Deadline Approaching, need help choosing a school [NCSU $23k, Purdue $42k, GT $52k, Duke $93k, Alabama $7k first year, $22k after]

I have only a few weeks to make a final decision on a school and am still unsure what to do. I applied as various engineering majors to each school, but still don’t really know which specific field within engineering I want to pursue (I was going to determine this over the summer).

I am a NC resident and am choosing between NC State, Purdue, Georgia Tech, Duke, and U of Alabama.

I did not get any financial aid from Duke (all in $93,000 per year), so I will most likely not being doing that but still wanted to put that out there in case somebody had a different opinion on the ROI. I have the Presidential Elite scholarship to Alabama which is a full ride. NC State I have a $16k scholarship on top of in-state tuition. Purdue and Tech are both full price out of state.

I also got Honors to UNC with a fellowship and assured admission into the Kenan-Flagler Business School, but I am scared to venture off of the engineering path. If this has a higher or equivalent ROI to the other schools, I have no loyalty toward engineering, it was just the path I have always been on.

I was wondering what you would recommend I do in this situation, I would really appreciate feedback I am so stuck lol.

Just an FYI, Duke and GA Tech had been my dream schools, so that may be why I am holding on to them. Ideally I want to go to GA Tech but would rather not put myself in a bad financial situation.

2 Likes

Which schools require more loans than the $27K total ($5.5K first year) that you, the student, can take out over four years? Start there to eliminate schools.

It’s great to have the Alabama full ride…how do you like that school? Have you visited?

If NC State and UNC are affordable they also seem like good options…but UNC sounds like it depends on how wedded you are to engineering. If you really want engineering, then drop UNC. I don’t think anyone can accurately assess ROI differences between UNC KF and engineering at your other schools.

If ROI were the main factor, you would choose either the no cost or one of the lowest cost options, right?

6 Likes

I guess Duke is out (too much). Perdue is out (not front runner and OOS).

Now you have
GaTech 50K
NC State ?
UNC ?
Alabama free…
List for these 4 COA (inlcude travel) , your major there…

2 Likes

I agree with eliminating Duke unless your parents can readily afford it and there’s something about it you love.

I agree with saying no to UNC - you can’t do engineering there and you gave no indication of wanting to do business.

So first off - congrats - you have wonderful options.

The first cut is ALWAYS budget. Can your family afford your options? Do they want to afford your options?

There is no denying that in some cases, some schools do carry more weight than others - so a Ga Tech and Purdue are wonderful.

At the same time, that might help sometimes, but in general - if you were a MechE for example, ABET matters most.

My kid chose Bama (not for the money but because he got his own room) - and he’s in a program at work with kids from Purdue, Michigan, etc. etc. but his company also hires Akron, W Michigan - and more. That’s the ABET is equalizing, etc.

When my kid interned during the summer, he roomed with two Ga Tech kids who interned at the same company. He went back a second year; they weren’t invited back.

So yes, some schools are more reputed but it doesn’t mean you can’t have a similar outcome.

Assuming all are in budget - and fortunately, Ga Tech and Purdue are “lower cost” compared to others - then it’s into more:

You don’t know what you want to major in - well maybe Purdue is great for that - as you start as an FYE - but at the same time - you need to meet certain qualifications to get the major of your choice. How is it at the others (secondary admission - you might look).

Ga Tech is urban - just North of downtown. NC State is - almost suburban - but not far from urban - and while my son was admitted, he declined it in part because of the separate engineering campus - is that something that you’re ok with - going back and forth?

Purdue is in a small city - but it has everything - but an hour from the airport, two from Chicago. Fantastic campus. Check the housing situation - when my son was deciding, they were housing people off campus and he did not want that. I believe in the five years since - that’s been resolved. @momofboiler1 and others who post only have the greatest to say about the Purdue experience.

Bama - let’s be honest - they buy kids in. The housing is great, the weather fine and the campus is gorgeous - immaculate, clean and the engineering quad is tremendous. But Presidential elite is not a full ride - it’s four years tuition, one year housing (so figure $10K for housing in other years) and does not include food. So maybe you’re 12-15K a year after the first. But you also get another $1K a year (put toward board) in scholarship, $500 for books each year and a one time $2K stipend - maybe you go abroad in a summer and use toward that.

You don’t have a bad choice - including Duke - but if it were me, I’d look at:

  1. Budget - what can your parents afford or more importantly what do they want to afford

  2. Secondary admissions - will I be able to get the major, whatever it is, that I ultimately decide to study.

  3. Environment - am I ok urban? Am I ok with a 20 minute walk or bus ride to another campus? Or do I want to leave my state (NC State is fine)

There’s really no wrong choice here - you can be very successful from any of them. That said, removing Duke, there’s no doubt that Ga Tech and Purdue have the name “cache” - but is that extra - whatever it is - $100K+ over Bama and the delta to NC State - worth having that “cache”. Only you can decide.

Admittedly, I wanted my son to choose Purdue. We didn’t have your level of scholarship at Bama but saved about $80K. My son told me the cache was overrated - and at least in his case, he was right.

But only you can decide - I’d first figure out, which would you really want to be at? And then go from there - to the - ok I want school X - do mom and day have a way to pay?

No need to take loans!!

Best of luck.

6 Likes

Tech: $52k Aerospace
NC State: $22k (Applied as biomedical but has a very flexible 1st year engineering program)
UNC: $25k (Finance)
Alabama: MechE (To clarify the scholarships covers tuition and first year housing only).

All Annual Costs :frowning:

To clarify Alabama scholarship covers tuition and first year housing.

Can your family afford GaTech without loans?
Explain why it is your dream school.

2 Likes

Also given so many different majors , we are comparing apples to oranges…
What do you want to do?

1 Like

If I am going to be honest, I don’t want to do engineering long term. I felt it allowed me to be the most flexible in the job market. My end goal is to work with people, I am much more business minded and I would love to do something like technical sales.

They technically could, but my sister is about to go to college as well. They also want me to “have some skin in the game” but want me to be happy and succeed. I think I could leave Tech with around 50k in loans.

Open excel and list 10 important criterias for you one at each line. Vibe, location, ability to switch major, dorms, need to hunt for housing, food, abilty to get home quickly, etc.
Rank each category 1-10 in 4 colums (one column at each school). Grand total each column… Think. Come back and tell us what you think…

1 Like

Will do.

I can help you with GaTech. I am alumni and have a daughter there now.
Food -bad.
Dorm -guaranteed only first year now.
Maybe second. Now nightmare for upper classes. First year dorms are so, so…
Switching majors used to be easy, but now they start to put more stops. (Too many students want CS).

Nope do not do loans!!! Sounds like GaTech is out. You can’t take so much loans by yourself…

That covers tuition all years, but housing and food only the first year (so about $15k per year afterward). In addition, there are $7k of non-billed costs estimated. So it should be estimated as $7k first year and $22k per year after.

4 Likes

Do you think the opportunities out of NC State and GA Tech will be similar, that is my only concern. I live close to campus and I have many friends attending, those are the positives.

Also to clarify on NC State the scholarship is $4k per year, $16k total. I should have worded that better.

You need to go from your end goals and available money. You do not have clear goals… That is the problem.

Go to UNC then. If you have assured admittance to KF that is huge!

10 Likes

Yes - Bama says $22k in the title - but that’s not right. Way too high. I paid $4K a year tuition and didn’t spend close to $22K a year. And my kid lived off campus the last three years, right next to campus (in an apartment next to the law school). About $750 a month with utilities.

I’d say $5K first year (board) although it’ll be less - and $14K each other - worst case. So under $50K all four years.