You are looking for value with a big ‘oomph’ in placement but then you worry that being an American overseas won’t deliver that oomph.
Personally I think you’ve got to want the experience.
Given it’s all a risk and you won’t know until four years, it seems an awfully big step to take - unless the student wants to take that step.
In that case it’s worth it.
In essence, take out the hopes for career outcome.
What collegiate experience does the student truly want ? Maybe that should be the focus ? Four years is a long long time to choose a school for a reason that might not pan out vs. I’d love the experience.