Demarie DeReu

<p>[Student</a> Faces Expulsion for Bringing Gun to School | KULR-8 News, Sports, Weather - Billings, Montana | Local Top Stories](<a href=“http://www.kulr8.com/news/local/Student-Faces-Expulsion-for-Bringing-Gun-to-School-111566419.html]Student”>http://www.kulr8.com/news/local/Student-Faces-Expulsion-for-Bringing-Gun-to-School-111566419.html)</p>

<p>What do you guys think?</p>

<p>You’d expect high school students to have some clue on what to bring and what not to bring to school, but you’d be wrong. This is just sad. Especially coming from a “honors student.”</p>

<p>Never mind…the comments are even worse >_></p>

<p>You have to think, it’s a bit of a different culture in Montana or wherever. Hunting is a very common practice and it’s probably safe to say that several other students had guns (NOT weapons) in their cars at the same time.</p>

<p>IMO a gun is only a weapon if used to harm someone.</p>

<p>She was straightforward and told the admins. They should have had an officer go into her car and get the rifle and confiscate it rather than just expel her. She clearly wasn’t planning on going on a killing spree since she had no ammo for it.</p>

<p>However, she did break the law and regardless of circumstances, the law must be followed. If you make an exception now, everyone will think they are the exception.</p>

<p>She deserves to be expelled for being dumb enough to admit it. We’ve all had a gun/knife/drugs on campus at some point. The smart ones don’t turn themselves in.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>That might be a bit of an overgeneralization</p>

<p>I don’t think she should be punished, after all, she didn’t even plan on using it; it was brought by accident. Discretion should be used in the case and she shouldn’t be punished.</p>

<p>If you break a rule you get punished.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>No. We haven’t.</p>

<p>I think an expulsion is a little too over the top; I’m not a big fan of the zero tolerance policy. Everyone makes mistakes, so what she did was stupid but I’m sure she’s not by any means a stupid person. She was responsible enough to tell authorities. But then again, it is a law… but that’s still kind of harsh.</p>

<p>

Jusssst like we’ve all brought vodka on the school field trip in fifth grade…</p>

<p>

It’s harsh, but school is not place for a weapon.</p>

<p>@HarryJones: I understand what you are saying, but the weapon was unloaded and locked away in her car; away from any human beings. It couldn’t cause harm like that, and the fact that she told the authorities means that she didn’t plan to use it.</p>

<p>No one is saying that she was about to commit any mass murders, but that isn’t the point. If you break a rule, you get punished.</p>

<p>I hate seeing my typos after it’s too late to edit: “is no place” :/</p>

<p>This one kid in my school got expelled for bringing a BB gun to school a few years back. </p>

<p>But I do feel sorry for the girl. Any kind of “zero tolerance” policy is a joke. It asks for simple solutions to difficult problems, and a penalty of “mandatory one year suspension” sure isn’t going to stop a crazed student from bringing firearms for whatever reason. It’s like saying that the penalty for suicide is death.</p>

<p>It’s obvious that the girl didn’t mean any harm, and she was the one who notified the school authorities. Then again, she shouldn’t have panicked and have believed that there is actually a dog that can sniff out firearms. (by “contraband” I’m sure they meant narcotics) </p>

<p>Oh well… it’s up to her, her parents, her lawyers, and the school now.</p>

<p>oh jeez give the girl a break.
she had an unloaded hunting rifle in a box in her trunk.
that school needs to just calm down.</p>