Chance me for Ivys, BS/MD Programs, NYU, and Swarthmore

I don’t have an A in Geometry, Algebra 2, and Chemistry

Semesters or full year? Any grades below B?

Full Year. Only C I ever had in my life was Freshman Year Geometry… Hoping to negate some of the impact of that by doing well on the SAT.

Having 3 full year grades below an A, including one C will impact decisions at some schools. A good SAT score will not negate a C in geometry. All you can do is control what you can control. Get good grades this semester. Prep for the SAT, knowing you will have to do better on that than you did on the PSAT. Have you taken all CollegeBoard’s bluebook SAT practice tests?

Putting in a strong QB app will give you your greatest chance to be accepted to the type of school you are targeting. Please work hard on your QB app over the summer, it is quite time consuming and will be due at the end of September. I would prioritize QB app over your BS/MD apps.

Edit: You didn’t respond to the DE calc question. Is taking AP Calc AB or BC an option next year rather than DE calc? AP is generally perceived to be more rigorous than DE.

2 Likes

I will take a wild guess. Of course predicting the future is inherently risky and I might end up being off base one way or another.

With a 3.8 unweighted GPA I would be surprised if you were accepted to any of NYU, Columbia, U.Penn, Princeton, Swarthmore, Harvard, Northwestern, or Chicago. I also would be surprised if you were accepted into any BS/MD program. I do not know Sophie Davis at all and cannot predict anything about it.

I think that your chances are quite good at most of the rest of your list, and that any of them can prepare you very well to apply to medical schools in the future, or for a wide range of other possible paths that you might choose to take.

I think that affordability is just as important as getting admitted.

I think that to get admitted to medical school at some point in the future you should do your best to learn what to do to get A’s or at least B’s in the toughest university classes (eg, sit in the front row, always pay attention, keep way ahead in reading and homework, start the homework the day that it is assigned, ask for help early whenever you have any questions at all, keep a list of all work that you need to get done, …). You can get to medical school with a few C’s, but you need to get as few of these as possible and you will have quite a few very tough classes as an undergraduate student taking premed classes.

If you get accepted to medical school, then affordability will probably continue to be an issue.

And I wonder whether you should trim the “reach” part of your list.

4 Likes

With a C in geometry and a B in Algebra 2, you show some “weakness” in math - and then a B in Chem.

I would say you’re unlikely for any school below not counting the BS/MD which I don’t know about. You should take AP Calc unless you’re not at that level. DE won’t help.

I do think you will get into Rutgers assuming a 1400+ SAT and Kean - but since you’ll be free at Rutgers, you wouldn’t go to Kean.

That’s my chance me on these schools. A school like Richmond and Lehigh (says need blind for most) are both need blind or almost need blind - so they would be not great, but better odds.

New York University (NYU)

Columbia University

University of Pennsylvania

Rutgers BA/MD program

Sophie Davis BS MD program

Rowan BS/MD

Montclair State University BS/MD

NYIT BS/DO program

Princeton University

NJIT BS/MD

Kean University

Swarthmore University

Harvard University

Northwestern

UChicago

Have you done any shadowing?

While I see that you have some clinical experience (EMS volunteer), it is important to spend time shadowing and speaking with physicians so that you know what the job entails on a day-to-day basis.

Note: I would prioritize Questbridge and additional meets full need schools over BS/MD.

2 Likes

They are an option, but I would have to get a 95% and above in pre-calculus which I don’t have.

I’m going to do shadowing over the summer!

1 Like

That’s good. It is hard to know if the job is for you until you shadow and speak with physicians about their daily grind and routine. And even then it might be hard….

2 Likes

NYU’s ED I will make it much easier for me to get in. To quote another user

NYU’s ED I pool is filled with people who often don’t have the strongest application but still send it because NYU is more of a dream school for its environment than purely its academics, causing a lot of academic oriented kids not to apply there first. Not to mention, NYU has a reputation of taking students with slightly weaker academics as opposed to other top universities.

Additionally, NYU does not have as much as athletic recruitments (like these other selective schools do) coming in through ED which can alter some of these numbers.

