Interesting list of schools for one ranked 1/184. Surprised that your daughter was not offered more generous merit scholarship awards to the schools at which she was accepted. Are you and your daughter comfortable sharing any standardized test scores such as the ACT or SAT ?
This may change within hours upon arrival on campus for the Fall semester.
Reasonable plan.
Correct.
Has she expressed strong interest in any of these schools to you and to the admissions officers at these schools ? (I read in one of your prior posts that her top choice LAC was Wash & Lee; is this still accurate ?)
P.S. Has your daughter considered taking a gap year after graduation from high school and reapplying to colleges next cycle ?
With respect to her current options, I think that you have received great advice thus far in this thread. Although I have some thoughts, my dominant thought is that any student who is giving serious consideration to Swarthmore College and is being considered for admission by Swarthmore College should have a different list of options, therefore I suggest that she give earnest thought about taking a gap year to work or travel and reapplying next cycle with a revamped application.
If you might be interesting in survey-based information pertaining to campus atmosphere, note that HWS appears in this Princeton Review result of colleges with the “friendliest students”:
Many who are interested in rushing a sorority show up on campus with several special outfits and coordinated accessories for the events. Probably harder to easily change one’s mind if not able to do some serious shopping unless they attend a school that doesn’t do rush activities until second semester.
Many large national/international law firms, prominent law firms, and elite federal government law offices have formal paralegal programs for recent college graduates. Typically, these programs ask for a 2 year commitment. To the best of my knowledge, these Biglaw & mid-size prominent law firms recruit from top tier universities and the most highly ranked LACs.
Exposure to some aspects of the inner workings at a major law firm helps one to better understand the profession; association with other high achieving potentially law school bound peers can be motivational and add a higher level of seriousness for the law school admissions process.
Those who we knew in such programs came from (US News’ rankings) Top 15 National Universities and Top 5 LACs, although I suspect that many other colleges & universities were represented. If I recall correctly, a high college GPA was expected and there was/is a minimum required GPA (probably above a 3.50).
FWIW I know one student who responded to 3 posted paralegal positions and was given interviews at all 3. (Two in DC & one in NYC). The DC options were with the most prestigious / respected firm, a Biglaw firm Washington DC office, and with the most prestigious prosecutor’s office in the nation (Southern District of New York) in a specialized unit/division. To the best of my knowledge, these positions are not posted/recruited at non-elite, highly ranked schools, but I am judging only by the results of those who were offered and accepted one of these paralegal positions.
This has changed at many schools. They issue t-shirts for those rushing and everyone wears shorts and tennis shoes.
Now I’m not saying that there isn’t a lot that goes into hair and makeup and even jewelry, but the days of Lilly Pulitzer dresses have past on many campuses.
As your goal is to select one school, your decision to eliminate Kenyon on price makes sense. If you were loving this and would say yes if they met your price, an appeal could be worthwhile, but to appeal simply to have it remain an option seems unnecessary.
Vibe-wise, I’d have guessed that Dickinson might have been the top choice as it may have the mildest party culture. Iirc, Dickinson also owns an impressive collection of early American documents that are available to students doing primary research. To that end, glad you’re revisiting that one. Proximity to Harrisburg could be beneficial for internships although in reality, most students find it easier to do these during breaks rather than during the school year. We’ve known of a couple of outstanding kids who have gone here and been able to put together a pretty impressive resume for post-grad endeavors. DS had all but HWS on his list, and fwiw, Dickinson was the one that he (and parents) liked best.
Gettysburg definitely punches above its weight in history and is only a bit further from Harrisburg. When we looked at this school, it seemed like a lot of kids found post-grad positions in DC (90 minutes away), so a plus for your D’s interests.
It sounds like she likes HWS already. The Admitted Student days might give you more clarity.
If you would like to consider a short anecdote, I knew a student who fell in love with HWS as a college applicant. However, despite her affinity for HWS, she was influenced by rankings, and her parents and peers, to choose Dickinson. She was not happy at Dickinson and transferred to HWS, at which she found her home. She is now a happy HWS alumna.
It (sorority rush) was never the same at these schools as it was at the southern schools where the girls had coordinated outfits for certain days like you see on YouTube at places like Alabama or GA.
I think anyone can change their mind once at school and Rush. Most kids where the type of clothes they normally wear around campus.
My experience in the last few years is that most national sororities (including the one I belong to and have worked rush for) no longer give a preference to legacies,no longer expect hs kids to send in letters of recommendation from alums, etc. They MAY require a hs transcript as part of the registration for rush (Panhell) would take care of that if there is an organized rush) because some sororities won’t initiate without a certain GPA and others won’t until at least one term of grades in college are in.
Of course even the schools that have changed to t-shirts and sneakers are going to make judgments on other parts of appearance, just like a job interviewer will care if your hair is combed and your personality is what they are looking for.
I’m sure it was an accumulation of a lot of events but it didn’t happen all at once either. I know, for example the ‘dress them all the same’ started at FSU as early as 2013 but probably earlier. The no preference for legacies started for my sorority in 2020 as I learned about it at an outdoor event (covid picnic where we all sat 6 feet apart), and while we were still doing reference letters at that time, I said it was stupid to spend time doing a reference letter if they weren’t going to consider them.
One of the reasons we were given for stopping the preference for legacies was that they wanted everyone to have the same chance of getting into the house and didn’t want it just filled with the same daughters and granddaughters of former members, that college campuses don’t look the same anymore so have the houses represent the campus, not necessarily a grandmother who had gone to Syracuse but a granddaughter at UCLA. There were times even in the 1970s when there were more legacies going through rush than there was room in the house that year; one year Nebraska had a limit of 25 new members per year and for my house there were ~35 legacies participating in rush. As the years went by, more and more kids were legacies of several houses (more women attending colleges, blended families with step mothers, step sisters, etc meaning more legacies).
Was this an easy change? No. There were a lot (tons) of alums who were pretty pissed off that their kids/gkids didn’t get an assist into the house.
This is my exact fear. Gettysburg and Dickinson are ranked higher in every ranking I have seen and I like them, but after initial visits to all three, she likes HWS more. In the end, she has to like the school.
Take law school out of the equation. Where you go is irrelevant - and these four are all strong.
If you can only afford $40K a year, then it comes down to Gettysburg and Dickinson. You can “borrow” or get a summer job for HWS.
But now, how will you pay for law school? Was there not a small public in state that is even less?
I would choose Dickinson of these three. Why?
I would eliminate Hobart for Greek life (and cost). And Gettysburg I believe is more a party school than Dickinson.
I don’t know how you cover law school. For History, I do know G is well known but both will be solid and I’m just thinking Dickinson might fit better socially.
Best of luck.
PS - I get this - that means they have good salespeople. That’s their job. But - once on campus, they are working on next year’s class. It’s nice they treat you great - but this is not a reason to pick a school. You find them #11 on this list (linked below)
When relying on any ranking, it may be helpful to consider the density of the distribution curve. This fairly conventional ranking, for example, placed Gettysburg at the 86th percentile and HWS at the 83rd percentile:
While it’s true, then, that Gettysburg ranked higher than HWS, it’s up to you to decide whether or not the 86th percentile differs significantly from the 83rd percentile.
It goes without say that those minor discrepancies matter not, which is your point Both are great options. Pick whichever you feel is a better fit, if both are affordable.
Since she likes HWS so much, have you contacted their financial aid office? I’m wondering if they would match the other 40K offers from the peer institutions, or at least come closer. It certainly wouldn’t hurt to ask, especially considering they went over your current budget (met by the other two).