Decide between Gettysburg [$40k], Dickinson [$40k], HWS [$44k], and Kenyon [$68k] for History/Pre-law

Did she really like HWS that much or it’s just the admissions/sales team she liked ?

Kids do choose based on that - but those folks are out of student’s lives on campus. It was their job to get them there.

2 Likes

Yeah, that level of difference doesn’t matter as much to me. As discussed in other threads, the rankings vary a lot depending on the source. We spoke with a practicing lawyer by us who owns his own firm and he said that we can’t really go wrong with any of those schools. Just get the best grades she can in the major classes and throughout college and law school, develop a 20 year plan of where she wants to end up.

1 Like

Yes, appeal letter has been written and sent to see if they will make an adjustment to be in line with the other schools.

1 Like

But given what you said her likes are, I don’t see how Hobart fits. Substantive greek life.

Their sales team is good - but they won’t be involved with her day to day.

1 Like

I note per US News, at HWS, 13% of undergraduate men are members of a fraternity, 3% of women are members of a sorority.

The OP states:

I personally would not be concerned about her attending a school where 97% of the women also did not belong to a sorority.

3 Likes

I’ll 3rd party yours with my own 3rd party. If OP is interested, they can ask the school.

If you click on their entry for HWS and go down to Student Activities . . .

They have “Join a fraternity” at 8%, and “Join a sorority” at 1%.

Obviously that does raise the question how it got on that list. Princeton Review claims it is based on “student ratings of the popularity of fraternities and sororities at their schools,” and clicking on the Learn More button specifies, “Based on students’ answers to the survey question, ‘How popular are fraternities/sororities at your school?’" At a guess, maybe the HWS students taking the survey interpreted “popular” to mean “well-regarded”, as opposed to “lots of people actually are members”.

Anyway, I have seen a lot of things like this with Princeton Review’s lists, so I do think it is important to click through to see the actual data.

6 Likes

With only 1 sorority at HWS, we aren’t too worried about it. Washington & Lee University has more Greek life and she was willing to go there if she was admitted. She spoke with people at both schools who were not involved with a sorority and it didn’t scare her away.

6 Likes

Ok. Thx Good luck to her.

1 Like

So, Hobart and William Smith turned out a quick review of our appeal and came back adding another $2k/yr in merit aid. It was a little less than we asked for, but it gets HWS closer to her COA at Dickinson and Gettysburg. We will be visiting HWS and Gettysburg again over the next 2 weeks and make the decision.

5 Likes

Regardless of the ultimate decision, that’s a nice bit of work! Not every day you “make” $8K (well, not me at least).

3 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.