Your logic AND your math is off.

Apply to NYU Early if it is your clear first choice, and is highly likely to be affordable based on the Net Price calculator. Whatever advantage you think you will get from an early application is “statistical noise” and not relevant for you. You are assuming facts not in evidence.

5 Likes

“Much” is maybe a bit strong. Is there an ED advantage - yes. Does that make it “easy” - no. And please don’t be misled by “easier stats”. Their published stats are influenced by Tisch admissions, where portfolios/auditions carry significant weight and can offset lower academic stats. To a lesser extent it is also affected by the NY HEOP cohort. If you’re applying to CAS, or even Gallatin as you indicated before, the overall numbers are not the stats pool you’re competing with. My daughter went in through liberal studies (her second choice) and said that almost everyone in her cohort was Ivy reject - that was the academic level of the group. Yes they may have been Ivy reject because they had 3.85 or 3.9 instead of 4.0… but that’s pretty much where you are. And… a lot of them were in LS as second choice (mostly vs CAS). I am not saying you wouldn’t get in - I think you are a competitive candidate in the right range (pending SAT) - but this and your other posts seem to indicate a level of confidence here that I don’t think is warranted.

3 Likes

You did ask what I thought. Knowing what I know, which isn’t everything, that’s my prediction. You asked.

In the end, only NYU and only after you apply can answer you.

NYU is known not to be generous so run that NPC before applying ED - and ensure you have the 2nd parent situation handled. I wouldn’t tell anyone it’s an immigration marriage etc which could get mom in hot water.

Having a test will help at NYU. I’m not sure ED will as they black out the data in the CDS.

In the end, you’ll take your shot. But you asked to guess so I said unlikely.

Having a 1500+ SAT could help. If your school scores low overall on SAT, maybe you can go lower but 1480 is the 25th percentile - but their test submission rate is low.

I do wonder if at schools where you apply for a major if you should go non stem given the weakness relative to the rest of your studies.

Also don’t forget the Providence Roddy and W&L who meets need, but the Johnson is even better.

First gen is a good thing for these type programs I’m guessing.

Be the best you - apply to a wide range selectivity wise and you have Rutgers as a safety valve.

Then you needn’t worry about what others think. We are neither accepting nor denying you for NYU. They will be the ones to do so.

Apply if you want and if it looks affordable based on the NPC. ED might give you an edge, but I would not call it easy. Apply and see.

Why NYU for premed?

You can not apply ED to any school if you do QB and rank colleges.

https://questbridge.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/218777177-Can-I-apply-Early-Decision-or-Early-Action-ED-EA-to-other-colleges-and-rank-colleges-for-the-Match

If I were your college counselor, I would say that you are probably better off applying to QB and ranking 15 colleges than applying to NYU ED. But obviously that choice is ultimately yours.

7 Likes

I think OP said before they would do ED2 if QB doesn’t work out.

1 Like

I did say this, but now that I think of it, my only fear of doing this is this comment from a user on the college forum:

“NYU’s ED I pool is filled with people who often don’t have the strongest application but still send it because NYU is more of a dream school for its environment than purely its academics, causing a lot of academic oriented kids not to apply there first. Not to mention, NYU has a reputation of taking students with slightly weaker academics as opposed to other top universities. However, NYU is one of the best schools in the US that does offer an ED2. This causes rejects from schools like Wharton, Cornell, and other ivy leagues or slightly better schools to take their shot at NYU next as their first choice only had an ED1, causing NYU’s ED2 to be way more competitive.”

If it wasn’t clear from my earlier post, I think the first part of that argument is flawed. As for the second part, I don’t know how accurate it is. Wouldn’t most Ivy ED rejects prefer to take their chances with other ivies RD than commit to NYU? I can see a Wharton reject applying to Stern ED2 but in general, I don’t buy it. From what I recall of their presentation, they said the profile of admitted students in both ED cohorts is very similar.

2 Likes

I don’t think applying to Gallatin makes much sense for me. I’ll go with CAS and hope to do their double major program in Global Health and Biology. If I don’t get into QB, I can ED1 there