OK - thanks for the update:
Elon is safe - but Elon tuition and room and board is over $60K and I don’t think merit is plentiful. So in that sense, it makes it a reach. Elon is smaller than Charleston - but that you like the Charleston location tells me you should remove Elon altogether - as there’s merely a strip within walking distance.
College of Charleston - you’ll get into - but likely no merit. If you just look at tuition, room and board (not other things like personal, transportation that schools quote), it’s in budget. But I can tell you, as a C of C parent, when you move off campus - the rent alone is likely to be more than room and board (unless you live far away).
You might look at UT Chattanooga as a sub for Charleston - similar size, access to a cool, touristy city close by.
Bama - agreed safety - and you get $6K off if your 1250 isn’t superscored. The school is in budget. A similar school - sports, good spirit, etc. and even cheaper will be Mississippi State.
Target - Va Tech - you’re up there in budget but right there (but don’t forget inflation). I’d put it at slight reach. Auburn might be a bit easier subt or one to consider.
Penn State - another enrocaching on your budget (inflation will raise costs in future years) - more likely than Va Tech but getting branched is possible.
U of SC - we saw kids with your stats deferred - target is fine but could go either way.
UTK is likely, not assured.
CU Boulder won’t make budget - so I’d remove. A like school - Arizona. If you want a Colorado school, then Colorado State makes budget - not by a ton, but makes it. If you want cheaper and same region and it’s a bit of an off name, but Wyoming. Or if you want Winter, Montana is brining in kids from outside. Another cheap one in the “region” would be UNM.
Pitt - apply early - go TO, and it’s 50/50 but you have as a target.
A&M, like CU Boulder, not a budget fit. So I’d remove. But Texas Tech, Oklahoma, and as you like city, you might especially like Arkansas - these would all make sense.
Other biggies that make sense for you - WVU, Michigan State, Kansas, etc.
Smaller, closer to home but still big sports - JMU, App State, UNC Wilmington - budget, sports wise (UNCW doesn’t have football, but either does C of C). A bit more rural - but still enough there - and might meet your needs spirit and sports wise. - Ohio U and Miami Ohio.
As for your reaches, I agree - based on your SAT. Perhaps FSU will come in at Summer admit - but you know, if you don’t try, you’ll never know. All are within budget - but like Va Tech and Penn State, Clemson is awfully close so if I were going to cut one, it’d be it. Based on what you like, UMN might be a solid sub or if you want to be down south, a UCF.
So I might refine my list a bit based on financials and I gave some thoughts above.
Best of luck to you.