You’re in NJ. Why don’t you attend a visit day at NYU and see what they say? You can ask them about ED2 if they don’t bring it up first. Presentation I referred to above was from that.
If you don’t become a QB finalist you can apply ED1 anywhere. If you become a QB finalist (and ranked schools) you can’t apply ED1. Just clarifying the QB terminology. There’s not really a such thing as ‘getting in to QB.’
I agree with others that your assessment of NYU ED1 and ED2 cohorts (and competitiveness) is likely off/not supported by facts.
So NYU’s ED pool is filled with “Hail Mary Pass” applicants who just want to live in NYC but aren’t serious about academics?
Did you hear this from an actual NYU Adcom or admissions representative? If not, I’d discount it by a huge amount. Most ED applicants at NYU are serious contenders for admissions. The kids for whom Cal Tech or Princeton are the top choice are NOT applying to NYU ED– because NYU is binding. Is that what you mean by “a lot of academic oriented kids not to apply there first”??? If so- yes, that’s true. But it’s irrelevant to YOUR situation.
“I think people are basing it off empirical evidence”
Do you know what empirical evidence is? It’s the exact opposite of the logic (conjecture, wishful thinking, confusing correlation with causation) you are citing here.
Again- run the NPC’s. If NYU is affordable and your “ride or die” first choice, then go for it. But if you are trying to game NYU admissions, that’s a game you can’t win. They can see the entire applicant pool- you can’t. They know how many kids who play the harp, how many play bridge, how many math geniuses vs. how many professional ballet company dancers are in the applicant pool and you do not.
You are YOU. Figure out what you can afford. And focus on QB and being the best HS junior you can be– whatever those skills and interests are.
Why NYU? Besides the supposed ED1 situation. There are a lot of great schools, including many / most of the QB schools. Why so much focus on NYU? Not saying it’s not a good school, my D29 is focused on it too, and I ask her the same question. As long as you have a good list of schools you are very confident you will both get into and be able to afford, go for whichever schools your heart wants, but know why.
You are a junior. I would focus on taking the SAT or ACT and creating an appropriate list of Questbridge schools. I would include Skidmore and Richmond, for example.
The 25% SAT at NYU is 1480, and the ACT is 34.
I think NYU will be a tough admit, but who am I to say. Be careful not to underestimate premed classes.
Here’s my thought on BS/MD programs. Just…don’t. You don’t want to make that decision while you’re still in high school. College is a maturation process where students find their real passions. Chances are, you will choose a different path, and you don’t want to be stuck in a school, studying something you find out you probably won’t like. For now, just focus on getting into an affordable school with flexibility. If you do decide medical school, top grades and MCAT scores will do most of the talking.