Great list of acceptances (so far). It may be hard to choose. Congrats.
Do you still have full ride at the Florida schools? I thought they limit the amount of NMFs now - guess come first serve. You might check into that. It used to be no limit but I thought they changed a few years ago.
UCF, as an example, notes “considered” - here’s the official statement - - If you advance to become a National Merit Finalist and designate UCF as your “first-choice” with the National Merit Scholarship Corporation by the May 31 deadline, you will be considered for an increased award from UCF.
Also, Bama does not include food but does 4k a year which will cover. But does give a 5th year of tuition so if a student wants to pursue the STEM To MBA or law school (they are highly ranked), it could help.
Finally, Bama has metallurgical (materials in the dept name but not degree) so no ABET accreditation in Materials nor does USF which seems to run Materials through the ChemE program. Does that matter? FSU doesn’t have - only in the Masters - and FSU engineering (sounds like you got the OOS waiver) - FSU is off campus as they share an engineering campus with FAMU (an HBCU) which is off both campuses - so you have to get there each day…so in addition to having the major undergrad, does being off campus matter? For my son, it did so we quickly removed it after visiting and following the route.
There’s only 80 accredited Materials programs in the country so that may matter to her (or not given others consider it through the prime major).
Given you have two, a limited budget, and the “where’ is highly unlikely to matter, I hope you choose the gift of free - or close to it.
At Bama and not pushing it, they’ll have their own dorm room with shared bathroom with one other in Ridgecrest Hall….does that matter? Check the others to see if they have the same.
I will tell you this - No matter which freebie the student chooses, they will be surrounded by other NMFs, with Bama being the most. Bama is near 1K or at 1K. UCF says 340, etc. So lots of bright kids all over - but sounds like she’s major specific and few on your list are accredited in Materials with your list.
A&M with 18 reporting in 2024 showed a $77.4K salary in major. No knowledge rate - meaning what % reported. Bama, as a counter, shows an 80% knowledge rate so 80% of kids reported - $77.5K salary but this was in engineering - not metallurgical specifically - as they did not break out any majors….just as a counterpoint - but the outcomes, regardless of where, likely won’t be much different at any school - but rather based on location.
But I do think studying what you want - and not every school will have it specifically (as only 80 do nationally - and your list includes many that don’t), should matter - although that’s up to your student.
Awesome opportunities - a true embarrassment of riches, especially if you grab the NMF at one of the schools.
Good luck.
We visited some colleges last week in Midwest trip and she liked the colleges but couldn’t able to justify the high cost (UIUC at 62k and Purdue at 46k) for out of state. She almost decided to attend in state Texas A&M and she liked the research (materials under extreme environments) and program (materials engineering major with nuclear engineering minor) there with ABET certification and cost is also affordable (15k) with NMF and skip ETAM. Out of the 4 reaches (Cornell, UPenn, Northwestern and Umich), she got rejected to 3 colleges and waitlisted to UMich.
Thanks everyone for all the suggestions and comments. It was really helpful to make decision.
Sorry if I missed it in your post. What was the decision?
You said she almost decide to attend A&M - but never said where she decided to attend.
She hasn’t committed yet but most likely chose Texas A&M in the next couple of weeks. She still thinking about UT Dallas in state for full ride and switch to Materials engineering instead of computer science, only issue is it’s not ABET certified.
You might seek their outcomes in the area. They don’t have a ChemE either.
Just curious - with NMF and I know you had Alabama on an initial list - why not go there and they have Mechatronics and Materials - vs. UTD. I believe you are Jewish - and you have a very strong and populous Hillel at Bama. Just wondering because with UTD and NMF, you get similar at Bama. The major is Metallurgical and Material - and Metallurgical is ABET accredited per the school.
I see it as UTD (but a more traditional college like A&M whereas UTD), a strong Hillel/Jewish population and the major with less risk. And a financial windfall.
Just curious as to why it was eliminated - not suggesting you alter the plan.
Is your daughter a senior or a junior?
They are Seniors with decisions in (two students/two threads) - on business and one engineering
This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.