuit education? Minneapolis/Saint Paul or Chicago?

1 Like

Loyola. My parents said if I’m thinking about transferring then I should go to the cheapest option and somewhere I would have the better chance of sucess off the bat. Also at Loyola I’m in their ā€œAcheiving college excellenceā€ program some federal government TRIO SSS thing I’m not super sure, I’m eligible since I have a learning disability. I get access to 1-on-1 tutoring and mentoring with that program so that’s a bonus. I mean techically if I change my mind I have until June 1st for UMN.

9 Likes

Congratulations! :confetti_ball:
The decision sounds well-thought out and Loyola is close to your former favorite, Holy Cross, in personality. :clap::sparkles:
I hope you return in the fall and let us know how it’s going, the good, the bad, the surprising :slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

I know a Canadian there now (transfer from McGill). Absolutely loves it. Very different from the typically impersonal Canadian university experience.

2 Likes

Out of curiosity, does anyone know how possible it is to transfer to either ND or Georgetown after your first year? I know it’s hard but is it as bad as trying to transfer to like Harvard, Yale etc. which I know are impossible unless you’re military.

Look up the Common Data Set for each school, scroll to Section D. You’ll see admissions numbers and minimum and maximum credits allowed for transfer applicants. Also, go to the transfer admission webpage for each school to learn about the processes.

Better yet, don’t start your freshman year in a mindset to transfer. It will prevent you from engaging at your school and could make for an unsatisfactory experience. Give it a fair shake.

2 Likes

I guess you don’t want to be an engineer after all.

If you go into your first year looking to transfer, then you won’t enjoy your first year.

Go to your school with the idea that you’re going to love it. You’ll be far from the only accomplished student there.

You already couldn’t make cost at other schools like Holy Cross - you didn’t have the need you thought you did - why would it change.

At Notre Dame, you cannot get a merit scholarship as a transfer.

Gtown admitted 296 of 2241 and UND 232 of 842 but don’t forget, they have a transfer agreement with Holy Cross (not your Holy Cross).

Notre Dame says you’ll need a 3.75 while Gtown shows a B+. Your high school record will also be evaluated.

You confuse me but obviously you’ve decided against engineering (or Gtown wouldn’t be on your list).

I hope you go to Loyola to excel. Thinking about transferring already doesn’t set you up for an enjoyable first year.

You are looking at a chemistry degree. The where isn’t going to matter - it’s a tough degree to translate to the job market.

Good luck.

3 Likes

Well, I’m in hot water again. I don’t think i’ll be attending loyola due to significant increase in cost. My backup was Penn State Altoona but housing is on a waitlist. I’m in big trouble guys what do I do?? I could call up ASU or UA.

1 Like

Did you ask Penn State Altoona if housing is available at other campuses
ā€œ Students also may request to change their campus to one at which housing is available. To discuss changing campuses, please contact the Office of Admission….ā€ See the PSU Altoona website.

Well I’m considering community college then transferring after a year, it would be the same situation with penn state Altoona since they don’t offer Chem E or Bio E and most people do 2+2 but i’d go somewhere else after a year. I’m thinking of Santa monica college in Socal since I have a cousin who just transferred from there to UCLA and they are known for being a good destination for transfer students. I’m concerned about doing community college here in Canada since I doubt it would be accredited. Well at Loyola they bumped the bill up like a lot from the preliminary financial aid offer.

Sorry to hear Loyola is too expensive.
What is your budget?
What about UMN or FSU?

UMN likley doesn’t have room this late, especially for Chem E or any engineering. I’m planning to try to transfer next year to somewhere. Maybe that means starting at ASU, Altoona, CC etc. Well I’ll be 100% honest, I never truly wanted to go to Loyola. My parents wanted me to cause it was really cheap. Now that it looks like Loyola won’t be possible there are a lot of potential pathways.

Please focus advice on this student’s path forward. Castigating them on past decisions holds no value. The primary purpose of CC is to support students. Thanks for posting with that goal in mind.

5 Likes